'The Pacific' a noble failure?

Bear669

New member
Apr 9, 2006
2,301
3
0
Wilds of the GTA
Finished #9 and of course will see the final episode next Sunday.

But geeze, what a let down, especially after the quality of the prequel "Band of Brothers'.

(Though someone commented that it is too much to expect another BofB? Why?)

Cinematography- Too much is DARK. Yes I know, fighting and dying in the dark was realty, but when you cannot see what the hell is happening, or to whom it is happening for extended periods- whats the point.

Cast-Lots of good 'no name' actors, but they come and go through the episodes, and you cant track let alone bond with them, especially in the mud and dark.

Episodes- wasted time and episodes on going to war, coming home from war (likely- maybe give #10 BoD) and for SURE spending a year in Australia.

History- Huge $ were spent on meticulous sets, and the main battles were accurate. BUT why the references to all the Aus troops being away from the East (NOT true in later 1942 and 1943), and a comment that the USA (and Pacific allies?) didnt do much in 1943, cuz they were short of resources (NOT true).
Most important,why was the battle of Medal of Honour Winner Basilone shortened to ONE night, when it actually went on for 48 HOURS*?

POV- War is Hell. War is a crime. But, I sympathize with comments by USA military & vets that "The Pacific' focuses excessively on marine brutality, marine atrocities, bad officers, breakdowns & PTSD.
And minimizes the successes*, skill and triumph of the men who are supposedly being honoured.

SHOW IT ALL! BofB pulled no punches, but because of this weak legacy historians of the future may assume that the Screaming Eagles had it all over the Jarheads. Not true, not fair.
 
Tom Hanks had mentioned that the war (from the US perspective) in Europe lent itself to a more natural story telling narrative than the War in the Pacific. In Europe, the Allied forces stormed the beach, moved in and cleaned up as they went and finally the Nazis surrendered and Hitler blew his brains out. This is a defined 'premise'/'conflict'/'resolution' narrative from a story telling POV.

The pacific war did not play out in such fashion and ended with tragedy for all mankind with the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. From a film-making perspective as well, you want to distance yourself from Band of Brothers by just not making a copy of it.

I found 'The Pacific' interesting to watch but in the same way you watch two Eastwood westerns. 'Good, Bad & Ugly' and 'Unforgiven' are both great but very distinctive films. That might be the best allegory I can present with 'The Pacific' and 'Band of Brothers'.
 
I think this series has been excellent and has shown the war for what is was. Brutal and horrific. What I found interesting in comparing the two series is how different the war was portrayed. The Germans were more conventional in their tactics and that there was little difference between the men fighting on both sides. In the Pacific, you get a sense of how fanatically and brutally the Japanese fought and how completely foreign they were to the US and their forces, even when the end was near the Germans didn't resort to kamakazi tactics or mass suicide (or least to extent that the Japanese did. I think that Spielburg and co were trying to portray the complete sense of shock and horror that the average Marine would have felt being witness to these events.
 
In the Pacific, you get a sense of how fanatically and brutally the Japanese fought.

I stopped watching after the 4th or 5th episode. Did they show the Battle of Saipan where Japanese soldiers pushed Japanese civilians off "Suicide Cliff" to their doom while the American marines were urging them to please stop? I think the LLL blamed these civilian deaths on the U.S. as well.
 
If BoB is a 10 then Pacific is a 7. It's good and very realistic to give you an idea as to what it was like there but honestly, it's like watching the same thing every week. The weather never changes, the basic type of fighting never changes, the locales all look the same. There also is not the rich character development like in BoB. I have watched every episode so far and honestly aside from Snafu, who is memorable in his psychotic weirdness - how creepy was it when he was plinking pebbles into the blown out head of that dead jap, I can't tell you the names of the characters, their background stories, or their history in the fight. Every episode is just more of the same.
 
We have generally enjoyed Pacific, though not as much as Band of Brothers. I did not find it unduly racist or casting the marines in a bad light, the way they reacted to the situations seemed pretty realistic to me.

What disappointed me was that I felt that the character development was inferior. In BoB, you basically moved through the process with the group, from training, to England, the invasion and advancing. But Pacific is much more disjointed. Sledge is now the main character, yet he did not appear until the second half, just as his buddy went home. Snafu is the second main character, yet we are never introduced to his back story like we are with the others. Basalone was perhaps developed the most, but it was uneven, he disappears, then comes back, and does not have interaction with the other characters.

