the Conservative ship is sinking

lookingforitallthetime said:
LMAO.....you really are pathetic.....

Look, do you have anything to say about the facts that I've given you, or are you just going to be a giggling little child who can't stop laughing because "you said pooh"?

The fact is that your 14% cut on 7% amounts to 1% off the gross cost of a GST taxable item. A 1% cut to anything is insignificant. For those who can only afford to splurge on a $10 item, a "14%" cut to the GST doesn't mean they can now afford to splurge on a $100 item, or a $50 item, a $20 item, or even a $11 item. They can now splurge on a $10.10 item.

If you are a rich enough to splurge on a $100,000 item, then the extra $1000 is hardly going to turn your life around either.

Of course, you could just go on being a good little Neo-con puppet and ignore the meat of the discussion and focus on some minor and basically meaningless mistake. Grow up please and deal with actual facts for once in your life.
 
LancsLad said:
Apples and oranges again woolf. Larger capital purchases are generally not made yearly on things like cars, boats,houses etc. However, most people do make them at some point and that is where the savings kick in.

It really seems to piss you off that a gov't in power actually did something to benefit the wealth producers in Canada. That in itself speaks volumes.

When did I ever say that I was pissed off that they did something to benefit the "wealth producers"?

I readily acknowledge that that's exactly what they did.

The problem is that that is not what they told us they were doing, and that is not how they still are presenting it. This was supposedly sold as a benefit for low income earners, but the lowest of the low income earners don't have the disposable cash to spend on GST taxable items, and the low income earners that can spend a little bit on GST taxable items have lost it all and then some on an income tax grab.

But I seem to have had at least one success, at least you are now admitting that you recognize that the only people who will actually benefit from a GST cut like this are the top couple of percent or so of tax payers who can afford to buy large ticket items once or twice in their lives, and has absolutely nothing to do with benefiting the poor.
 
Woolf dude , take a deep breath and relax. So you say the tax reduction is insignificant, fine thats your choice. Bet you would also complain if it went up by 1%. There is just no pleasing you.
 
woolf said:
Look, do you have anything to say about the facts that I've given you, or are you just going to be a giggling little child who can't stop laughing because "you said pooh"?

The fact is that your 14% cut on 7% amounts to 1% off the gross cost of a GST taxable item. A 1% cut to anything is insignificant. For those who can only afford to splurge on a $10 item, a "14%" cut to the GST doesn't mean they can now afford to splurge on a $100 item, or a $50 item, a $20 item, or even a $11 item. They can now splurge on a $10.10 item.

If you are a rich enough to splurge on a $100,000 item, then the extra $1000 is hardly going to turn your life around either.

Of course, you could just go on being a good little Neo-con puppet and ignore the meat of the discussion and focus on some minor and basically meaningless mistake. Grow up please and deal with actual facts for once in your life.

Poor woolfy.

You're really going to be upset when the GST goes down another point.
 
woolf said:
When did I ever say that I was pissed off that they did something to benefit the "wealth producers"?

I readily acknowledge that that's exactly what they did.

The problem is that that is not what they told us they were doing, and that is not how they still are presenting it. This was supposedly sold as a benefit for low income earners, but the lowest of the low income earners don't have the disposable cash to spend on GST taxable items, and the low income earners that can spend a little bit on GST taxable items have lost it all and then some on an income tax grab.

But I seem to have had at least one success, at least you are now admitting that you recognize that the only people who will actually benefit from a GST cut like this are the top couple of percent or so of tax payers who can afford to buy large ticket items once or twice in their lives, and has absolutely nothing to do with benefiting the poor.



I make NO such concession. A consumption tax cut benefits everyone who spends.
 
Children, you miss the point altogether, I can only hope that it's on purpose and that you really do understand that the Cons have not put money in your pocket, but instead have removed it (ever wonder why they brag about the GST "cut", but you never hear a word about the income tax increase?) and that you are only pretending to be this ignorant because you have so much invested in believing that the Cons would never make fools of you ... no wonder the Cons can so easily lie to you.
 
woolf said:
Children, you miss the point altogether, I can only hope that it's on purpose and that you really do understand that the Cons have not put money in your pocket, but instead have removed it (ever wonder why they brag about the GST "cut", but you never hear a word about the income tax increase?) and that you are only pretending to be this ignorant because you have so much invested in believing that the Cons would never make fools of you ... no wonder the Cons can so easily lie to you.



Children are we now oh wise and learned one. We will never agree on anything here since your abject hatred of the Conservatives makes that impossible. I'll take any kind of tax cut any day and so will the voters.
 
