'The Pacific' a noble failure?

Seriously? WTF is wrong with you guys?

War is a fucking disaster. If you wanted a nice war story, watch Lord of the Rings with it's nice Hollywood ending. Real war (not that I've ever been there, but after studying it as long as I have I think I have the gist of it) is a fucking nightmare. No storyline, fucked up, absolute fucking horror.

The Pacific has levels of realism that I've not seen elsewhere. It shows the "good guys" as real guys, i.e. as humans in war being turned into demons by the circumstances they find themselves in.

As for Europe, the war was won on the Eastern Front in the titanic battles between the USSR and Nazi Germany where some 30+ million people died.


It's downright pathetic how people (even Terbies) can't handle the sanitized version of the war we're presented with here because of "weak character development" and graphic violence and an inability to bond with the characters. I suppose they are telling a tale (they being the producers), but maybe they are trying to tell us something else. War is hell. This is what it looks like.
 
WSO: blow me. NO one here is commenting on the accuracy or asking for a typical hollywood war movie. We're comparing the method the producers used to tell the story of these characters and their exploits in the pacific and comparing that to the story telling of Band of Brothers.

Maybe if you read the thread you'd have gotten that.
 
Might actually be better to suspend your humanity for the duration. Do what you have to do. Get it done and then return to normalcy.

This sounds just like the arguement(s) the Nazis had once WWII ended. The committed atrocities because they were simply 'following orders' & were caught up in the war. Shameful.
 
I recently sat down with a WWII vet who fought in the south Pacific. He mentionned he rarely talked about the war & still had nightmares about it today. He added that most of the stuff we've been seeing in movies & on tv was still nothing compared to the real thing. He was a member of the spec OPS and still holds a grudge against the Japanese. Same with the Russians & the Germans. He did say that the Japanese were the most brutal of them all. He saw soldiers get tortured by them with his own eyes. One technique was to put a rat inside a bag & tie that bag on a soldier's head. He said he also saw & heard about more brutal things the Japanese (he referred to them as 'Japs') did to POW's, but didn't want to talk about them since it still affected him deeply. He did confirm when asked if the part of castrating American soldiers tied up to a tree & then stuffing their mouths with their sex organs was true, and he confirmed it, but adding he had never seen it done with his own eyes. I must admit that this was one of the most interesting conversations i had ever had in years, maybe ever.
 
This sounds just like the arguement(s) the Nazis had once WWII ended. The committed atrocities because they were simply 'following orders' & were caught up in the war. Shameful.

Actually, it is what the Russians said about getting rid of the Nazis from their homeland. Don't believe me? Just ask any Russian survivor from the Great Patriotic War.
 
The atrocities committed by the japanese are well documented and it is said because they felt that any soldier caught alive was not even "human" any longer. Which is why so many fought to the death even when it was futile.

There were also eyewitness accounts of soldiers being herded into underground bunkers then a barrel of gasoline lit and rolled in.
 
I gave up on "The Pacific" after the 2nd or 3rd episode. IMO it simply did not hold up to comparisons with BofB. My SO is (hopefully) recording it, as I'd like to watch it in its entirety sometime (but won't spend the money to buy the inevitable box-set). For me, the series can still be salvageble if they make even a passing reference to Pfc Lee getting shot in the ass at Saipan....I think that would be a hoot!!
One day a few years back, after a few too many beers with the neighbours at a block party, I took a few guys into our basement and popped in an old video.......footage from the Battle of Vukovar circa 1991 and a few other places in eastern Slavonia, Croatia. These were actual videos from the Croats which some Serb got hold of, and some actual videos from the Serb side, which all eventually found their way into my possession, reformatted, and into my VCR for my newfound buddies' viewing pleasure. The consensus from these guys on watching actual combat footage was that it seemed fake......they've watched soooo many "realistic" interpretations from "Saving Pvt Ryan", "BofB", "BlackHawk Down", etc etc, with its Dolby sound and cinemascope imagery, that the real thing didn't look what they'd come to believe it should look like. I found that very interesting, and shortly thereafter, the neighbours started ignoring me even more than they did before. Luckily, we've moved away since then.
Now, no matter how many times I watch some actress pretending to give birth, or even watch an actual birth, being a dude (and, might I add, a quite dudely dude at that!) there's just no way that I'll ever be able to really grasp the experience of giving birth. And that's the same with war.....it's just such an absolutely foreign & intense experience, that unless you've actually been through it you'll just never understand really how it is. And that's a good thing, so be thankful for that. When any of those old WW2 vets , or vets of a more recent vintage, show them some gratitude for what they've done so that you wouldn't have to.
So, what's my point? None! There's no point here, I'm like Oblio and just keeping in touch!

