The Trinity and Christian Doctrine

canada-man

Well-known member
Jun 16, 2007
33,846
3,777
113
Toronto, Ontario
canadianmale.wordpress.com
1 John chapter 5 verse 7-8





the footnote in the NIV bible i have says

a7,8 Late manuscripts of the Vulgate testify in heaven: The father, the word and the holy spirit. and these three are one. 8 And there are three that testify on earth (not found in any Greek manuscript before the sixteenth century)
 
You want to discuss one of the most complex points of Christian Theology on TERB?!


what's there to discuss?

a7,8 Late manuscripts of the Vulgate testify in heaven: The father, the word and the holy spirit. and these three are one. 8 And there are three that testify on earth (not found in any Greek manuscript before the sixteenth century)

this footnote proves that verse does not appear in early copies

Mark 16

http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=mARK 16&version=NIV

[The earliest manuscripts and some other ancient witnesses do not have verses 9–20.]
 
what's there to discuss?

a7,8 Late manuscripts of the Vulgate testify in heaven: The father, the word and the holy spirit. and these three are one. 8 And there are three that testify on earth (not found in any Greek manuscript before the sixteenth century)

this footnote proves that verse does not appear in early copies

Mark 16

http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=mARK 16&version=NIV

[The earliest manuscripts and some other ancient witnesses do not have verses 9–20.]

See?
 
This is the fundamental misunderstanding on which the Christian Church, (but not Christianity), is based:

"The father, the word and the holy spirit. and these three are one."

Yes, they are one, and all three are the emotion of love.

John 1:1

"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God."

1 John 4:8

"He that loveth not knoweth not God; for God is love."

Christianity was supposed to be a redefinition of the meaning of what God is, changing Him from the old man in a robe that smites people who piss him off, to the emotion of love. So, effectively, Jesus was a love child, conceived by two people in love, rather than two people in an arranged marriage who may or may not have had romantic feelings for each other. That's why there was no room in the Inn, when he was born; inn keepers didn't rent rooms to unmarried couples, as is still the case in some backwater towns. Jesus was just a man, with some good ideas.

Unfortunately, much of his message was perverted, when the decision was made to deify him. He was never meant to be worshiped. He was meant to be emulated.
 
does it mentioned that the gospels weren't written by eyewitnesses?

does it interview bible scholars like Bart Erhman whose research shows that the NT that we have today is not the same and have parts removed, edietd and insert later than the alleged events of Jesus?
 
does it mentioned that the gospels weren't written by eyewitnesses?

does it interview bible scholars like Bart Erhman whose research shows that the NT that we have today is not the same and have parts removed, edietd and insert later than the alleged events of Jesus?

So what, no one is claiming otherwise. There were a number of gospels which were written and not included in the standard scriptures. This is not a secret. In a culture where an oral history tradition is a strong part of daily life, this is not a surprise or a crime.
 
C-M click the link the entire series is there for you to watch.

By the way the first trailer answers your question right in the trailer!
 
So what, no one is claiming otherwise. There were a number of gospels which were written and not included in the standard scriptures. This is not a secret. In a culture where an oral history tradition is a strong part of daily life, this is not a surprise or a crime.
Perhaps in the environment in which C-M grew up this really is something that wasn't talked about, and he thinks Adult mainstream Christians in Canada, Australia, the U.S.A., the U.K., New Zealand don't know it and that it is shocking and faith destroying.

However, good grief it would be quite hard to be around a congregation in these parts for a few years without running into a Christian Education Program which discussed it all in great depth.
 
what's there to discuss?

a7,8 Late manuscripts of the Vulgate testify in heaven: The father, the word and the holy spirit. and these three are one. 8 And there are three that testify on earth (not found in any Greek manuscript before the sixteenth century)

this footnote proves that verse does not appear in early copies

Mark 16

http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=mARK 16&version=NIV

[The earliest manuscripts and some other ancient witnesses do not have verses 9–20.]

So a footnote on one passage settles the whole issue. Wow that was easy.

Now answer this question.

Are there any other NT passages that are used in support of a trinitarian argument? Or just the one?

Tell us again how gnostics, despite writing an entire book of quotes from Jesus claimed he didn't exist.

You do know the amount of lies you have told on this subject has left you with no credibility don't you?

Have you read any of Ehrman's book or enjoyed any of his courses? Or do you simply quote selectively to support your hatred? Having seen you do this before to his work (well not actually quote, rather cut and paste from anti-christian websites), I know you don't treat his work, or any other scholar's with any honesty.

Call back when you have finished reading "A Marginal Jew." It is kind of seminal in the field.
 
So a footnote on one passage settles the whole issue. Wow that was easy.

Now answer this question.

Are there any other NT passages that are used in support of a trinitarian argument? Or just the one?

Tell us again how gnostics, despite writing an entire book of quotes from Jesus claimed he didn't exist.

You do know the amount of lies you have told on this subject has left you with no credibility don't you?

Have you read any of Ehrman's book or enjoyed any of his courses? Or do you simply quote selectively to support your hatred? Having seen you do this before to his work (well not actually quote, rather cut and paste from anti-christian websites), I know you don't treat his work, or any other scholar's with any honesty.

Call back when you have finished reading "A Marginal Jew." It is kind of seminal in the field.


RDL why don't you read Bart Erhman and other bible scholars instead of calling me a liar?
 
RDL why don't you read Bart Erhman and other bible scholars instead of calling me a liar?

He clearly has read more of the scholarly works than you have, as shown by your constant flow of C&Ps post, many if not most of which face plant is short order after examination, and very few posts in your own words which crash and burn in short order..
 
RDL why don't you read Bart Erhman and other bible scholars instead of calling me a liar?

Because I have read most of his books, listened to almost all of his courses commercially available, and know you are a liar.

Why don't you answer any of the questions I pose?
 
Because I have read most of his books, listened to almost all of his courses commercially available, and know you are a liar.

Why don't you answer any of the questions I pose?

in previous posts and threads you still call me a liar after i provided evidence


Bart Erhman called the new testament a forgery you would know this if you listen to all of his courses as you claim



and isn't it freakish that everytime rdl show up to oppose me blackrock13 magically shows up and vice a versa


wonder twin powers ACTIVATE!
 
in previous posts and threads you still call me a liar after i provided evidence


Bart Erhman called the new testament a forgery you would know this if you listen to all of his courses as you claim



and isn't it freakish that everytime rdl show up to oppose me blackrock13 magically shows up and vice a versa


wonder twin powers ACTIVATE!

You have provided plenty of evidence of lying. Like saying gnostics denied this historic jesus. A flat out lie, that anyone who understood the first thing about gnosticism would spot a mile away. You are a liar and a poor one.

I have read the materials you think I should read. Have you read Ehrman's books or taken any of his courses?

Why do you not have the courage to answer any questions on this subject. All you do is cut an paste crap from shit sources and then run away. You may as well be a stormfront poster.
 
in previous posts and threads you still call me a liar after i provided evidence


Bart Erhman called the new testament a forgery you would know this if you listen to all of his courses as you claim



and isn't it freakish that everytime rdl show up to oppose me blackrock13 magically shows up and vice a versa


wonder twin powers ACTIVATE
!

I hope Aartie doesn't feel left out again.

You aren't well enough read on the subject, but you try to appear like you are, limiting most of your reading to blogs and websites that support you rain puddle like position, and regularly offering up books you clearly haven't read, giving phoney opinions on them that clearly aren't yours, hoping others won't notice.