The Dumb Dumbs from down South

Re: Ok I am from the South of the South..

Tallman1 said:
Yep its true, I am a Southerner which means that I am looked down on by the people that you are looking down on.........

God, that makes me feel really, really bad about myself that I get stereotyped.

Course my stereotype is that those who stereotype are wrong.........oops I just confused myself.......

Is it true that Janet Renno was dancing in Little Rock when she first me Bill????
 
scubadoo said:
You know, swearing just goes to is an indication of how incapable you are of debate. If you disagree with my point of view, opinions and observations, you should clearly state how and why you disagree! I don't mind a debate, but saying it "bullsh*t" isn't debating, it only points to a lack of intelligence on your part.

So, please indicate to me how my assessment is in your words is 'bullsh*t please?

Because Canada is not a socialist country.

Socialism is defined as a type of government that maintains control and ownwership over large key industries, etc.

Here, read the definition for yourself because you obviously flunked political science 101.

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...&client=REAL-tb&oi=defmore&q=define:SOCIALISM

Now, please tell me which key industries that the Canadian gov't owns?

Well, there's VIA Rail. But that's only because no-one in the private sector wants to run passenger trains.

But hey, in the USA, the government owns AMTrack for the same reason.

What else is there, hmmmm, steel?? Nope.

Oil, used to own Petro Canada, but not anymore. Sold that at a big profit (there's capitalism at your finest).

Transportation - Nope

Autos - Nope

Mining - Nope

Forrestry - Nope, and i would even argue that our system is more capitalist than that of the United States where the gov't there levies large taxes in terms of stumpage fees that the Canadian Gov't does not.

Farming - Nope, and again the US farming industry is THE most heavily subsidized farming industry IN THE WORLD.

Here's a link to brighten your horizons....

http://news.google.com/news?q=Unfai...&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&client=REAL-tb&sa=N&tab=nn

What else, health care - well we have universal health care coverage, but they don't own health care. Besides, you won't find too many Canadians who would want an American styled health care system.

Education - The Americans have publically funded education last time I checked.

Canada is a free market economy. You are left to your own devices on just how much you succeed or fail in life. In a lot of ways, it's tougher to make a go of it here because you have to contend with a very tough climate. In the States, the climate is more favourable.

So I repeat, your post is BULLSHIT, and I now add that you don't have a clue of what you are talking about.

Cheers
 
Ask yourself this though bbking, which country has been more successfull with their system?? Canada or the USA??
Seems to me that the U.S. is slightly richer, slightly more powerful and I use the term 'slightly' loosely.
You cant argue with success now can you??
 
james t kirk said:
Because Canada is not a socialist country.

Socialism is defined as a type of government that maintains control and ownwership over large key industries, etc.

Here, read the definition for yourself because you obviously flunked political science 101.

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...&client=REAL-tb&oi=defmore&q=define:SOCIALISM

Now, please tell me which key industries that the Canadian gov't owns?

Well, there's VIA Rail. But that's only because no-one in the private sector wants to run passenger trains.

But hey, in the USA, the government owns AMTrack for the same reason.

What else is there, hmmmm, steel?? Nope.

Oil, used to own Petro Canada, but not anymore. Sold that at a big profit (there's capitalism at your finest).

Transportation - Nope

Autos - Nope

Mining - Nope

Forrestry - Nope, and i would even argue that our system is more capitalist than that of the United States where the gov't there levies large taxes in terms of stumpage fees that the Canadian Gov't does not.

Farming - Nope, and again the US farming industry is THE most heavily subsidized farming industry IN THE WORLD.

Here's a link to brighten your horizons....

http://news.google.com/news?q=Unfai...&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&client=REAL-tb&sa=N&tab=nn

What else, health care - well we have universal health care coverage, but they don't own health care. Besides, you won't find too many Canadians who would want an American styled health care system.

Education - The Americans have publically funded education last time I checked.