Rant over for the day, time to go & earn my pay!! (perhaps, as a rapper!)
 
Okay, 1 more post, but then that's it!!

HBO’s 'Pacific': Someone please flush!

Posted By Thomas E. Ricks
091022_meta_block.gif
Friday, March 26, 2010 - 11:18 AM


Here is a guest review by Eric Hammel, author of a boatload of military histories, including well-known books about the battles of Chosin Reservoir, Hue City, Khe Sanh and Beirut.




Not only does he specialize in Marine Corps history, he has written more books about World War II in the Pacific than many military history buffs have read, including these titles:
By Eric Hammel
Best Defense guest TV reviewer
Tom Hanks is an accredited war history buff, and I think he really has put his heart into paying homage to WWII vets. His heart's in the right place, but his head is in Hollywood.
Why should I be surprised a "docudrama" like The Pacific is shit? The whole effort behind the docu part is invested in toys such as gunner's gloves. I long ago boycotted documentary filmmakers who want my brand to legitimize their sorry little TV vignettes. Their objective is entertainment centered on the dramatic visual, not the intellectual, and not quite the historical. If self-professed documentarians can't get it right because they edit the talking heads to accommodate their thin film libraries, why should self-professed entertainers make a better effort, show greater concern?
Has anyone else noticed that the talking heads -- nameless, unexplained vets -- in The Pacific seem to be reading from scripts rather than dipping into memories? They merely mouth error-filled platitudes. Band of Brothers used interesting people with interesting observations. This is the worst way to exploit vets -- making them look like idiots.
It is difficult to frame this story using this set of icons. But the people behind The Pacific volunteered for this. This is their befouled vision, perhaps with the aid of a few bought historians who were probably ignored when the script -- a visual outline -- was fabricated from its many disparate parts. Their good intentions ran afoul bad toilet training; they left the seat up and neglected to flush.
It all comes down to adults making bad, ill-informed, drama-driven decisions that end up befogging the teachable events in bullshit that must be the knee-jerk impulses of people trained to do what they do.
Was there not a reasonable effort made to understand that selecting relatively rare machine gunners as focus for two out of two visually entangled storylines would confuse rather than enlighten? Why is the basic philosophy of The Pacific romance while the hallmark and touchstone of Band of Brothers is true grit? Does anyone ever say "No!" to Spielberg?
Waiting to see if Part 3, etc. are better overlooks that the series was filmed and edited as a whole. I doubt it, because it's not like a regular TV series, where the third episode is being filmed the same week the first is shown, as scripts for episodes four and five are being tweaked. This mess was conceived, edited, and market-tested as a single unit long before Part 1 appeared. So it can't get much better. There's no way to change to a course that's backed by anything better than the bad decisions we've already seen manifested in Parts 1 and 2.
These people got hung up on knick-knacks and drama, but they sacrificed the history and clarity they implicitly promised by advertising it off Band of Brothers. That's a dishonest coattails strategy that dishonors the memory of all who were there.
​
 
This sounds just like the arguement(s) the Nazis had once WWII ended. The committed atrocities because they were simply 'following orders' & were caught up in the war. Shameful.

How is that differerent from every war since. Victors write teh histroy books. Atrocities were committed on a large scale by both sides.
 
Over all I've enjoyed the series. Considering that each episode opens with comments from the veterans that actually fought the battles and framed the general plot, I don't think it is a complete white wash. Certainly better than the John Wayne version.

