The Gardiner Expressway (Keep it, or Nuke it)

Tear down the Gardiner or not

  • Leave the Gardiner as it is - It works, don't fuck with it

    Votes: 26 34.2%
  • I'd love to see the Gardiner torn down, but replace it with a tunnel

    Votes: 15 19.7%
  • Tear it down, build the road as per the report

    Votes: 7 9.2%
  • Leave the Gardiner alone, the money'd be better spent building subways

    Votes: 28 36.8%

  • Total voters
    76

james t kirk

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2001
24,059
4,068
113
Last week a report was released by the Toronto Waterfront Redevelopment Corporation (Who?) that recommended that part of the elevated portion of the Gardiner Expressway be demolished from roughly Spadina to the DVP.

The report recommended that the elevated portion be replaced with a "great road" whatever the hell that is. Essentially, a ten lane road with a boulevard down the middle and development on either side of the road way.

The report stated that the cost would be 785 million dollars and construction and engineering would take approximately 10 years.

On the cover of the national post the other day they had a photo of a forlorn bent under the Gardiner Expressway taken in February, verses an artist's conceptual drawing of a nice 10 lane roadway in June with 5 cars on it and pedestrians walking down the street.

I have never seen a bigger pile of steaming bullshit in my life.

That picture needs to be ammended to show bumper to bumper traffic with people running for their lives to cross that road and avoiding idiots who will run the reds.

I was all for them tearing down the protion of the gardiner from the DVP to Coxwell as this was never even close to being utilized. It was originally intended to be the Scarborough Expressway take off from and to the Gardiner (originally called the Lakeshore Expressway by the way). The Scarborough Expressway was to run from the DVP along part of Kingston Road through the Beaches, then into the Ontario Hydro Corridor. It was never built and never will be built and that's a good thing.

The Spadina Expressway was to take off from the Gardiner around Spadina (hence why you have those really wide lanes there) and go north on Spadina in cut (sort of like that Autoroute Metropolitan?) in Montreal. The Spadina was to cut right through the Annex and several of Toronto's other nicer neighbourhoods right to the 401. The Allan was the only portion of the Spadina that go built and the Spadina was killed off (thank god)

I do not believe that this city needs any more expressways whatsoever.

However, I think that the recommendation to remove the Gardiner Expressway and replace it with an at grade road is the dumbest thing I have ever read in my life.

I would be all for replacing the Gardiner with a Tunnel under the lake from Stachan to the DVP, but anything else is just plain stoo-pid. The Gardiner as is is a free flow roadway with no stops, no pedestrians and it is bumper to bumper every day of every week from 6 a.m. to 8 p.m.

The very notion that making an at grade road would only add 4 minutes to one's trip down the Gardiner is akin to "peace in our time".

Personally, I'd love to see Toronto Transportation add temporary stop lights at all the major intersections along the Gardiner just to see the effects. You'd have traffic backed up to the 401 along the DVP and the Ford plant in the west.

This report was commissioned by the Toronto Waterfront Redevelopment Agency (Who?). They have a vested interest in the redevelopment of the Railway lands adjacent to Skydome (Robert Fung, and his Hong Kong buddies) and the Portlands. In the case of the Skydome area, I find it most interesting that this report would recommend keeping the elevated portion of the Gardiner up and running to - wait for it - Spadina.

Hmmm, I wonder if they are trying to shift the core of Toronto westwards to THEIR properties and developments.

Anyway, as I said, I am all for the tunnel option, but anything else is just rediculous.

BTW, the Gardiner will be closed the weekend of October 28 for a little maintenance. Enjoy the traffic grid lock in the rest of the city.
 
We lost our chance to build a beautiful waterfront when the wall of condos went up over the last decade. There's no sense tearing down the Gardiner now - it's too late, it's not the main hindrance anymore and yes it works.
We should have checked out how Chicago built a beautiful people friendly area, Toronto had the same potential but blew it.
 