Canada is a free market economy. You are left to your own devices on just how much you succeed or fail in life. In a lot of ways, it's tougher to make a go of it here because you have to contend with a very tough climate. In the States, the climate is more favourable.

So I repeat, your post is BULLSHIT, and I now add that you don't have a clue of what you are talking about.

Cheers


I agree to disagree with you.

I believe that our gov't is too involved in the marketplace to consider canada a capitalist society. We lean to socialism. Everytime you turn around one industry or sector is asking for a gov't handout. Bombardier, The beef industry, banking ( lack of letting the free market forces to bear etc etc.....

I still believe that your need for swearing is unwarranted. But you have atleast put up a much better arguement this time than just stating 'thats bullshit". My congrats for putting together an arguement!
 
bbking said:
Ok I will take you up on that, we do encourage people to start new business with at least in Ontario, the lowest corporate tax rate in the Great Lakes basin. We have great Universities for higher education, and while our public school system could be better - we consistently beat US public schools.
Our society can hardley be called a society of socialism, maybe compared to the US, but the benchmark for cradle to grave society is Sweden and Sweden has the highest taxes in the Western World and a very high suicide rate. Canada is not even as socialist as some moderate Europian countries, like France, GB, Germany. We are some where in the middle. The Canadian idea is that those of us who have thrived in our society must contribute to those who do not do well for one reason or another (not just lazy). This results in a higher income tax, but personally I don't mind it because the alternative is US society, which in the last twenty years has clearly broken down to the haves and have nots. As a result crime in Canada is lower per capita than the US. The one thing about crime - it's not an ethnic thing the root cause of crime is poverty which the US has much higher per capita rate. On the positive side the US certainly has more millionares per capita than Canada does. Personally I think the HAVES created the Myth of the American dream to keep those who have failed thinking that it is there fault. Clinton started the US down a more Canadian philosophy with his welfare reform - referring to his program as a hand up not a hand out.
As in any philosophy ( that is what Capitalism is) taking it to extremes can be bad. I feel the Canadian approach is the more practicle approach.

bbk

Some good points bb. I enjoy the dabate. From what you have posted I guess we can say that Canadian is a Social-Capitalist State. My agruement to being with was that Canada and the US are two very different cultures. In the US everything seems to lead back to the dollar, we in Canada while the dollar is not as important to us.
 
scubadoo said:
I agree to disagree with you.

I believe that our gov't is too involved in the marketplace to consider canada a capitalist society. We lean to socialism. Everytime you turn around one industry or sector is asking for a gov't handout. Bombardier, The beef industry, banking ( lack of letting the free market forces to bear etc etc.....

I still believe that your need for swearing is unwarranted. But you have atleast put up a much better arguement this time than just stating 'thats bullshit". My congrats for putting together an arguement!

While Bombardier gets loans from the Federal Gov't, they are loans, and not gifts for the most part. And for that Bombardier produces hard final run end run consumer products. Not iron ore, or coal, or potash, or wood, but trains and planes. And they are pretty good at it too. (Despite what David Gunn might tell you.)

And gov't subsidies to industry also occur south of the boarder I can assure you. Even more so than they do here. Everywhere from McDonalds (true) to the defence insdustry (in spades).

And we won't even begin to talk about US protectionism.
 
nearlynormal said:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
originally posted by johnnyhandsome:

"Ask yourself this though bbking, which country has been more successfull with their system?? Canada or the USA??
Seems to me that the U.S. is slightly richer, slightly more powerful and I use the term 'slightly' loosely.
You cant argue with success now can you??"
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I guess it depends on how you'd define success. A few examples:

About 1 of every 7 Americans (43 million people) are without health insurance. In Canada we are almost universally covered.

http://www.kaisernetwork.org/health_cast/hcast_index.cfm?display=detail&hc=1096

The murder rate in the US is triple that of Canada and the American rate of incarceration is over 5 times as high.

http://www.npb-cnlc.gc.ca/reports/pdf/pls_2002/08_e.htm

Canada also outstrips the US in the area of social development or overall quality of life, life expecatancy, education, literacy, distrubution of wealth etc.

http://www.ccsd.ca/pubs/2002/olympic/indicators.htm

OHIP isnt doing so well and in the States you can buy Blue Cross for $1,200 a year.