I don't like the non-battle episodes - like shore leave in Australia, but I did feel like I was in the battle - similar to the beach scene in Saving Private Ryan. I don't mind the characters changing and dying early as I figure that was more in tune with what was happening. You would bond with you buddies and your friends and then in an instant - they were gone.
 
Over all I've enjoyed the series. Considering that each episode opens with comments from the veterans that actually fought the battles and framed the general plot, I don't think it is a complete white wash. Certainly better than the John Wayne version.

I don't like the non-battle episodes - like shore leave in Australia, but I did feel like I was in the battle - similar to the beach scene in Saving Private Ryan. I don't mind the characters changing and dying early as I figure that was more in tune with what was happening. You would bond with you buddies and your friends and then in an instant - they were gone.

I actually didn't mind the background stories of the soldiers leave in Austrailia. Gives a good perception of how their lives were while fighting, and how they were treated on leave. I was a little ashamed when they were loaded into cots stacked up in the stands of a stadium. I mean really they couldn't find them a barracks somewhere? I mean hell, even a tent would be better. (not like I'm against sleeping outside or anything).

I'm glad to see that the leaders realized that these guys are risking their lives for their country and should be taken care of whenever possible. Now I think they've gone a little overboard in Iraq (paying for meals they don't even eat via Haliburton) but they're a hell of a lot better off than they were during WWII.

Like the scene in B of B where they were sent to bastogne without cold winter uniforms. Then they arrived with spring. You'd think the planners supply chain would get at least that much right. Same as going into battle with ONE round for their rifle? Jesus.

Same as sending them into battle without clean drinking water.
 
How is that differerent from every war since. Victors write teh histroy books. Atrocities were committed on a large scale by both sides.

Usually, the first atrocities are commited by the "bad guys". Hence, they will be called the "bad guys". Then we hope that our guys can be just as bad or badder so we can kick the bad guy's ass and not end up as fried ashes in his gas chambers. War is a brutal business. If you no like, then throw up your hands and surrender like the French and the Danes.
 
Not even close to BoB.
BoB was a 10/10, Pacific is almost a documentary. 5/10 at best.
2010's biggest disappointment so far for me.
I was so looking forward to Pacific and Spartacus this year.
Spartacus lived up to the hype and then some.
IMHO, Pacific has been a dismal failure.
 
Excellent comments

I found 'The Pacific' interesting to watch but in the same way you watch two Eastwood westerns. 'Good, Bad & Ugly' and 'Unforgiven' are both great but very distinctive films. That might be the best allegory I can present with 'The Pacific' and 'Band of Brothers'.

However, I cannot accept the US Marine Corps as the gang of admitted murderers of women & children in 'Unforgiven'.

Perhaps more important, as a piece of quality cinema, 'Unforgiven' is far superior.
 
I just finished reading "Helmet for my Pillow" by Robert Leckie, and "With the Old Breed" by E.B.Sledge, the two primary books on which Pacific is based. I had read many first-person accounts of the war in the Pacific previously, but none in the last 30 years. I enjoyed both books, to me, they were a lot more realistic and intense than the series was. I was also surprised by how much in the series about Leckie and Sledge was not from the books. Either they had a lot of other source about the same guys, or else they made a lot of stuff up. Overall, I found both highly worth reading.
 
Well I just finished the series and I thought they did a great job. Instead of trying to top BoB, they put a different face on the Pacific theatre with the marines there. They told stories that were much more three dimensional and showed more pain and dissappointment than they did with BoB. Like when Lucky begs to be returned to his unit after his hospital stay and comes back without his edge and winds up getting wounded. Or how Sledgehammer comes home to no fanfare because all the parades are over without having been laid once during the whole war. Or even how Snafu talks Sledge out of harvesting the gold teeth out of the dead soldiers.

I am glad they didn't try to take the character arcs in the same direction as BoB, I thought they did a great job and created something with a whole other flavor.
 
