The Pope
001 said:
It's a sad day for the world.
Is it? Please read On
Karol Wojtyla was not the greatest pope of the 20th century but he was certainly the most contradictory .
Outwardly, he called for conversion, reform and dialogue with the rest of the world. But this was sharply contradicted by his internal policy, which was oriented toward the restoration of the pre-Second Vatican Council status quo, obstructing reform, denying dialogue within the church and absolute Roman dominance.
While expressly acknowledging the positive sides of this pontificate, which, incidentally, have received plenty of official emphasis, I would like to focus on the nine most glaring contradictions of Pope John Paul II.
Human rights John Paul II supported human rights while withholding them from bishops, theologians and women. The Vatican has yet to sign the European Council's Declaration of Human Rights: far too many canons of the absolutist Roman church law of the Middle Ages would have to be amended first.
The concept of separation of powers, the bedrock of all modern legal practice, is unknown in the Roman Catholic church. Due process is an alien entity, as well. In disputes, one and the same Vatican agency functions as lawmaker, prosecutor and judge.
Consequences: A servile episcopate and intolerable legal conditions. Any pastor, theologian or layperson who enters into a legal dispute with the higher church courts has virtually no prospects of prevailing.
The role of women The great worshipper of the Virgin Mary preached a noble concept of womanhood but at the same time forbade women from practising birth control and barred them from ordination.
Consequences: There is a rift between external conformism and internal autonomy of conscience. This results in bishops who lean towards Rome, thus alienating themselves from women, as was the case in the dispute surrounding the issue of abortion counselling (in 1999, the Pope ordered German bishops to close centres that issued certificates to women that could later be used to get an abortion). This in turn has led to a growing exodus among those women who have so far remained faithful to the church.
Sexual morals John Paul II preached against mass poverty and suffering in the world but made himself partially responsible for this suffering as a result of his attitudes toward birth control and explosive population growth. During his many trips and in a speech to the 1994 United Nations Conference on Population and Development in Cairo, he declared his opposition to the pill and condoms. As a result, this long-reigning Pope, more than any other statesman, can be held partly responsible for uncontrolled population growth in some countries and the spread of AIDS in Africa.
Consequences: Even in traditionally Catholic countries like Ireland, Spain and Portugal, the Roman Catholic Church's rigorous sexual morals are openly or tacitly rejected.
Celibacy By propagating the traditional image of the celibate male priest, Karol Wojtyla bears the principal responsibility for the catastrophic dearth of priests, the collapse of spiritual welfare in many countries and the many pedophilia scandals the church is no longer able to cover up. Marriage is still forbidden to men who have agreed to devote their lives to the priesthood. This is only one example of how this Pope, like others before him, ignored the teachings of the Bible and the great Catholic tradition of the first millennium, which did not require office bearers to take a vow of celibacy.
Consequences: The ranks have been thinned and there is a lack of new blood in the Catholic church. Soon almost two-thirds of parishes, both in German-speaking countries and elsewhere, will be without an ordained pastor and regular celebrations of the Eucharist.
Ecumenical movement John Paul II liked to be seen as a spokesman for the ecumenical movement. At the same time, however, he weighed heavily on the Vatican's relations with orthodox and reform churches and refused to recognize their ecclesiastical offices and Communion services.
"taken from Der Speigel"