Murder rates stats are dwarfed byt inner city killings. If you live ina middle class area you wont get shot at everyday, get real!!

If Canada had a higher incarceration rate then maybe we wouldnt have mothers paralyzed at sandwich store shootings.

And who will Canada call on if it's attacked by say Russia???
The canadian armed forces??
Dont make me laugh, they are mediocre at best.

And by the way.......... I'm a Canadian!!!!
 
OK, That one ...

really pisses me off.

Lets really get real: Why in the world would anyone attack Canada except because of our proximity to the United States.

Canadian Forces are peacekeepers. Have been since the last world war. The world knows and respects it.

The fact that geography binds us beside war mongers puts us at great risk ONLY from those trying a side entrance to the United States. And makes us damned uncomfortable allies.

BTW, "Attacked by Russia"? What century are you living in?
 
Re: OK, That one ...

LeatherDoll said:
BTW, "Attacked by Russia"? What century are you living in?
Be careful Leather Doll, don't mess with god's gift to women or the handsome one might deny you his "pleasures"! hahaha
 
Re: OK, That one ...

LeatherDoll said:
Canada are peacekeepers. Always have been. The world knows and respects it.

Sigh.

We certainly like to tell ourselves that, don't we? Too bad its not really true.

First of all, the thousands and thousands of brave Canadians who died in World War I, World War II, and Korea would likely roll over in their graves at that suggestion, but lets assume you're only referring to 1956 (Suez) and beyond.

Was Canada essential in the creation of UN peacekeeping efforts? Absolutely. But that's no more relevant today than the "Invaded by Russia" comment you sneered at.

If we're such great peacekeepers, why are there dozens of countries that contribute more soldiers to UN peacekeeping missions than we do? According to the CBC, "of the 49,000 troops deployed on U.N. peacekeeping operations around the world only 252, or one-half of one per cent are Canadian." The roughly 3000 other soldiers that we have in "peacekeeping" roles are serving in U.S. led forces or NATO.

Were we peacekeepers when we bombed Kosovo (right or wrong) in 1999? How about our participation in the first Gulf War?

We can say how wonderful and superior we are all we want - it doesn't make it true.
 
Re: OK, That one ...

LeatherDoll said:
BTW, "Attacked by Russia"? What century are you living in?

Ever heard of the term "hypothetically". OK, insert any other country besides Russia. Unless of course you think that we could never ever possibly be attacked.
 
Hell, with the current state of our military Belgium could take us in a matter of weeks. Our defence budget is so small that it has become a joke worldwide.
 
johnnyhandsome said:
Hell, with the current state of our military Belgium could take us in a matter of weeks. Our defence budget is so small that it has become a joke worldwide.

Canada's military defense expendature as a percent of GDP is 1.1%. The USA's is 3.2%. Not a huge difference, although Canada certainly has one of the lower expendatures in the world. I will cheerfully agree that Canada ought to have higher defense spending. Why? Not for "defense" or because we need to go to war. The military provdies employment and, more importantly, cheap education for the middle and lower class. A well-funded military provides job opportunities and the chance for better jobs in the future for people who might otherwise spend the rest of their days in McDonalds.

Would anyone care to guess which countries have the highest military expendature as a percent of GDP?

North Korea: 33.9%
Ethiopia: 12.6%

Both countries, of course, have better things to be spending their money on. Like food. Sometimes huge military spending is not a good thing...Israel only spends 8.75%, for God's sake!

Facts from the CIA World Fact Book.

PS Belgium only has 1.4%....
 