If you want to read an excellent historical record of the war in the Pacific, read The Rising Sun - The Decline and Fall of the Japanese Empire 1936-1945. It's over 800 pages but it's a fascinating and comprehensive account of the war. While I already knew most of the major battle stuff, the internal political in-fighting amongst the Japanese (especially the Army vs. Navy and the military vs. political/Emperor) was very revealing. It was fascinating to read how intensive the efforts were from Japan to avoid war and how a series of apparently mundane events triggered the war.

For example, the differences in culture between Japan and the US led to mistrust and errors in judgement. And something as simple as translating the message wrong had dramatic repercussions. Or that Japan never intended Pearl Harbor to be a sneak attack; they wanted to first break off peace negotiations (though not formally declare war).

When America cut off oil exports to the US, the intention was to force Japan to the bargaining table. In fact, it hastened the onset of war because it started the clock ticking on when Japan would run out of oil and forced them to attack sooner rather than later (which had implications for the peace negotiations).

Hearing about how thorough the Japanese had scouted out Pearl Harbor was also quite a revelation. They had spies who were providing details of the American naval presence as late as a couple days before the attack.

It was also interesting to read how proficient and successful Japan was at waging war for the first couple years (especially in naval battles, where they licked the Americans several times; night battles were their specialty), after which the tide turned and it quickly became a slaughter. It was definitely a very different war than the war in Europe where the Germans fought on effectively to the very end of the war whereas the Japanese were basically resorting to suicide attacks as early as 1942 and continuously from 1944 on.

Finally, it was a revelation to find out the Japanese Imperial Army was only ~2.5 million men. In Europe, the German Wehrmacht was over 18 million. So the scale of the battles was definitely very different. Much smaller actions, especially due to the limitations of naval transport.

A very good read!

http://www.amazon.ca/Rising-Sun-Dec...r_1_10?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1276347761&sr=8-10
 
Tom Ricks is a well-respected US journalist, writing mainly on military & political subjects:

Who was the tougher World War II enemy, the Germans or the Japanese?

Posted By Thomas E. Ricks
091022_meta_block.gif
Wednesday, June 9, 2010 - 10:55 AM

Yesterday I was reading the transcript of comments Gen. J. Lawton Collins made at Fort Leavenworth in 1983. "Lighning Joe" Collins was one of the few generals to fight in both the Pacific and the European theaters in World War II, and to my knowledge, the only one successful in both. (Generals Eugene Landrum and Charles Corlett, not so much.) So I was interested to see Collins conclude that the Germans were better fighters:
They were radically different. The German was far more skilled than the Japanese. Most of the Japanese that we fought were not skilled men. Not skilled leaders. The German had a professional army. . . . The Japanese army was very much like ours in a sense. They had a small corps of officers who were professionals. But the bulk of their people were not professionals in the sense of knowing their business and so on. They didn't have the equipment that we had. They didn't know how to handle combined arms-the artillery and the support of the infantry-to the same extent we did. They were gallant soldiers, though. They fought to the end and you had to knock them off-that was all there was to it. And we had to do that right on Guadalcanal. . . . The Japanese were very gallant men. They fought very, very hard, but they were not nearly as skillful as the Germans. But the German didn't have the tenacity of the Japanese."
​
Tom again: Still, I think the Pacific war, conducted on remote islands where the enemy would fight to the death, probably was the tougher fight, even if the foe wasn't as skillful or as well-equipped.
 
Finally, it was a revelation to find out the Japanese Imperial Army was only ~2.5 million men. In Europe, the German Wehrmacht was over 18 million.

Are you saure about these numbers? At the beginning of WW II didn't Japan have a much larger population than Germany and yet they were able to put so many fewer soldiers in the field? If the Japanese Imperial Army was only 2.5 million strong, then their death rate must be close to 100%. Query: Is it true that every pilot (except one) who participated in the attack on Pearl Harbour was killed by war's end?
 
The best soldiers

I think I posted some time in the past, that the ideal army would be-

Japanese privates circa WWII
German non-coms circa WWII
American officers- today

(wasnt my original idea, but it makes sense)