I think they could have made it just as realistic, but had a more coherent group of characters. I gather that it was based on the actual accounts of certain soldiers, perhaps that is why they did it that way.
 
Did they show the "Marianas Turkey Shoot"?

When they didn't show the "Miracle at Midway" and the bloody battle for Tarawa, I gave up watching the show.
 
I was disappointed by the Pacific as well. I think they made some big mistakes here. I will watch Band of Brothers episodes several times, no such desire with the Pacific. None of the characters we very endearing, except Basilone.. and it was sad to see him die in a historically incorrect way. There was no redeeming uplifting story to counter that. I would have also like to see a naval component to the story, from a carrier for example, with kamikaze attacks coming in... so much potential for greatness ...a missed opportunity.
 
If BoB is a 10 then Pacific is a 7. It's good and very realistic to give you an idea as to what it was like there but honestly, it's like watching the same thing every week. The weather never changes, the basic type of fighting never changes, the locales all look the same. There also is not the rich character development like in BoB. I have watched every episode so far and honestly aside from Snafu, who is memorable in his psychotic weirdness - how creepy was it when he was plinking pebbles into the blown out head of that dead jap, I can't tell you the names of the characters, their background stories, or their history in the fight. Every episode is just more of the same.

Here Here. With B of B you could identify with the characters and (revel isn't the right word) share in their experiences and yeah, care about them. So far in the Pacific Sledge is one character who has been on long enough to car and briefly, Basilone.

Plus how Basilone got killed is SO not what happened in real life. Not even close. The real story was he was leading a stranded Sherman out of a mine field while it was under fire from artillery. The closest the pacific came was when he yelled to someone "tell that tank to follow me...".

Maybe the war on the islands WAS all of the same? Shoot, get shot at, die in the mud. Shoot, get shot at, die in the mud???

I was disappointed by the Pacific as well. I think they made some big mistakes here. I will watch Band of Brothers episodes several times, no such desire with the Pacific. None of the characters we very endearing, except Basilone.. and it was sad to see him die in a historically incorrect way. There was no redeeming uplifting story to counter that. I would have also like to see a naval component to the story, from a carrier for example, with kamikaze attacks coming in... so much potential for greatness ...a missed opportunity.

I think maybe they spent so much money on the accuracy of the sets that they had to scrimp on the story telling......
 
I think maybe they spent so much money on the accuracy of the sets that they had to scrimp on the story telling......

Considering that they based the series off a couple books, that's no excuse...

Something you need to remember is that the war in the Pacific doesn't garner anywhere near the same level of interest as the war in Europe. Just look at the number of books sold re: Europe vs. the Pacific and you'll see how true that is. There's just a heck of a lot more war aficionados interested in Europe rather than the Pacific. So this show started out behind the eight ball...
 
The Pacific has been a bit of a disappointment for me also. As mentionned by others, it's hard to keep up with the characters. They come & go too quickly. Where's Leckie? He was the character i liked the most until he disappeared. In Band of Brothers, it was easy to get to know & identify the characters. We even referred to them by their nicknames! There were more characters than in The Pacific. We felt a bond among them.

The Pacific is also very dark & it's hard to see the action & the characters. As mentionned, i find it extremely disjointed & one of the reasons why it's difficult to get to know the characters & care for them. In one of the first episodes, one of the main characters (or so we thought at the time) was sent home at the beginning of one of the episodes. I may have missed something, but i have no idea why. At the end of one of the episodes, he was in the south Pacific. The next episode begins with him visiting families in the States. I had absolutely no idea what had happened. Not Basilone, but the other guy. Lechie's buddy. I find that there was also a bit too much romance in the earlier episodes, something we didn't see in Band of Brothers. I don't want to sound dark, but i find that The Pacific could have been a bit more gory. Sure, it was a different war & there were possibly more night time battles than daytime....but the series was made for entertainment value first and foremost.

It's still one of the best war miniseries every made.....but it doesn't come close to the greatness of Band of Brothers, which i've seen dozens of times. I doubt i'll watch The Pacific again once its run comes to an end. Here's wishing that the final episode will show some scenes in Hiroshima or Nagazaki, for dramatic effect (similar to the discovery of the concentration camp in Band of Brothers).
 
Worthington is right. The last episode showed how the Japanese used civilians including babies as explosive boobytraps.

