The John Next Door - Newsweek Article

pg.2 said:
In their interviews, the sex buyers often voiced aggression toward women, and were nearly eight times as likely as nonbuyers to say they would rape a woman if they could get away with it. Asked why he bought sex, one man said he liked “to beat women up.” Sex buyers in the study committed more crimes of every kind than nonbuyers, and all the crimes associated with violence against women were committed by the johns.

Please take a moment to read the whole article if you can.

http://www.newsweek.com/2011/07/17/the-growing-demand-for-prostitution.html

Thoughts?
 
A well written article but it kind of says the same thing as all this type of article does. I certainly don't identify with the sentiments expressed by the men they interviewed. I don't agree with the underlying premise that all SPs are forced into this line of work. Maybe I am totally deluded, but when I speak to some of the ladies, I do not get a sense of being forced or fear. I see women getting paid to do a job that they chose, even if they don't love it as much as they pretend some times.

They talk about the Swedish model, and they talk about child trafficking, which is abhorrent but also a SEPARATE issue, as it involves minors, for which there are already separate laws. They don't really look at the German, Australian, or Brazilian sex business models except in a cursory way. They spend a lot more time telling horror stories or handwringing that couldn't even get a control sample of men who fit their predefined notion of a non sex buyer.

And the whole pornography thing is a different argument, too, I would say.

In agree with the one researcher who thinks that itnshould be treated like a job, so that it can be safer for those involved, instead of as a crime.
 
it would be interesting to see how the quotes in the article were brought out. they seem to be very weird things for someone to say.
 
I also wondered where they found their clients, getting a good representation of a client base would be important and I am curious as to if they did that. I have no doubt there are a number of clients that would say these things but for them to say that "many" expressed these beliefs makes me wonder, though I know the people I see are also not representative of the entire market so perhaps I am not aware of what is average.

As far as the porn issue, I was reading Sci Am Mind on my flight back from Ottawa (a good way to spot me on a flight is I am almost always reading Sci Am or Sci Am Mind) and it had this article The Sunny Side of Smut. It suggests that porn isn't a negative influence on the majority of people and may even offer some benefits but that it can be a problem for a few select individuals.
 
From wikipedia
Melissa Farley (born 1942) is an American clinical psychologist and researcher[1][2][3] and feminist anti-pornography and anti-prostitution activist.[4][5] Farley is best known for her studies of the effects of prostitution, trafficking, and sexual violence.
The biggest problem with the study is that there is no explanation of how the 100 buyers were selected, other than that they were pre-screened by a phone call.
Did the phone list come from the registered sex offender list?
 
Very troubling article in many respects. It was clearly written with a purpose, but still....

One is the objectification of women. I think many guys here would protest that point. We'd like to think that we respect women even more because of our experiences. But the fact is, the hobby conditions us view sex and companionship as a commodity. We can get friendly, and even care for each other, but it's still business. If our regular retires, we find a new one.

Another disconcerting thought is the question of choice. I feel more comfortable with companions who appear to be in the business because of their own free will. Choosing sexwork because of childhood or other abuse is not really a choice.
 
I'm left with the impression that the author interviewed only street prostitutes and registered sex offenders, and extrapolated 'facts' for the Industry as a whole.

"...the average age of death is 34" - I strongly doubt the authenticity of that statement. One would expect to read this sort of irresponsible drivel in The New York Post, not in a supposedly respectable publication such as Newsweek.
 
As much as I like to talk a big game on this board, it's really because it's all part of the fun. I don't really see women exclusively as "objects". I never have and never will.

If I ever got the impression that the SP I was seeing was only with me because she "had to", or because she was under any sort of duress, I would would end the session prematurely leaving her the full fee and not return.

Furthermore, I don't think I am anything but respectful to the ladies I see (save for "dirty-talk" once the session is in full swing). When the session is over, I don't see the lady as "used", but I am rather grateful that she was willing to set aside some time and have a pretty intense experience with me.

I think this profession could be a great one. I think in a perfect world, the only downside to this industry would be that it might stop men in potentially successful relationships from discussing their concerns with their SOs (sometimes it's just easier to book an hour with an SP than explain to your SO that you really would like your sex life to be more raunchy).
 
This is a US article, that to me explains a lot. The activity is a lot more illegal there, its a more uptight repressed place, and I would suspect that a nastier part pf ciety gets involved (in general of course) than does here. A lot more drug involvement, and a lot more streetwalkers. I bet a heck of a lot of TERBITES have used escorts a long long time while NEVER using a streetwalker.


I get the impression that the sex industry here is a lot more upmarket than it is there.

Just an impression though. But I think anyone who has hobbyed in the states would surely agree that it is a different game there altogether.
 
