The truth behind wine tasting

Sniffing a cork is mainly to check for mould. So on most commercial wines it is useless. On some old ones sure but you can usually see it anyway. If they wave it around....that's a haha.
If a wine has turned some people can smell ahead of time with a quick glass swirl and sniff. Personally when I test a wine its quick swirl, sniff, taste and yep that's fine. But I don't make a production out of it.
And yes I will spend money on a good wine, although as a rule if I'm out fine dining with my spouse I let the chef pairings usually be the choice with any meal. They already matched it nicely for me,and I don't have to buy a bottle then either.

Agreed, on all point.

One of the most amazing tastings I attended was after my last trip to South Africa, a large basis for the invite, and there were a number of wines to sample and compare. The real surprise was that one of the wines that rated high, but didn't triumph was a boxed wine. We all were surprised and went away with a different sense of what right or wrong. Much like the resurgence of screw caps. Quality cork is at a real premium now and many top line wineries are using the technique to top their bottles.
 
I know someone who won't drink wines from Ontario.
I remember them telling me all about Chilean wines

I bought a bottle of wine from Chile. Used it to cook.
Filled it with a $20 Pinot Noir/Shiraz from Ontario and
put the cork back in.

The only draw back was all through dinner I had to listen
to how good Chilean wine is.

If you like it drink it.
 
I know someone who won't drink wines from Ontario.
I remember them telling me all about Chilean wines

I bought a bottle of wine from Chile. Used it to cook.
Filled it with a $20 Pinot Noir/Shiraz from Ontario and
put the cork back in.

The only draw back was all through dinner I had to listen
to how good Chilean wine is.

If you like it drink it.

I agree, I have been with pretentious people particularly scotch and wine drinkers, who use certain "labels " to boast their self-esteem or hide their insecurities. I too saw a bait and switch with J&B scotch in an expensive single malt bottle for a superficial person who made a fool of themselves before and after drinking it. I had experience recently with a lady who suddenly informed me that she couldn't take chardonnay hated the taste and avoided it for years. I then informed her that her favorite was Pouille Fuisse which is a chardonnay and her face turned a burgundy colour. She was an airhead but a good fuck.
 
A crying waiter... never heard of that before!

Were these tears of joy or tears of anguish? :biggrin1:

Perry

Oh man...I used to laugh watching when my female counterparts would lose it on the floor and burst into tears. Fontunately I never took it so seriously usually. I did however have to repair two holes I put into walls in my time.
Such a simple job in theory.....yet so many have a shelf life.
 
So true

I know someone who won't drink wines from Ontario.
I remember them telling me all about Chilean wines

I bought a bottle of wine from Chile. Used it to cook.
Filled it with a $20 Pinot Noir/Shiraz from Ontario and
put the cork back in.

The only draw back was all through dinner I had to listen
to how good Chilean wine is.

If you like it drink it.

Bin there, done that, really surprising how a label can instantly change a wine !!!

FAST
 
As a species there was probably a time thousands of years ago that our sense of smell would have been honed enough to distinguish between good and bad types of wine. Unfortunately we were likely more interested in sniffing the asshole of other people.

It is fun to mess with so called wine experts though...
 
let's face it, my dog has a 100 times better developed olefactory sense than you or any so-called wine expert! Deal with it!

Nothing to deal with here.

Sniffing a cork would be a waste of time to me because I probably wouldn't smell the difference, but it is not a bad idea to see the condition of the cork to get a sense. The oldest wine I've tasted, a Madeira, was almost 100 years old at the time and it was an amazing treat, even though most Madeira aren't my favourite . No other similar wine comes even close.