I agree, that's because Toronto is ruled by the Developers.

They never want to build anywhere but the best areas in order to attract buyers with big bucks. If this city had any balls, we'd tell them, "sure, you can build your new 40 storey Minto Tower, but not at Yonge just south of Eglinton, but in Downsview, or Scarborough"

This city is dumber than Mississauga when it comes to planning.
 
hmnn

I like the idea of a tunnel..true the waterfront is beyond repair, but the absence of the gardiner can only improve the accessability ..and in an ideal world, mayeb more green space?
 
Miss Maya Blue said:
I like the idea of a tunnel..true the waterfront is beyond repair, but the absence of the gardiner can only improve the accessability ..and in an ideal world, mayeb more green space?

How would tearing down the raised part of the Gardiner create more green space? The Lakeshore is under it.
 
The Gardiner's something of an engineering achievement—though hardly unique in the world—and certainly a member of an endangered species: the urban expressway. It should be preserved, even if it is more expensive to maintain than conventional roads.

And who says it is anyway? The folks who don't know how much they need to maintain our sorry excuses for city streets. By that logic they're right on; of course no roads at all would be even cheaper and make the Gardiner maintenance look even pricier.

If anyone looks north from the lake, it's clear the GE actually could be made into a series of very impressive Gates to the City from Spadina to Bay. Looking south from the city, it's clear the Huang&Danzsky condos and their cousins are the only things separating us from the lake. You can walk or drive under the GE w/o hinderance anywhere there's a street, though it's true there's someone's 20 floor moneymaker anywhere there isn't a street. Well that's not entirely true: the province and the city haven't yet figured out which of their conies is gonna get to build on the shitty collection of parking lots and derelict offices and warehouses from Yonge east.

Speaking of the east: c'mon over to my end of town and see "how much better" life is w/o the Gardiner. Lakeshore's now impossible for pedestrians to cross with eight lanes of high speed traffic. Though it finally got the sidewalks—well bike and blade paths actually, pedestrians take their chances there too—streetlights and landscaping we've been begging for for years, we also got a cheaply built underdesigned major interchange at Carlaw whose road bed is a rutted mess and will one daybe the death of someone trying to turn north from eastbound Lakeshore. Granting it's all so wondrous, why did we have to take down the Gardiner to do any of it? Only because it takes multi-million dollar projects to interest anyone at City Hall who actually does anything. Be vewwy, vewwy afwaid; they may find something to do in your neighbourhood.

Am I the only one who remembers the heady exhileration of coming into Toronto at dusk, back when you couild still see the lake from your car and swweping past those wonderful lit up rails with the red of the setting sun turning the tower windows into fires and grain elevators into beacons? It was art.

Until they, no we, let the beancounters despoil it, using salt that corroded not just the lighting but the rebar, so they could 'justify 'taking it down because, "…it's too expensive to maintain".
 
The bureaucrats are gonna tinker with this and they'll probably make the whole thing worse.

You heard it here first
 
Svend said:
We lost our chance to build a beautiful waterfront when the wall of condos went up over the last decade...
I like it as it is. Not all the structures are to my taste, but generally speaking I enjoy the feeling of being shielded and walled off from the rest off the downtown by a curtain of glass windows. I don't want to feel conected to the noise, ugliness and hustle of Yonge St or Spadina.

We should have checked out how Chicago built a beautiful people friendly area, Toronto had the same potential but blew it

Is this the place?
http://ocaoimh.ie/xeer/images/waterfront.jpg
http://www.kriske.com/TheTrip/chicago/Image28.jpg

Nothing special at ground level if you ask me.

By the way what on earth to you types mean by "people friendly" anyway? How is not people friendly? Are you saying there are Land Mines, Death Squads or man-eating Lions down there now?

