The Innocence Project

rama putri

Banned
Sep 6, 2004
2,992
1
36
Though I am very pro-police, I just know there are few officers, prosecutors and others in the system (including jurors <-- yes) that need to go to jail because they purposely and knowingly put innocent people in jail. We've got to stop making excuses for them. http://www.innocenceproject.org/
 
Seeing an innocent person have 34 years of the most precious thing they own taken from them makes my blood boil!!

The Innocence Project is a very worthy cause, all the power to them.
 
Yes, it is hard to imagine how devastating it would be to be wrongfully convicted of a crime and to spend 10 or 20 years behind bars. There is also a Canadian branch of Project Innocence based out of Osgoode Hall. http://www.innocenceproject.ca/
 
What about juries who intentionally acquit (i.e. OJ, Klansmen in the South, L.A. cops)?
 
You have to consider the technology at the time a person was convicted A lot of the overturned convictions are DNA related.

Police work Legal System etc.has changed a lot over the last 50 years hopefully for the better.
 
Yes, it is hard to imagine how devastating it would be to be wrongfully convicted of a crime and to spend 10 or 20 years behind bars. There is also a Canadian branch of Project Innocence based out of Osgoode Hall. http://www.innocenceproject.ca/


The real question is do they have projects in countries where you will die in prison before anyone hears an appeal?
 
In a "just" society an organization like this would be an integral section of the Justice System, funded by taxpayer dollars and doing everything in it's power to give innocent people back their freedom and dignity.
 
What about juries who intentionally acquit (i.e. OJ, Klansmen in the South, L.A. cops)?
Those are equally serious problems with our justice system at the other end of the spectrum.
You have to consider the technology at the time a person was convicted A lot of the overturned convictions are DNA related.
Police work Legal System etc.has changed a lot over the last 50 years hopefully for the better.
Yes, DNA is an advance in technology that has allowed for many of these convictions to be overturned. That is because DNA evidence is very hard to argue against. But that doesn't mean that DNA cases are the only ones where a person has been wrongfully convicted. Think of the cases where DNA evidence is just not available to overturn a conviction.

In a "just" society an organization like this would be an integral section of the Justice System, funded by taxpayer dollars and doing everything in it's power to give innocent people back their freedom and dignity.
Good point. Hopefully we will get there some day.
 
What about working to ensure innocent people don't get convicted in the first place?
 
What about working to ensure innocent people don't get convicted in the first place?

Yes, true, but do we forget about the ones that have been wrongly convicted?
Unfortunately it isn't a perfect system.

Don't forget about the proverbial "crack" that people fall through.

Seeing it on TV, an innocent man stand before a judge after spending 34 years in prison and the judge says: We would like to apologize for our mistake" seems like Science Fiction to me...just absurd.

Oh well :(
 
I've been aware of the innocenceproject.org for quite some time. I closely followed the case of Clarence Elkins a man wrongfully convicted of rape and murder in 1998 based on the testimony of his 6 year old niece. http://www.trutv.com/library/crime/criminal_mind/forensics/ff313_clarence_elkins/1_index.html
There are many wrongfully convicted felons languishing in US and Cdn prisons. But I don't blame the police as much as their attorneys, many court appointed who are substandard practioners.
 
There are many wrongfully convicted felons languishing in US and Cdn prisons. But I don't blame the police as much as their attorneys, many court appointed who are substandard practioners.

I blame the police when they fabricate or destroy evidence or intimidate witness

I blame crown attorneys who hide evidence that does not support their cases and do not provide full disclosure to the defence.

The prosecution has many more resources than the defense so should be called to a high standard of ethics to see that a proper investigation is completed.
 
What about working to ensure innocent people don't get convicted in the first place?
OldJones, I don't know whether you are in Criminal Practice - but quite how does one do this?

The Victim picks the defendant out in a entirely Kosher line-up, testifies that the defendant was the one who did whatever, the victim honestly believes this. There is other evidence that collaborates this. Yet it comes out years latter that there is definitive evidence that someone else committed the crime. (no DNA evidence is available or appropriate). There was no conspiracy rather a tragic mistake. Other than trying to avoid illicit action by witnesses, Police, prosecutors checking and double checking the case and and evidence - I'm at a loss as to how such miscarriages can be entirely prevented. Fortunately there have been significant improvements over the past quarter century.
 
There are many wrongfully convicted felons languishing in US and Cdn prisons. But I don't blame the police as much as their attorneys, many court appointed who are substandard practioners.
There are not tons of such cases. I will agree that there should be none, personaly I'm unaware of any - now again that may be the part of the world were I reside and practice.

p.s. there is a typo in the article it is the Benjamin N. Cardozo NOT Cardoza School of Law.
I blame the police when they fabricate or destroy evidence or intimidate witness

I blame crown attorneys who hide evidence that does not support their cases and do not provide full disclosure to the defence.

The prosecution has many more resources than the defense so should be called to a high standard of ethics to see that a proper investigation is completed.
Indeed your last two points are part of the canon of Bar ethics.

Again perhaps this does go on in Toronto, personaly I've never seen it.
 
The real question is do they have projects in countries where you will die in prison before anyone hears an appeal?

I don't think they have those kind of resources, plenty of work to do here in our pathetic system already. The problem with our system is it is all about winning and losing. Prosecutors are measured by how many cases they "win" same with the defence. Truth has little to do with the outcome. In such an adversarial system, tons of money is wasted and the poor often do not have the $$ to mount a good defence. Legal aid is a joke. There needs to be a rebalancing. I think if the prosecution loses, the state should cover the cost of the defence. This way the poor could get defence lawyers to take their case on "contingency".
 
I don't think they have those kind of resources, plenty of work to do here in our pathetic system already. The problem with our system is it is all about winning and losing. Prosecutors are measured by how many cases they "win" same with the defence. Truth has little to do with the outcome. In such an adversarial system, tons of money is wasted and the poor often do not have the $$ to mount a good defence. Legal aid is a joke. There needs to be a rebalancing. I think if the prosecution loses, the state should cover the cost of the defence. This way the poor could get defence lawyers to take their case on "contingency".


you make some good points but why should they only be extended to be poor since we have equal protection under the law?
 
you make some good points but why should they only be extended to be poor since we have equal protection under the law?

No I think reimbursement of legal bills should be universal in the event of acquittal. I think it should come out of the same budget that pays for prosecutions so there is equal pressure on both sides and the power of the state is neutralized.
 
What about juries who intentionally acquit (i.e. OJ, Klansmen in the South, L.A. cops)?
Sigh. I agree there is a problem there too, but like the terrorist apologists who bring up Bush or Christians Crusade or more recent Catholic pedophiles as an excuse to do nothing, your post is in the same vain. Venn diagram buddy, mutually exclusive. Red herring.