Drunken Master said:
Canada's military defense expendature as a percent of GDP is 1.1%. The USA's is 3.2%. Not a huge difference, although Canada certainly has one of the lower expendatures in the world. I will cheerfully agree that Canada ought to have higher defense spending. Why? Not for "defense" or because we need to go to war. The military provdies employment and, more importantly, cheap education for the middle and lower class. A well-funded military provides job opportunities and the chance for better jobs in the future for people who might otherwise spend the rest of their days in McDonalds.

Would anyone care to guess which countries have the highest military expendature as a percent of GDP?

North Korea: 33.9%
Ethiopia: 12.6%

Both countries, of course, have better things to be spending their money on. Like food. Sometime huge military spending is not a good thing...Israel only spends 8.75%, for God's sake!

Facts from the CIA World Fact Book.

PS Belgium only has 1.4%....

LOL.....you looked all that up.
For the first time I fully agree with Drunkie.
Canada was proud of our military during WW2 but it has become dilapidated. The reason is because we have big Brother USA next door who would quickly come to our rescue.
 
Actually, ...

You're right Shake, we aren't as peacekeeping as we would like. However, my point remains. The only reason anyone would attack Canada is because of proximity to the US.

And, I'm not so sure that increased military spending is necessary. If you want to see employment, housing, education, etc. provided, then spend the money there. Increase minimum wage, subsidize housing, freeze tuition, increase transfer payments, enforce any policy on violence against women, provide day-care, ...

These are the kinds of things for which we pay taxes (apart from infrastructure). Call me advanced, but I strongly believe that the way to decrease hate and violence is to create a well fed, well housed, working, populace.

Mr. WarMonger, please, go ahead and join the military. I would be willing to be if you did you would be MP. The military available now is sufficient to stave off immediate assault. Canada has plenty of allies, I doubt we'd fight alone. I doubt more that we'd ever have to fight.

There are others of us, who live where it snows on purpose. Not because we like the cold, but because we prefer to be somewhere that the corporate military agenda doesn't drive our entire economy, and threateen to bring the world to its imminent collapse in the process.

In case you haven't noticed, violence has long been demonstrated to be an inefficient method of dispute resolution.
 
I think you miss my point. The main reason why Canada has never been atttacked and has been able to flourish economically is because we are next to and protected by the ole USA. And instead of the occasional "Thank You', the americans instead get tons of anti-americanism thrown their way on the media here and by lots of people in general. This really bothers me and I wish there was less of it.

Thats my whole point.
 
johnnyhandsome said:
The main reason why Canada has never been atttacked and has been able to flourish economically is because we are next to and protected by the ole USA.
Attacked? Are we talking about recently? or in the past? In the past we were too far away. And recently why was Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands ... etc not attacked because they are next to and protected by the ol' USA? Why was the USA attacked because it was not "next to and protected" by the USA? Well at least you are handsome. :p I am just waiting for your usual childish comeback such as ... "And you Peeping Tom, would be first to cry for the americans to help out if we were attacked. Actually they would be 2nd, your mommy would be 1st. " Ahahaha

johnnyhandsome said:
And instead of the occasional "Thank You', the americans instead get tons of anti-americanism thrown their way on the media here and by lots of people in general. This really bothers me and I wish there was less of it.
Anti-American? So Anti-Bush / Anti-neocon / anti-rightwing is Anti-American? There must be a lot of Anti-American Americans.

johnnyhandsome said:
Thats my whole point.
Was it your whole whole point? hehehe Then say what you mean man!
 
And you Peeping Tom, would be first to cry for the americans to help out if we were attacked. Actually they would be 2nd, your mommy would be 1st.
 
Your right ...

It had nothing to do with hard work (and endentured servitude), inventiveness, creativity, our Common Law grounding, our seemingly enless supply of natural resources and agricultural territory, our socialist/humanistic public policy that desires a minimum standard of living for all citizens, tolerance of differences, visionaries, . . .

What, do you think all our ancestors landed in Canada because they got lost on the way to the US?

We started as a British Commenwealth. I would venture to say that this had more to do with our success than our proximity to our neighbours to the South. Duh!