Last edited:
Thoughts?
As I posted in the thread yesterday

a) it was conducted in a city in which prostitution is illegal.

b) the "research was conducted by Melissa Farley a anti-prostitution activist,

c) the subjects were recruited via an advertisement in a local free daily newspaper, so how many escort customers were reading The Boston Phoenix.

d) were these clients of Street Walkers or Escorts (I rather suspect the former)

e) would not some men refuse to participate due to the illegality.

f) there are psychological reasons for it but given their methodology (advertisement in a free newspaper, prostitution illegal etc. . . they were more likely to attract those with low impulse control – something common among petty criminals)
 
The term Objectification is meaningless feminist psycho babble intended to make men feel ashamed that they desire women. It is interesting to see the flip side of the equation, women using male desire as a means of power and control and not being held to the same standard. If we witness the slutwalk, this feminist concept should also make women feel ashamed for wanting to be desired. We know it does not and this is the hypocrisy. One can not celebrate or express solidarity with the slutwalk without also acknowledging the equal moral legitimacy of male desire and male objectification of women.
With respect to the issue of exploitation. I have never felt that I exploited any woman. I do however have feelings that I have been exploited. After all I am the one who is paying. No one has ever paid me to enjoy my body. I have been in a situation where I was the most attractive one in the room and yet I was also the one paying. There was a time when I was hot. I had abs. I was fit and very attractive yet I don’t recall there being the same opportunity open to me. It is an ironic truth, men pay money to give pleasure to women. That is the nature of the transaction. If we consider a man who is not in a high paying job, who earns perhaps $20 per hour before tax and saves up and spends $200 after tax money how can we make a claim that he is the exploiter? I would suggest this is not an uncommon situation.
The point I am making is simple. We need to rehabilitate the term objectification. I feel I can look at a woman as a sex object and still look at her as being a human being. In fact it is precisely this that makes her an appealing sex object.
 
The term Objectification is meaningless feminist psycho babble intended to make men feel ashamed that they desire women. It is interesting to see the flip side of the equation, women using male desire as a means of power and control and not being held to the same standard. If we witness the slutwalk, this feminist concept should also make women feel ashamed for wanting to be desired. We know it does not and this is the hypocrisy. One can not celebrate or express solidarity with the slutwalk without also acknowledging the equal moral legitimacy of male desire and male objectification of women.
With respect to the issue of exploitation. I have never felt that I exploited any woman. I do however have feelings that I have been exploited. After all I am the one who is paying. No one has ever paid me to enjoy my body. I have been in a situation where I was the most attractive one in the room and yet I was also the one paying. There was a time when I was hot. I had abs. I was fit and very attractive yet I don’t recall there being the same opportunity open to me. It is an ironic truth, men pay money to give pleasure to women. That is the nature of the transaction. If we consider a man who is not in a high paying job, who earns perhaps $20 per hour before tax and saves up and spends $200 after tax money how can we make a claim that he is the exploiter? I would suggest this is not an uncommon situation.
The point I am making is simple. We need to rehabilitate the term objectification. I feel I can look at a woman as a sex object and still look at her as being a human being. In fact it is precisely this that makes her an appealing sex object.

Good post. You seem to be someone with a rational mind.

With regards to the bolded section, the ONLY logical way I can think of to get around the nice little bit of hypocrisy you pointed out is to make the claim that slutty dress is in no way sexual, it 'just happens' to be how they want to dress, which also 'just happens' to get men's attention.
 
I certainly don't trust Farley, and it seems problematic that the definitions of "sex buyer" and "non sex buyer" are such that most men are in neither category. I admit to wondering if the reason "non sex buyers" report less criminal activity might not be because many of those who ended up being so categorized were just men who weren't inclined to admit to anything questionable when asked in surveys. It would certainly undermine most of the conclusions of the study if that were the case.
 
Having just read the article I think it ignores the underlying damage in the individuals who responded. It isn't prostitution that makes them want to demean or rape women it is a failure in their development as a rational human being that has kept them from any kind of healthy relationships . Visiting an escort doesn't make them sick it only allows them to act out their sick fantasies with less chance of being caught because the sexworker is unlikely to have the oppurtunity or means to seek protection from family,friends or society. The johns know that these women are often isolated and relatively easy prey for them to make use of because they have been marginalized by a society that has historically blamed the victim not the offender. Pushing the sex trade further underground will not solve anything.
 
I agree about porn and paying for sex has warped my attitude towards relationships and women in general. For some, it comes out as disrespect and sometimes violence.

Nothing new there, just that perverts are now more wide-spread and able to connect thanks to the internet.
 
Thoughts?
My initial thought is that it's amazing that people with no grasp of statistics or commons sense are given a forum to publish articles in places like "Newsweek" which purport to have journalistic standards.

Perhaps "American men who admit to journalists that they buy sex" are more likely to CLAIM they would be violent than men who deny buying sex. Of course those who deny buying sex may be lying about that and/or also about how violent they are. Those who admit they buy sex may be lying too, both about hobbying and being violent.

Altogether a useless article in my view.
 
“We had big, big trouble finding nonusers,” Farley says. “We finally had to settle on a definition of non-sex-buyers as men who have not been to a strip club more than two times in the past year, have not purchased a lap dance, have not used pornography more than one time in the last month, and have not purchased phone sex or the services of a sex worker, escort, erotic masseuse, or prostitute.”

Wow, who's left? I mean, there's the guy from Seventh Heaven but anybody else?
 
Because the survey and article are flawed doesn't mean their isn't an element of truth to it. It is a useful starting point in discussing the violence experienced by woman in the sex industry. Instead of denying the problem and attacking the writer why not acknowledge the darker side of human nature and the problems it poses for the people working in the industry.
 
Because the survey and article are flawed doesn't mean their isn't an element of truth to it. It is a useful starting point in discussing the violence experienced by woman in the sex industry. Instead of denying the problem and attacking the writer why not acknowledge the darker side of human nature and the problems it poses for the people working in the industry.
Because it assumes that street walking and escorting are exactly the same. That may sound simplistic but an very great deal flows from it, the type of SP involved, the type of client involved etc. . . & etc. . .and the point you raise as well.