Here is a letter in the Toronto Star that confirms my thoughts on the verdict i.e. the jury could not agree on a murder or attempted murder so negotiated a guilty on something verdict.
This letter writer does a good job of explaining it
The jury made the best of an impossible situation. They knew they couldn’t let Const. Forcillo get away scot-free after killing Yatim, but they also didn’t have the courage to convict a cop of murder. The “cops are tops” mentality is still too pervasive for that.
To me the verdict demonstrated the wisdom of Solomon. It was savvy and wise. When it was announced, the relief on the streets of Toronto was palpable. Not perfect, but some justice was meted out.
When I saw once more the famous picture of the doomed youth in the empty streetcar on the Star’s front page, I thought again of Crocodile Dundee’s line from the Hollywood movie, “that’s not a knife; this is a knife.” Yatim should not have died. Cops are not 007s. They don’t – or shouldn’t – have a licence to kill.
Police spokespeople have publicly worried that the verdict will “send a chill through the force.” But if a chill is what it takes to soothe the itchy trigger fingers of cops like Forcillo, then it’s exactly what we need. These men and women are given public permission to patrol our streets armed with increasingly deadly force. It’s time they understood that public scrutiny is part of that privilege – scrutiny that will become a bit uncomfortable now and then. Or are we supposed to look the other way when a citizen is killed?
As your editorial notes, the verdict will be small comfort to the Yatim family, but at least it’s something. And the Star deserves credit for its excellent series on police abuse and accountability in the GTA, “Breaking badge.” I believe that it has helped to shift our outdated attitudes towards the police.
http://www.thestar.com/opinion/letters_to_the_editors/2016/01/30/the-forcillo-verdict.html