Time for Tory's Tories
The Ottawa Citizen
Tue 09 Oct 2007
Page: B4
Section: City
Source: Ottawa Citizen
The Ontario election campaign has served up two big surprises: the youth and energy of the Progressive Conservative party's candidates, and the savvy and wisdom of the Green party's. Both are a refreshing antidote to the NDP's socialism and the Liberals' cynicism.
Relatively few of the Progressive Conservative candidates, at least in Eastern Ontario, are tired relics from the old regime of Mike Harris. Party leader John Tory seems to recognize that Harris-style bombast -- you don't have to bully the poor to promote fiscal rectitude -- won't draw many votes today. He's lined up with thoughtful young people such as Graham Fox in Ottawa-Orléans, who appear not only to believe that smaller government is better government, but to have spent time reflecting on the importance of doing small government well.
The same degree of thought has gone into preparing the Green party for the campaign. The Greens are hardly ready to form a government, but their platform offers an increasing number of economically sound solutions to major environmental problems that any competent governing party should steal. Hectoring people and passing regulations won't save the planet -- as smart candidates such as John Ogilvie in Carleton-Mississippi Mills recognize. The Greens might not elect an MPP this time, but they can no longer be called a fringe party.
The New Democrats can. They've run much the same campaign they did in 2003 and 1999, trotting out policies that only grow more dated each time out of the barn. They'd raise dramatically the minimum wage (eliminating marginal jobs), freeze post-secondary tuition (subsidizing even students who could afford to pay more), and chase the private sector out of health care entirely.
At least the New Democrats, ideologues that they are, seem to believe what they're saying. The same is not true of most Liberal candidates, who've been forced into collective denial thanks to their party's official position on religious schooling.
Is it fair that Roman Catholic parents get public funding to send their children to Catholic schools, while members of other faiths don't? Most Liberal candidates refused to answer, or worse, a couple suggested that it is fair because Protestant, Jewish, Muslim and Sikh parents can supposedly send their children to Catholic schools just as readily as Catholic parents can.
It's difficult to vote for candidates, no matter how polished, who insist that black is white.
The Liberals do have achievements of which to be proud. Ontario's electricity system is cleaner and more stable than it was four years ago. Wait times for some high-priority medical procedures have been reduced, driven by better public information and a clever system for paying hospitals more if they do more surgeries.
But these are glimmers in a dark curtain.
As with Catholic education, the Liberals refuse to articulate principled positions on health care -- which will eat the whole Ontario budget soon, if we let it, and which Liberal Health Minister George Smitherman refuses even to discuss reforming.
The party must also suffer for breaking the no-tax-increase pledge Mr. McGuinty ostentatiously signed before the 2003 election, hiking taxes nearly $3 billion with a regressive health levy the premier and Finance Minister Greg Sorbara insisted was an insurance premium until that became inconvenient. They couldn't even break a promise in a stand-up way.
Next to the cynical Smithermans and McGuintys of the Liberal party, Progressive Conservative leader John Tory has emerged as a figure of unusual civility. Agree or not with his desire to give non-Catholic families the same rights as Catholic ones, Mr. Tory at least has the courage to acknowledge that the current system is discriminatory.
Some critics feel that his decision, late in the campaign, to allow his MPPs a free vote on the issue suggests a failure of nerve, but that's unfair. In comparison to Mr. McGuinty's health-tax move, Mr. Tory modified a controversial position before being elected; Mr. McGuinty abandoned a popular one after it got him elected. The distinction is important.
So is the distinction between the two parties. The Progressive Conservatives are not as conservative as we might like on a number of economic issues, nor as progressive as they should be on environmental issues.
But Mr. Tory is a man of integrity, with a long history of community involvement and volunteerism, who has the clear-head of a successful businessman.
He and his party are offering an appealing package of policies and leadership, and they deserve to form the province's next government.
The Ottawa Citizen
Tue 09 Oct 2007
Page: B4
Section: City
Source: Ottawa Citizen
The Ontario election campaign has served up two big surprises: the youth and energy of the Progressive Conservative party's candidates, and the savvy and wisdom of the Green party's. Both are a refreshing antidote to the NDP's socialism and the Liberals' cynicism.
Relatively few of the Progressive Conservative candidates, at least in Eastern Ontario, are tired relics from the old regime of Mike Harris. Party leader John Tory seems to recognize that Harris-style bombast -- you don't have to bully the poor to promote fiscal rectitude -- won't draw many votes today. He's lined up with thoughtful young people such as Graham Fox in Ottawa-Orléans, who appear not only to believe that smaller government is better government, but to have spent time reflecting on the importance of doing small government well.
The same degree of thought has gone into preparing the Green party for the campaign. The Greens are hardly ready to form a government, but their platform offers an increasing number of economically sound solutions to major environmental problems that any competent governing party should steal. Hectoring people and passing regulations won't save the planet -- as smart candidates such as John Ogilvie in Carleton-Mississippi Mills recognize. The Greens might not elect an MPP this time, but they can no longer be called a fringe party.
The New Democrats can. They've run much the same campaign they did in 2003 and 1999, trotting out policies that only grow more dated each time out of the barn. They'd raise dramatically the minimum wage (eliminating marginal jobs), freeze post-secondary tuition (subsidizing even students who could afford to pay more), and chase the private sector out of health care entirely.
At least the New Democrats, ideologues that they are, seem to believe what they're saying. The same is not true of most Liberal candidates, who've been forced into collective denial thanks to their party's official position on religious schooling.
Is it fair that Roman Catholic parents get public funding to send their children to Catholic schools, while members of other faiths don't? Most Liberal candidates refused to answer, or worse, a couple suggested that it is fair because Protestant, Jewish, Muslim and Sikh parents can supposedly send their children to Catholic schools just as readily as Catholic parents can.
It's difficult to vote for candidates, no matter how polished, who insist that black is white.
The Liberals do have achievements of which to be proud. Ontario's electricity system is cleaner and more stable than it was four years ago. Wait times for some high-priority medical procedures have been reduced, driven by better public information and a clever system for paying hospitals more if they do more surgeries.
But these are glimmers in a dark curtain.
As with Catholic education, the Liberals refuse to articulate principled positions on health care -- which will eat the whole Ontario budget soon, if we let it, and which Liberal Health Minister George Smitherman refuses even to discuss reforming.
The party must also suffer for breaking the no-tax-increase pledge Mr. McGuinty ostentatiously signed before the 2003 election, hiking taxes nearly $3 billion with a regressive health levy the premier and Finance Minister Greg Sorbara insisted was an insurance premium until that became inconvenient. They couldn't even break a promise in a stand-up way.
Next to the cynical Smithermans and McGuintys of the Liberal party, Progressive Conservative leader John Tory has emerged as a figure of unusual civility. Agree or not with his desire to give non-Catholic families the same rights as Catholic ones, Mr. Tory at least has the courage to acknowledge that the current system is discriminatory.
Some critics feel that his decision, late in the campaign, to allow his MPPs a free vote on the issue suggests a failure of nerve, but that's unfair. In comparison to Mr. McGuinty's health-tax move, Mr. Tory modified a controversial position before being elected; Mr. McGuinty abandoned a popular one after it got him elected. The distinction is important.
So is the distinction between the two parties. The Progressive Conservatives are not as conservative as we might like on a number of economic issues, nor as progressive as they should be on environmental issues.
But Mr. Tory is a man of integrity, with a long history of community involvement and volunteerism, who has the clear-head of a successful businessman.
He and his party are offering an appealing package of policies and leadership, and they deserve to form the province's next government.