Why are condos, shops and venues not "people friendly"? What disqualifies the tens of thousands of individuals who live, work or vist there from counting as "people"?? :confused:
 
A couple of other thoughts:

1. I actually don't mind the Gardiner "that much". That is to say, if they were to tear it down, would they just replace it with more ugly boxes like they are building like weeds down by the SkyDome? To me, that is worse than the Gardiner.

No-one hangs out down there because it's a cold, impersonal wind tunnel. People hand out on Front Street, College Street, Queeen Street, Bloor Street, etc. No-one hangs around Harbourfront except for a few American tourists who don't know any better. The best streets in Toronto are those that just grew.

2. It's kind of neat to drive downtown via the Gardiner and see the view of the City, especially at night. It's downright exhilarating in fact at times.

3. I don't believe for a minute that this "great road" could be completed in 10 years at a cost of 785 million bucks. Just dealing with the utilities under there would cost 500 million. I could see the "great road" costing about 5 billion when all was said and done.

My personal favourite would be to build a queen Street subway line, an Eglinton Line, complete Sheppard, and extend Bloor. As well as more north south lines.

If you have to take down the Gardiner, build a tunnel from the CNE to the DVP and make the Gardiner corridor a park with NO development whatsoever, no condos, no shops, no restaurants, no affordable housing. Just trees, rocks, trails, paths, etc.
 
james t kirk said:
The report recommended that the elevated portion be replaced with a "great road" whatever the hell that is. Essentially, a ten lane road with a boulevard down the middle and development on either side of the road way.
.

As I understood it, that was only one of the three options in the report.

...an artist's conceptual drawing of a nice 10 lane roadway in June with 5 cars on it and pedestrians walking down the street.

I have never seen a bigger pile of steaming bullshit in my life.
On this we can agree - these sketches always show conditions as they would be at 2AM, not during the day. They also edit out the inevitable panhandlers, squeegie kids and trash scavangers who would be attracted by the stop lights, transit shelters and increase in foot traffic.

This report was commissioned by the Toronto Waterfront Redevelopment Agency (Who?). They have a vested interest in the redevelopment of the Railway lands adjacent to Skydome (Robert Fung, and his Hong Kong buddies) and the Portlands...
Hmmm, I wonder if they are trying to shift the core of Toronto westwards to THEIR properties and developments.
True. I didn't hear that question of "Who?" addressed in any of the TV & Radio new items on this report.

I do not believe that this city needs any more expressways whatsoever.
That would be true if we invested in an underground system like London or Paris, along with a ten-fold increase in service levels on surface transit routes, with a symetrical increase in public spending and fares. Otherwise it is foolish to force the city make-do with an infrastructure from 30 years ago unless you baned all immigration and the provice forbade current residents and businesses from moving in or out of the area.

If this city had any balls, we'd tell them, "sure, you can build your new 40 storey Minto Tower, but not at Yonge just south of Eglinton, but in Downsview, or Scarborough"
Yeah, but the problem is there is that people like You would be against building expressways, roads or even Subway extensions to make that workable.

I am all for the tunnel option, but anything else is just rediculous.
The tunnel is the optimum idea, but Toronto couldn't pull it off right. We'd take 8 years to finish it and it would have built in problems to ensure constant work for the contractors, just like every other road here.
 
Last edited:
The lake is right there, people should be able to stroll along it, ride bicycles, hang out, shop in full view of it. The condos separate the people from all that, it's very sterile and not people friendly in my opinion. They should have been kept a distance away from the lake on the north side of Lakeshore Boulevard or Queen's Quay, they'd still have lakefront views in their units and more people would visit the area.
 
Why get rid of something that works? If they wanted to make the lakefront people friendly, you have to demo all those CONDOS and make the area south of the Gardner one HUGE lakefront park, maybe anchoured with a new, expanded CNE on one end and a home for the Beaches Jazz Festival on the other end. But becuase we have those dam CONDOS there, why tear down the Gardner? Could it be because the CONDO owners don't like it?

