The Nazi King

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
I watched the documentary last night. It turns out, that the removal of Edward as king had more to do with him giving sensitive state information to the germans, than with the lovely mrs. Simpson.

I am looking forward to Aardie and Blackie defending him.
 
Edward VIII abdicated in 1936, long before anyone was CERTAIN that there was going to be a war with Germany.

HOWEVER, you are correct when you say that the man was a nazi. Much more than a nazi sympathizer.

But the crux of his abdication was his relationship with Wallace Simpson. By all accounts, Edward VIII was a sexual freak. On one hand, he enjoyed having affairs with married women, on the other, he was rumoured to be homosexual. I think that the truth was probably that he was an extremely kinky guy and regular vanilla sex did nothing to get him going. Supposedly, Wallace Simpson was quite the kinky woman herself and regularly cuckolded David (his real name) in front of him and then had him fellate her lovers as she watched. In either case, their sex life was a million miles from normal.

There was a documentary on the CBC about 6 months ago on Edward VIII and it was a fact that both he and Wallace were nazis. It got so bad, that during the war, they were shipped off to the Bahamas where they could be far away from both Britain and Germany. Since Edward was basically an idiot - he had to depend on his allowance in order to survive, so he did what he was told.
 
Edward VIII abdicated in 1936, long before anyone was CERTAIN that there was going to be a war with Germany.

HOWEVER, you are correct when you say that the man was a nazi. Much more than a nazi sympathizer.

But the crux of his abdication was his relationship with Wallace Simpson. By all accounts, Edward VIII was a sexual freak. On one hand, he enjoyed having affairs with married women, on the other, he was rumoured to be homosexual. I think that the truth was probably that he was an extremely kinky guy and regular vanilla sex did nothing to get him going. Supposedly, Wallace Simpson was quite the kinky woman herself and regularly cuckolded David (his real name) in front of him and then had him fellate her lovers as she watched. In either case, their sex life was a million miles from normal.

There was a documentary on the CBC about 6 months ago on Edward VIII and it was a fact that both he and Wallace were nazis. It got so bad, that during the war, they were shipped off to the Bahamas where they could be far away from both Britain and Germany. Since Edward was basically an idiot - he had to depend on his allowance in order to survive, so he did what he was told.

I think it is the same documentary that was rebroadcast. It did make the point that already in 1936, that his nazi sympathy, which went as far as giving sensitive information to ambassador Rippentrip, was a serious concern for the government and played a big part in his abdication or removal from the throne. The british establishment wanted him gone.
 
I watched the documentary last night. It turns out, that the removal of Edward as king had more to do with him giving sensitive state information to the germans, than with the lovely mrs. Simpson.

I am looking forward to Aardie and Blackie defending him.
The Abdication Crisis had to do with a lot of things.

Sir Alan Lascelles, King Edward VIII's Private Secretary has stated that his “impression [was] that the Prince of Wales was caught napping by his father's death; he expected the old man to last several years more, and he had, in all probability, already made up his mind to renounce his claim to the throne, and to marry Mrs S. . . . . King George VI has told me that his brother, at the time of the Abdication crisis, said to him: 'It was never in my scheme of things to be King.'”

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-417388/Prince-Charmless-A-damning-portrait-Edward-VIII.html


However, I don't believe that it has ever been shown that King Edward VIII was deliberately passing information to Germany, however, it is certainly true that he was horrifically casual/careless with handling state papers, and was likewise gossipy in the extreme.
 
The Abdication Crisis had to do with a lot of things.

Sir Alan Lascelles, King Edward VIII's Private Secretary has stated that his “impression [was] that the Prince of Wales was caught napping by his father's death; he expected the old man to last several years more, and he had, in all probability, already made up his mind to renounce his claim to the throne, and to marry Mrs S. . . . . King George VI has told me that his brother, at the time of the Abdication crisis, said to him: 'It was never in my scheme of things to be King.'”

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-417388/Prince-Charmless-A-damning-portrait-Edward-VIII.html


However, I don't believe that it has ever been shown that King Edward VIII was deliberately passing information to Germany, however, it is certainly true that he was horrifically casual/careless with handling state papers, and was likewise gossipy in the extreme.

I must admit I did not give the documentary about the british royals my full attention, but it did make the point that newly released documents show that the government was seriously concerned about the king's conversations with the german ambassador, and that the establishment wanted to get rid of him.
After he abdicated, during his "tour of duty" in France, he did give sensitive information to the germans. The germans changed their plan for attacking France on the basis of the intelligence he gave them. In addition, he urged the germans to intensify the heavy bombing of Britain. Any other british officer would have been shot, if he had behaved this way.
 
Any other british officer would have been shot, if he had behaved this way.
Since that couldn't be done and St. Helena would have been too obvious, he was made Governor of the Bahamas where save for mangling the Sir Harry Oakes murder investigation he was in a position of not being able to cause much trouble.
 
