No, frankly no, this is a rating thread, not a review thread. If somebody wanted to do a review then they would start one. No further explanations are ever necessary. You take your pluses and minuses and add them up, that's all.
I usually don't have bad experiences enough to rate a -1, but when I do, I usually send that rating to Maseeker privately, just to avoid these discussions here, you wouldn't even see the rating in here, it'll only appear mysteriously in the final list. Yeezy should be commended for being brave enough to post it publicly.