Just remember to make the city less accessible, we all love the TTC right?
 
The tunnel is the best idea... but I heard somewhere that engineers have thought of it but it's not architectually sound.

Way too much important crap underground (sewers, pipes, cables, etc) so it would be extremely dangerous and costly to move that stuff around.

I think the Gardiner is one ugly piece of crap... it ruins the landscape and skyline (just like the condos they keep building)... and Toronto in general really didn't think ahead when they planned transportation infrastructure.
 
If they do tear it down and rebuild something more useful they will probably charge a toll to use it. Best to leave it alone for now and add transit routes to alleviate the congestion.
 
WhaWhaWha said:
If they do tear it down and rebuild something more useful they will probably charge a toll to use it. Best to leave it alone for now and add transit routes to alleviate the congestion.
They should be charging tolls now: that could cover the maintenance costs and they could be structured to rise as the road clogs up to discourage use at high demand times. Result more people get where they're going faster because the tolls keep usage at peak efficiency instead of peak occupancy. London, Singapore and Stockholm's resoundingly successful central zone 'congestion charges' suggest another useful benefit from tolling the Gardiner—to say nothing of the DVP, Allen, and central part of the 401/427.
 
I voted to tear it down, but with the wall of condos going up it probably doesn't really matter, as even it we tear it down it will just get replaced by more condos .... how they could let that condo crap happen is a crime.

I used to have a condo in a converted, already existing building down in that area. Had a great view of the lake, the islands, the SkyDome, and the CN tower. I sold it as soon as I started seeing them build their first new 30 some story condo. I knew then that my view would be sold out from under me with no compensation ... and I was right. There is no longer any view at all of the lake, the islands, or the SkyDome, and only the very top of the CN Tower can be seen from that building now.
 
james t kirk said:
My personal favourite would be to build a queen Street subway line, an Eglinton Line, complete Sheppard, and extend Bloor. As well as more north south lines.

Yeah, they always seem to have extra billions (which a gardner replacement tunnel would end up costing) to burn on unnecessary projects, while they always make an excuse that subways (worthwhile investment) will cost too much.

James T. Check out my TTC subway plans map,
My_TTC_Subway_Plans_Interactive.html
you can click on the stations and tracks to modify, click 'Create New Map' and post a new url to show your map.
 
Fork Master said:
Yeah, they always seem to have extra billions (which a gardner replacement tunnel would end up costing) to burn on unnecessary projects, while they always make an excuse that subways (worthwhile investment) will cost too much.

James T. Check out my TTC subway plans map,
My_TTC_Subway_Plans_Interactive.html
you can click on the stations and tracks to modify, click 'Create New Map' and post a new url to show your map.


I like your map, the changes I would make would be extend your Queen Street Line from Roncessvailles all the way to Sherway Gardens in the west.

You could run at grade along the existing street car line from Roncessvailles to the food terminal, then drop below grade with stations at Parklawn, the House of Lancaster, Islington, Kipling, East Mall and into Sherway.

Also, I would extend the north south lines to the 407, or further into Richmond Hill with the Yonge line.
 
I actually like the Gardiner. I love the drive through downtown core. At night of course. :) Without it, I'd hate to see the gridlock. Toronto needs a new subway system. FO SHO!!
 
Toronto downtown is slowly imploding on itself. Many businesses are vacating the core for the 905 region and it is a matter of time that the legal firms and such follow suit.

Eventually the hassle of getting there and the bullshit of downtown wears thin on the buying public.

Fuck Toronto! I toiled there day-in and day-out for over a dozen years and the opportunity to work outside of the GTA came and I took advantage of it. What a fucking difference! Fifteen minutes to work and no traffic.

For those who enjoy an hour or two hour communte to the office, no offense, have fun.

As for the Gardiner...JTK is spot on. Without it, Toronto will suffer big time. I only hope they throw out that lefty fucking council. They really are a bunch of fucking whackos!