Was it factual that people and babies were used as booby traps or is this just a bit of exploitive artistic licence? I was told by a fool that heard it from a Vietnam vet that the Vietnamese would take a young boy and open him up and sew him back up with explosives inside.

1) If a person were to be opened up by a person untrained in medicine and explosives were to be inserted in a non sterile, non surgical enviornment. I would think that he would not be in good shape.
2) In the Vietnam era, remote control detination of explosives were not as they are today, it would be difficult to detenate the explosives at the desired location.

I think that this was just a bit of sensationalism that was added to spice up a dull script.

Some people will hear unsubstanciated accounts from idiots that donot know what they are talking about or from people that were not even at the event but telling heroic tales about themselves.They might even see things on television or the movies and in their minds fiction becomes fact.
 
Well CC, they remote detonated the explosives by shooting the bomber with a rifle. If it was TNT that might set it off. (any explosive experts out there?).

I'd say the sewing up the boy with a bomb inside is BS but just because remote detonaters weren't readily available to the public doesn't mean they weren't to the military.

We know a LOT about weapons and stuff now but just think: if they tell us about it, then it is old technology. Just think of what they aren't telling us about? that's the scary part.....I mean really, if the raptor and the drones are cutting edge and they have no secret weapons, would they REALLY tell the enemy about them?

BTW: The episodes with Sledge in them are based on his award winning book about his experiences in the pacific. You can believe them or not but I'd tend to believe someone who had first hand experience.....
 
One thing I think might be interesting to discuss while we're on the topic of suicide bombers etc, and this is prompted by the line in the last episode that "the botany bay (?) was sunk by a kamikaze, how can they do that"???

Quite an effective weapon when you think about it. Now we westerners think "OH MY GAWD" but in reality, is it so different than sending a platoon of men across an open airfield that is within range of enemy artillery and machine guns? Or driving a landing craft directly into the field of fire of a machine gun nest and the second the door is dropped, 23 men are killed? It would be far more effective and economical to have one fighter loaded with explosives fly into the bunker. You lose ONE plane and ONE pilot instead of 23 men.....
 
when i saw them cutting out GOLD teeth from dead enemy soldiers , i found the F/F on the PVR remote handy

i understand the point the director was making , but ewww
 
when i saw them cutting out GOLD teeth from dead enemy soldiers , i found the F/F on the PVR remote handy

i understand the point the director was making , but ewww

Then you should stay away from a lot of vietnam movies. They collected ears on that one. Oh, and inglorious basterds? That one too.....

What's that saying? It is hard to keep your humanity when you're walking through hell......
 
It is hard to keep your humanity when you're walking through hell......

Might actually be better to suspend your humanity for the duration. Do what you have to do. Get it done and then return to normalcy. The problem now is that we try to fight wars and maintain humanity at the same time and that is why wars now last a 1,000 years and are more costly in blood and treasure than they need to be. Plus, we also try to fight wars on the cheap only to have to rely on "surges" later to get the job properly done.
 
yeah well, I guess it would be tough to return to normalcy after you've walked through your buddies guts and wiped his head off your fatigues.........
 
when i saw them cutting out GOLD teeth from dead enemy soldiers , i found the F/F on the PVR remote handy

i understand the point the director was making , but ewww


I was watching a documentary on WW II, they asked soldiers if they regretted doing somethings while they were at war. Three old soldiers in the Doc told stories with tears in their eyes,

- Story 1
A soldier told of how he was in wet clothes for a week, and when he saw a pile of dead American solders in a pile, he took the opprtunity to change clothes with a dead soldier.

- Story 2
One soldier told a story while looking down and not looking at the camera when he spoke. He told of how he removed gold teeth from Japanese soldiers dead bodies. When he started the story he was looking down and enthusiastic but as he finished the story his speech slowed and there was regret in his voice. He tried to justify what he did with his last few words. He said that he had a pile of gold teeth the size of a softball at the end of the war and he set himself up in business after the war with the gold from the dead. He was quite old and his last sentance was, I hope they forgive me for what I did to them. I might be seeing them soon.

- Story 3
One farm boy told of how his platoon had come upon a tank where soldiers were killed with smoke inside the tank and the bodies was in rigamortis. They were ordered to get the bodies out but they could not. He spoke up and said that he was a farm boy and they butchered cows and pigs, so they cut the body up and removed it from inside the tank. After the first body, the captain decieded that they would not remove the other bodies and left the tank with the other bodies in it..