You didn't get a tax cut ... your overall taxes increased ... that's the point. Pretend you're a real person with an independent mind and do the math for yourself.

GST cut from 7% to 6% (remember, most major recurring expenses such as rent, mortgage, and groceries, are not GST applicable.)

vs

0% tax on the first $8,548 down from 0% on the first $9,048. (ie. $500 more that is taxable at 15.25%)

plus

$8,648 - $36,378 taxable at 15.25% up from $9,048 - $36,378 taxable at 14%.

Come on, prove to me that you understand the situation. For once, don't take the work of the CPC without question, check out their claims and see if what they say is correct.
 
LancsLad said:
Children are we now oh wise and learned one. We will never agree on anything here since your abject hatred of the Conservatives makes that impossible. I'll take any kind of tax cut any day and so will the voters.

I hope the voters keep Harper in long enough to drop it to 5%. It's not a windfall, but it's money in my pocket instead of Ottawa's. I'm one of those selfish bastards that's all for that.

I wonder what woolf would say if the Liberals won the next election and raised it back up to 7%?
 
Its only a matter of time before the Conservatives choke on their own shit. The Liberals handed them the last election in a gift wrapped package known as Gomery and the best they could do was a slim minority?

Get used to another Liberal government by the spring time...
 
Argocock said:
Its only a matter of time before the Conservatives choke on their own shit. The Liberals handed them the last election in a gift wrapped package known as Gomery and the best they could do was a slim minority?

Get used to another Liberal government by the spring time...

Think so? i don't see any leadership. Who do you see?
 
You guys kill me


so many posts from operatives so little time to the election:confused:
 
Argocock said:
Its only a matter of time before the Conservatives choke on their own shit. The Liberals handed them the last election in a gift wrapped package known as Gomery and the best they could do was a slim minority?

Get used to another Liberal government by the spring time...

Strangely enough, it wasn't Ad Scam that led to the Libs dowwfall (even though it should have been enough), it was poor leadership.

Considering the front runners in the Liberal leadership race, your optimism is unfounded.
 
Ramming through the motion isn't keeping any commitment. It's prolonging the Conservative's callous stupidity in prolonging the sight of our lads in khaki coming back in coffins.

lookingforitallthetime said:
"rammed through a motion"?

OK, I'll bite......It's the party that's keeping our committments to the UN. or actually doing what it said it would do. I know this is a foreign concept to all the Liberal supporters out there.
 
I will gladly step in to fill the void ( as you see it at the top of the Conservative Party) but many people wouldn't like my policies, in fact the only ones that would , would be the people who actually work and produce the wealth in this country.
 
canadian_liberal said:
And im not to sure if Ignatieff will win the upcoming leadership race. Its going to be a race between Dion (Yes, i Know hes 3rd or 4th after the first ballot polls - but so was Mcguinty in the Provincial Leadership race.) and Rae.

I agree. The Liberal party has a history (I've heard its even an unwritten law within the party) of rotating French and English canadian leaders. If the trend continues, Dion should get it.

I also think 4th palce Kennedy is the best candidate
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Considering it's a 1% saving on GST, you only make purchases of $200 a month?????? You must ride a bicycle home to your cardboard box.

You can scoff at the savings if you want, I'll say thank you very much Mr. Harper!
Just how much of the gst savings actually got passed down to the end user?
 
guelph said:
Just how much of the gst savings actually got passed down to the end user?

Check with woolfy, he's the numbers guy.


I'm just the dumbass that considers a tax break, no matter how small, a good thing. If you're smart, you'll enjoy it while you can. Bob Rae could be your next PM.
 
guelph said:
Just how much of the gst savings actually got passed down to the end user?

From what I've seen of my purchasing habits, of the goods and services I purchase that apply GST to their charges, retail outlets, Cable, Phone, Internet, have all lowered their tax rates. Whether they've increased their charges by that 1% or not is unclear and hard to tell.

Gas is impossible to tell, as the GST isn't easily broken out of the cost, and even if you go through the effort, who the hell can tell whether the 1% was passed on to the purchaser, or was simply absorbed into the overall price and handed back to the distributer?

I do know that my insurance charges have not changed a bit since the GST cut so they have taken the 1% and put it towards their bottom line. I have them take out monthly payments directly from my account, and it is the same amount taken out now as it was before the GST cut ... nor have I received any notice of a GST adjustment either (I have though, received notice that my rates will be going up as of next month as my postal code has had a new actuarial reassessment and it turns out they weren't making enough profit from me even with no accidents.)