Since that couldn't be done and St. Helena would have been too obvious, he was made Governor of the Bahamas where save for mangling the Sir Harry Oakes murder investigation he was in a position of not being able to cause much trouble.

It is good to know that you believe royals should be above all laws and conventions.

He was demonstably a traitor.
 
Edward the VIII should have gotten the Charles I hair cut and had his head displayed on traitors gate.
 
It is good to know that you believe royals should be above all laws and conventions.

He was demonstably a traitor.
I'm not sure given the evidence that he was. A Nazi sympathizer definately, at least at the outbreak of the war more than that I haven't seen the evidence.

Further, you think being shuttled off to a backwater like the Bahamas as far from any front as possible, and then being in exile in Paris was "fun?" It may have been gilded but it was a cage.
 
I'm not sure given the evidence that he was. A Nazi sympathizer definately, at least at the outbreak of the war more than that I haven't seen the evidence.

Further, you think being shuttled off to a backwater like the Bahamas as far from any front as possible, and then being in exile in Paris was "fun?" It may have been gilded but it was a cage.

The documentary presented proof that, when he was on duty in France, he informed the germans that the french/british expected the germans to through the lowlands instead of through the Ardennes. The germans, who were planning to attack through the lowlands, then changed their plans and attacked through the Ardennes. If he did not deserve to be shot for that, nothing would suffice.

However, to me this raises a whole different question. Does it not give you pause to think about the monarchy, when such a pitiful, weak and generally horrible human being like Edward can become King of the then greatest empire on the planet? I can hardly imagine any better argument against the monarchy. If the only qualification for the highest office in the land is to have emerged from the royal birth canal, these deplorable situations are bound to happen.
 
The documentary presented proof that, when he was on duty in France, he informed the germans that the french/british expected the germans to through the lowlands instead of through the Ardennes.
I'd have to dig out some books, but I was under the impression that the evolution of "Case Yellow" was quite well known from the German military archives. That the German plan all on their own was to go through the Ardennes (because the French thought tanks couldn't be driven through it). That in fact Belgium Military Intelligence quite accurately predicted this and the information (which they passed along) was ignored by the French and British.
 
I'd have to dig out some books, but I was under the impression that the evolution of "Case Yellow" was quite well known from the German military archives. That the German plan all on their own was to go through the Ardennes (because the French thought tanks couldn't be driven through it). That in fact Belgium Military Intelligence quite accurately predicted this and the information (which they passed along) was ignored by the French and British.

In any event, your hero was a traitor by passing information on the british/french plans to the germans.
 
The documentary presented proof that, when he was on duty in France, he informed the germans that the french/british expected the germans to through the lowlands instead of through the Ardennes. The germans, who were planning to attack through the lowlands, then changed their plans and attacked through the Ardennes. If he did not deserve to be shot for that, nothing would suffice.
You really need to be selecting your sources with better care. I know it is a sick sad world when the History channel has "documentaries" on how the aliens did everything in the ancient world, but still.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechelen_Incident
 
He was demonstably a traitor.

How do you define "traitor"? He was the King. How do you betray yourself?

Or are you talking about his actions after he abdicated? He could be a traitor then.

(There's a constitutional question here. I'm not disputing whether his actions were reprehensible or not.)
 
I must admit I did not give the documentary about the british royals my full attention, but it did make the point that newly released documents show that the government was seriously concerned about the king's conversations with the german ambassador, and that the establishment wanted to get rid of him.
After he abdicated, during his "tour of duty" in France, he did give sensitive information to the germans. The germans changed their plan for attacking France on the basis of the intelligence he gave them. In addition, he urged the germans to intensify the heavy bombing of Britain. Any other british officer would have been shot, if he had behaved this way.

While my command of modern British history is mediocre, my knowledge of modern German history is pretty good. I have never seen a source suggest that the German attack on France was at all influenced by any special intelligence that came from a British or a royal source.
 
While my command of modern British history is mediocre, my knowledge of modern German history is pretty good. I have never seen a source suggest that the German attack on France was at all influenced by any special intelligence that came from a British or a royal source.

That may very well be true, however, that does not alter the fact that the Duck (apologies to Clint) while on duty in France gave the germans military intelligence. Therefore he without question was a traitor. If the germans needed or used the information is irrelevant.
 
I must admit I did not give the documentary about the british royals my full attention, but it did make the point that newly released documents show that the government was seriously concerned about the king's conversations with the german ambassador, and that the establishment wanted to get rid of him.
After he abdicated, during his "tour of duty" in France, he did give sensitive information to the germans. The germans changed their plan for attacking France on the basis of the intelligence he gave them. In addition, he urged the germans to intensify the heavy bombing of Britain. Any other british officer would have been shot, if he had behaved this way.

No, shit Sherlock!

Your attention span and ability to absorb facts on the Royals are notorious within the walls of TERB.
 
No, shit Sherlock!

Your attention span and ability to absorb facts on the Royals are notorious within the walls of TERB.

Come on, Blackie. Show us you will defend the traitor.