As a result, the ALS Association has received more than $70 million so far, compared to only $2.5 million during last year’s campaign. It is a great way to raise money — but it is a horrible reason to donate it.
"Horrible" is a strong and IMO inappropriate characterization. Participation in a "look at me" activity for charity may not be the
best reason to donate, but it's fun, it has people talking and it has very successfully raised awareness of this disease (which as noted affects a relatively small number of people, which is why awareness
needs to be raised). The fundraising results speak for themselves.
We, as individuals and as a society, have finite resources to donate to medical research and other worthy causes.
While this is true of course, I find this argument the greatest of red-herrings. In North American society, we are NOWHERE near our capacity for charitable giving. Most of us can easily afford to give more, it's a question of priorities and making sacrifices. Everyone has to determine what they are willing to give, and willing to give up. But most of us -
especially on this board - have considerable disposable income with which to play. To suggest that other worthy causes must be suffering as a result of this campaign is disingenuous. In the article that suggested otherwise, the author was asking donors to commit 10% of their income to charity. That is a significant donation, and that charity's donors are likely giving all they can realistically afford to (and noticeably sacrificing their own discretionary consumption to do so), but Canadians as a whole are nowhere near that level of giving collectively.
When we decide where to spend our charitable dollars, we need to consider three factors.
1. Where is the greatest need?
2. Where will my dollars have the greatest influence?
3. What is the most urgent problem?
The ALS challenge fails all three of these tests.
While it's commendable to have a rational approach to charitable giving, going by these 3 simplistic criteria alone is inadequate.
Regarding #1 and #2 - While ALS may not affect a huge number of people, its effects are devastating, its cause is unknown, and there is little in the way of treatment. Thousands of people and hundreds of millions of dollars and being spent researching cancer, heart disease, diabetes, etc, and significant progress has been made. More than a token amount of research for ALS could similarly make a huge difference in the lives of those affected, not to mention that research in one area can often provide spillover benefits in the treatment of another disease or condition. ALS is getting its moment now, and shouldn't be denied it. Saying it is extremely well funded is bullshit using a dollars raised per death metric, for precisely the reason mentioned - relatively few people are affected by it. Its total fundraising numbers are still low compared to other "major" diseases that have dozens of fundraising events/campaigns through the year.
Regarding #3 - Most chronic diseases aren't "urgent needs" the way humanitarian disasters and virulent outbreaks are. Using this criteria, all chronic disease research funding would stop every time there's a hurricane, earthquake, war, or communicable disease outbreak. Doesn't make sense at all.
We aren’t rational, though. Typically, you will spend more time considering where to order a pizza and what to put on it, than you will deciding where to donate your charitable dollars. As a result, the real threats, the diseases that are far more likely to kill you and your loved ones are ignored. This is why the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge is bad for you, and me, and all of us. Instead of supporting what is most needed, we support what is most amusing.
For slacktivists, perhaps (and I wouldn't classify the ALS Ice bucket challenge as slacktivism). In my experience those who make significant donations give considerable thought to their significant charitable donations. However for those making modest donations like with this ALS challenge, they want to be involved with something fun, social, exhibitionist, and yes, fad-dish. Not the best reasons perhaps, but far from the worst, and not hurting anybody or any other worthy causes.
Health research is way to important to be determined by fads and performing circus monkeys trying to get attention.
Regarding government allocation of health care research dollars, I agree. For private donations, as you said, nobody is going to tell me what to donate to. It's my money. If I want to give to ALS as part of this challenge/campaign, and perhaps do the ice bucket challenge, I will. If not, I will decline. 100% my decision.