The Volt is a Joke

Correction. It was 28 miles on a CHARGE, instead of the expected 40. BIG difference!!

What does that mean, I have to charge it up every 28 miles???? If this is true I feel this will hurt GM for making such a splash last November, the Japenese are light years ahead of GM regarding electric vehicles. Lutz might take the fall for this.
 
What does that mean, I have to charge it up every 28 miles???? If this is true I feel this will hurt GM for making such a splash last November, the Japenese are light years ahead of GM regarding electric vehicles. Lutz might take the fall for this.

I means that in extreme weather conditions that Lutz drove the car, he received 28 miles on a charge. The expected level in regular driving conditions is about 40 miles. This does not mean the car craps out, it just ran on pure electric for 28 miles (at which point it would have be 30% charge and the generator kicked in).
Since there's no Japanese electric cars on the market, I find it quite amazing that they are light years ahead.
 
The Volt is an EREV – Extended Range Electric Vehicle. For those that don’t know what that is, do a search on previous threads. EREV’s are different than hybrids but they both are limited by the amount of energy that the battery can hold. That’s why they both also rely on a gasoline engine. The technology is still in its infancy and I’m sure it will improve as time goes on.
Hybrids and EREV’s signigicantly improve fuel economy while giving the consumer at least the same utility that a straight gasoline powered car does. The same cannot be said about a pure electric vehicle. That’s why hybrids and EREV’s are the future. Which one is better? Who knows at this point?

What I want to know is what is the fuel economy of the Volt while the gas engine is running? Does anyone know?
 
Electric vehicles are a step, but you have to make clean utility power for it to make sense. Now 100% of Ontario's incremental power comes from coal (some power comes from nuclear, hydro and gas burning, but they all run almost 100%, sometimes that is not enough, then they burn coal). So for now, electric cars in Ontario are coal cars. But once there is enough nuclear power that coal and gas plants are not used, then electric cars will start to make sense.

The other thing they should do is imbed electric wires in 400 series highways, like a slot car. That way the 28 miles just has to get to the highway, then on the highway, the highway power charges your car, and powers it. So you are charged up again by the time you get off the highway. If 400 series, DVP and Gardiner had this, 28 mile range for pure electric would be fine. I don't know how feasible this might be in winter with salt and things.

I don't think you can just convert a battery car to full gas. Unless you keep the whole electric system and just use the gas motor to make electricity. Which would be a lot of weight for the power you would get.
 
What does that mean, I have to charge it up every 28 miles???? If this is true I feel this will hurt GM for making such a splash last November, the Japenese are light years ahead of GM regarding electric vehicles. Lutz might take the fall for this.

Yes.

Or, rather, that after 28 miles (40 miles under normal conditions), the gasoline generator will kick in and charge it for you, if you have not already begun to do so at that point.

This is different from the Japanese Hybrids, which have a gasoline engine to supply power to the drive train when the battery runs low.

In theory, the Volt could get hundreds of miles to the gallon, if you kept plugging it in every 30 miles or so.

And if your other car gets 40 MPG, at $4.00 per gallon, you're paying about $.10 per mile in gasoline. For the Volt, If the electricity costs you (say) $.40 for a full charge to take you 40 miles, you're paying about one tenth as much per mile for your energy. (I don't know, though, how much it would cost for a full charge - assuming it's just a few kWh seems a bit low but the charging circuit probably can't draw too much more than, say, 1500W, or about 9kW for a 6 hour charge, or about $.40 at an overnight rate of 4.4c/kWh).
 
This is a step in the right direction. Of course there'll be some issues with one of the first mass produced electric vehicles. To use the computer as an analogy, remember the Vic 20? Yeah it sucked but it was a starting point for things to come. Not many owned one, but as the technology improved more and more people came online. I can't wait for the day that I never have to again be held hostage by the monopoly that is the oil/gas industry. It's still probably a long way off but it's certainly coming.

Exactly.

The volt is a start. It's the Model T so to speak of electric cars. It's pong, it's a brick cell phone, it's a Commodore Vic 20.

I think that 5 or 10 years ago, the Big 3 were in bed with Big Oil, but not anymore. Big oild fucked over the Big 3 and now it's payback time and payback can be a bitch.
 
I do remember the Vic 20. I used to program video games on them when I was 8. Then there was the PET. Ahh the good old days of break! I used to play that for hours.

But getting back to the original thread, the Volt is a step in the right direction, but if anyone saw Who Killed the Electric Car? knows, is that electric cars predated the gasoline internal combustion engine, and was the first cars on the road. And we have had streetcars and subways and metrorails for many decades, so it's isn't as if we can't design a society around those technologies, or make them financially viable.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_Killed_the_Electric_Car?

