This should be fun.
Explain to the sane people here why accusing NOAA of 'Enron-style accounting' ... is a 'metaphor'.
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/metaphor
This should be fun.
Explain to the sane people here why accusing NOAA of 'Enron-style accounting' ... is a 'metaphor'.
Sorry, but Enron-style accounting doesn't qualify as an actual temperature increase.
It's amazing how many things you can get wrong in just one sentence.
A metaphor would have been 'NOAA's adjustment of SST's based on new information is like fraud'.
Dr Carter's findings weren't solid enough to be published, they were only suitable for a video for those zealots who have already made up their minds.
As noted, he has no published work on the subject to judge, and as you noted you need a scientist to provide a hypothesis and evidence, not just a youtube video.
No he just questions the conclusions of your studiesHe fails your own test.
A zealot is someone who is absolute in their believe despite any alternative evidence that they are 100% without a doubt rightYou fail as you fit your own definition of zealot.
Instead you just said NOAA's adjustments were fraud.
Actually, that's a simile. :thumb:
I compared the NOAA's adjustments to sea surface temperatures with "Enron-style accounting."
As you stated you 'compared' NOAA's actions to fraud, that's not a metaphor or a simile, that's an accusation.
Do you think this chart shows a flat, horizontal line from 2000 on?
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-Ppt8Cg0zf...global+mean+surface+temperature+to+2015Lz.png
It is kinda difficult to publish when you are dead. You can not be that stupid can you?
If you watched the video he discuss the scientific methodology, proposing a hypothesis and then showed the evidence.
Enough to raise some serous questions before developing an economically devastating and technologically unachievable policy
As Dr. Carter pointed out your time reference is too short
We haven't seen any warming in the 21st century fuji.
2000-1979: Satellite stratospheric data
1979-1871: S. Hemisphere ground temp. data
1871- 422k B.P.: Vostok Ice Core Data
Agreed. I fully acknowledge that I accused the NOAA of cooking the books.
I said the metaphor was "Enron-style accounting."
And as long as you're accusing NOAA of fraud, its time for you clearly state what this fraud is.
I assume you'll be retracting your previous claim that I "backed down" from what I had previously posted. That is irrefutably false.
We haven't seen any warming in the 21st century fuji. With the exception of 2015 which was due to El Nino. Dr Carter was right and there are scores of other scientists who are predicting a 30 year cooling trend. One climate data point.
Just wildly curious because I generally give these climate threads a wide berth but has anyone reading these threads actually wrote:
' ... OMG ... You are right ! Obviously Climate change is /a worldwide conspiracy / a scientific certainty / the world's most boring topic.
Hallelujah ! My life has changed for the better !'
You backed down previously from stating you were accusing NOAA to claiming it was just a 'metaphor'.
Not one of your links contains allegations or evidence of fraud, this claim is entirely coming from you.
No, I was responding to k douglas' claim:
And your source, dead Dr Carter makes idiotic mistakes.
His calculation of temperatures on your page states its 'lower atmosphere' readings, as he mixes surface temp reconstructions with upper stratosphere satellite data:
That's just stupid to put those in the same chart and claim that its one series of measurements.
Surface reconstructions and then stratosphere?
How stupid do you have to be to not notice that stuff, larue?
No, hasn't happened.
The trolls are trolls, and the conspiracy kooks keep digging their heels in even as we hit yet another global temperature record.
Those who understand the science see the evidence get stronger every day.
While the denier universe gets more scared of liability in the wake of the Exxon investigations.
Its a bit like watching the last defenders of apartheid, or the last few people who still thought tobacco smoke was good for you.
They get crazier with every post, like moviefan accusing NOAA of fraud, but they don't notice the rest of the world has moved on.