Finished #9 and of course will see the final episode next Sunday.
But geeze, what a let down, especially after the quality of the prequel "Band of Brothers'.
(Though someone commented that it is too much to expect another BofB? Why?)
Cinematography- Too much is DARK. Yes I know, fighting and dying in the dark was realty, but when you cannot see what the hell is happening, or to whom it is happening for extended periods- whats the point.
Cast-Lots of good 'no name' actors, but they come and go through the episodes, and you cant track let alone bond with them, especially in the mud and dark.
Episodes- wasted time and episodes on going to war, coming home from war (likely- maybe give #10 BoD) and for SURE spending a year in Australia.
History- Huge $ were spent on meticulous sets, and the main battles were accurate. BUT why the references to all the Aus troops being away from the East (NOT true in later 1942 and 1943), and a comment that the USA (and Pacific allies?) didnt do much in 1943, cuz they were short of resources (NOT true).
Most important,why was the battle of Medal of Honour Winner Basilone shortened to ONE night, when it actually went on for 48 HOURS*?
POV- War is Hell. War is a crime. But, I sympathize with comments by USA military & vets that "The Pacific' focuses excessively on marine brutality, marine atrocities, bad officers, breakdowns & PTSD.
And minimizes the successes*, skill and triumph of the men who are supposedly being honoured.
SHOW IT ALL! BofB pulled no punches, but because of this weak legacy historians of the future may assume that the Screaming Eagles had it all over the Jarheads. Not true, not fair.
But geeze, what a let down, especially after the quality of the prequel "Band of Brothers'.
(Though someone commented that it is too much to expect another BofB? Why?)
Cinematography- Too much is DARK. Yes I know, fighting and dying in the dark was realty, but when you cannot see what the hell is happening, or to whom it is happening for extended periods- whats the point.
Cast-Lots of good 'no name' actors, but they come and go through the episodes, and you cant track let alone bond with them, especially in the mud and dark.
Episodes- wasted time and episodes on going to war, coming home from war (likely- maybe give #10 BoD) and for SURE spending a year in Australia.
History- Huge $ were spent on meticulous sets, and the main battles were accurate. BUT why the references to all the Aus troops being away from the East (NOT true in later 1942 and 1943), and a comment that the USA (and Pacific allies?) didnt do much in 1943, cuz they were short of resources (NOT true).
Most important,why was the battle of Medal of Honour Winner Basilone shortened to ONE night, when it actually went on for 48 HOURS*?
POV- War is Hell. War is a crime. But, I sympathize with comments by USA military & vets that "The Pacific' focuses excessively on marine brutality, marine atrocities, bad officers, breakdowns & PTSD.
And minimizes the successes*, skill and triumph of the men who are supposedly being honoured.
SHOW IT ALL! BofB pulled no punches, but because of this weak legacy historians of the future may assume that the Screaming Eagles had it all over the Jarheads. Not true, not fair.