The Ev1 designed in 1996 also by GM, 13-14 years ago did 121-240 km on a charge.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_EV1

The movie was really very interesting. The car, ground breaking. The decision to pull it was irresponsible.
 
I don't think you can just convert a battery car to full gas. Unless you keep the whole electric system and just use the gas motor to make electricity. Which would be a lot of weight for the power you would get.


Racers make these front wheel drive cars / rear wheel drive. Is it cheap no, why you see few around. Smog rules are another, Michigan has no safety / smog checks.

I'm just thinking what is going to become of the Volt once its used and cheap. I haven't really seen it either.
 
Racers make these front wheel drive cars / rear wheel drive. Is it cheap no, why you see few around. Smog rules are another, Michigan has no safety / smog checks.

I'm just thinking what is going to become of the Volt once its used and cheap. I haven't really seen it either.

People will not want to convert electric cars in the future.. the only modification they will want to make is installed new and better batteries giving more range/quicker charge times/less weight. Battery technology has made leaps in the last decade, expect far more in the future.
Electric motors are not going to die anywhere near as quickly as a gas engine. I read somewhere that the average electric motor should be good for well beyond a million KM.

Look at the following video of what a guy did in his garage. Imagine what can be done when all the car companies are putting resources into the technology:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BrHXdM9f13k
 
Electric vehicles are a step, but you have to make clean utility power for it to make sense. Now 100% of Ontario's incremental power comes from coal (some power comes from nuclear, hydro and gas burning, but they all run almost 100%, sometimes that is not enough, then they burn coal). So for now, electric cars in Ontario are coal cars. But once there is enough nuclear power that coal and gas plants are not used, then electric cars will start to make sense.

First, the 100% coal statement doesn't make any sense. Sure, coal burning plants do run all the time as the generators need to spin, but regardless of the energy being consumed or not, it's spinning.. why not use that energy rather than waste it? Plus, only a small portion of Ontarios electricity comes from coal.
And even if 100% of it actually did, it would still be cleaner to have an electric car society than millions of gas ones. It's much easier to clean/regulate one tail pipe than millions.

The other thing they should do is imbed electric wires in 400 series highways, like a slot car. That way the 28 miles just has to get to the highway, then on the highway, the highway power charges your car, and powers it. So you are charged up again by the time you get off the highway. If 400 series, DVP and Gardiner had this, 28 mile range for pure electric would be fine. I don't know how feasible this might be in winter with salt and things.

That's not even remotely practical. Put aside the enourmous costs and the dangers, there's all sort of other obsticles like bridges.
 
Recall how some people believe living near high voltage power lines can cause cancer and other ills, studies say not but still some believe it. Even headaches.

I do recall some saying driving electric cars might do the same thing. All the current is going to be flowing around near your body.
Has any long term health studies been done, nope.The first people to buy these cars will be the guinea pigs.

As for long term the motors might last but the battery packs do not last even 10 years. They cost over 1,000 to replace. Wires go bad too over time.

We will see over time what happens, I have many doubts and after hearing the 28 mpg number my doubts just grew (which GM claims, might be even less, that dude is like 73 years old and it wasn't even winter yet)

Oh my 18 year old car can sit unused outside in the cold for days and start and run just fine. People really believe a 18 year old Volt car will do the same, we will see.
 
At the turn of the century, cities were overwhelmed by horse manure. Horses would also develop problems and have to be shot on the spot, the carcass sometimes blocking traffic for hours before it could be hauled away. The stench was awful on hot days, on rainy days it would wash down to the rivers and lakes.
New horseless carriages came along and were laughed at for their problems, but they improved with time.

So let's wait and see if they work the kinks out of these new cars, we can go on with the current technology very well but we're going to run out of oil one day in the future. It's unsustainable, just like with the horses.
BTW, horse manure now actually has value today, people will gladly take it off your hands.
 
SC Joe,

Not many people keep cars for that length of time these days so even if they didn't last, it wouldn't be a big issue for most people. An electric motor essentially has one moving part, a gas engine has many.. far less likely to break down.
I understand your concerns, but you can carve this in stone. Electric cars are the future. The peak of oil guarantees it.
 
Again GM is applying the wrong technology. Electricity is the way to go but they should be using the super capacitors rather than batteries. Check out the Zen vehicles which uses super capacitors (Wikipidia). They have a much higher power density (power per unit weight) than batteries and can fully charge in 15 - 20 minutes.
 
A straight electric car was never a viable solution because an electric battery could never store enough energy to make an electric car competitive to a gasoline car.
The solution is some sort of gasoline/electric combination such as a hybrid or an EREV like the Volt. This is not a final solution but an interim one until something better comes along. The problem with these cars is that they still burn gasoline, although they burn much less, they still burn it.

We must stop our dependency on gasoline, particularly the kind that comes from the ME.
 
First, the 100% coal statement doesn't make any sense. Sure, coal burning plants do run all the time as the generators need to spin, but regardless of the energy being consumed or not, it's spinning.. why not use that energy rather than waste it? Plus, only a small portion of Ontarios electricity comes from coal.
And even if 100% of it actually did, it would still be cleaner to have an electric car society than millions of gas ones. It's much easier to clean/regulate one tail pipe than millions.
.

I said 100% of Ontario's incremental energy is coal, which it pretty much is. Incremental means the extra energy needed if people consume more power, such as if they switch from gas cars to electric, charged from the grid. The gas, hydro and nuclear generators already operate at capacity, when they need even more power, they run the coal plants, but as little as possible. So if demand increases, that means 100% of it is filled with coal power, no more hydro-electric or nuclear capacity is available. Not until all the coal plants are permanently closed will the incremental power come from anything else.

That's not even remotely practical. Put aside the enourmous costs and the dangers, there's all sort of other obsticles like bridges.

Would the cost be that high? Compared to the cost of gasoline? Imbedding wires in the 407 would not cost as much as building it did, it would pay for itself quickly in the gas savings. Gas costs about $0.10 per km, comparable to the cost of the 407, doesn't it? So if the 407 cost double, but you did not have to pay for gas to use it, it would be worthwhile.

Would it be dangerous? If you get out of your car in the driving lane of the 407 now, you will be killed anyway, I don't see electrifying it changed that. And there are no pedestrians crossing now. It would not be all roads, just grade separated, access controll highways. That is all you need, the batteries would handle the local driving.

Why would a bridge be an obstacle? It is not like a streetcar with a live connection and no battery, you can have all kinds of gaps in the service, and the car just runs on the battery then. But highways are grade separated anyway, so the supply could be continuous.
 
I said 100% of Ontario's incremental energy is coal, which it pretty much is. Incremental means the extra energy needed if people consume more power, such as if they switch from gas cars to electric, charged from the grid. The gas, hydro and nuclear generators already operate at capacity, when they need even more power, they run the coal plants, but as little as possible. So if demand increases, that means 100% of it is filled with coal power, no more hydro-electric or nuclear capacity is available. Not until all the coal plants are permanently closed will the incremental power come from anything else.

There's a great mis-conception about how the grid system works and the media hysteria we get in the summer about not enough available electricity. What the media doesn't tell you that those problem times pretty much refer to two very specific points of the day. Around 9am and around 1pm. The rest of the day, there's generally enough capacity to cover what's required. This fluctuates throughout the year as air conditioners make demands higher in the summer. With proper energy saving measures and perhaps allowing companies and individuals to add to the grid with solar/wind power the capacity "problem" will more or less go away. The reality with regards to cars is that MOST people will charge them at night, where there is absolutely HEAPS and HEAPS of available electricity which is currently wasted. Clean electricity. Ontario could sustain and large electric vehicle fleet today, with no negative impact. Once there is a really large fleet of electric cars on the road, then possibly because of people charing during the daytime it will become a problem. But that is so far in the future that we should hopefully have solutions at that time.

Would the cost be that high? Compared to the cost of gasoline? Imbedding wires in the 407 would not cost as much as building it did, it would pay for itself quickly in the gas savings. Gas costs about $0.10 per km, comparable to the cost of the 407, doesn't it? So if the 407 cost double, but you did not have to pay for gas to use it, it would be worthwhile.

Would it be dangerous? If you get out of your car in the driving lane of the 407 now, you will be killed anyway, I don't see electrifying it changed that. And there are no pedestrians crossing now. It would not be all roads, just grade separated, access controll highways. That is all you need, the batteries would handle the local driving.

Why would a bridge be an obstacle? It is not like a streetcar with a live connection and no battery, you can have all kinds of gaps in the service, and the car just runs on the battery then. But highways are grade separated anyway, so the supply could be continuous.

Gasoling is paid for by inviduals.. these installations would be likely paid for by the tax payer (nobody will buy a car that's only useable on a single toll road) consider how much is spent now on maintaining roads.. multiply that by a few times.
I initially thought you were talking about having wires above, like streetcars.. I never considered embedding.. I can't see it being practical myself.. would it even be possible? I don't know.. the one thing you can be sure it, it would cost a damn fortune to install and people would have to buy the cars to work on it.. I can't see either of those happening personally..