the Conservative ship is sinking

peteeey said:
Thanks to the Conservatives, our lads in Afghanistan are coming back in coffins.



They went during the libs occupation of Ottawa, and the risk of death, while tragic comes with the territory when you are in the Military.
 
Other Wanderer said:
But to make a statement like yours, when the conservatives have done nothing to help the country on a long-term basis of consequence, is just silly.
Everything the conservatives have done has been for long term - FTA, GST, a home made clean air plan that is attainable, accountability reform, Afganistan.............Where have you been??
 
Which party rammed through a motion to prolong the military mission in Afghanistan by two more years?

LancsLad said:
They went during the libs occupation of Ottawa, and the risk of death, while tragic comes with the territory when you are in the Military.
 
peteeey said:
Which party rammed through a motion to prolong the military mission in Afghanistan by two more years?

"rammed through a motion"?

OK, I'll bite......It's the party that's keeping our committments to the UN. or actually doing what it said it would do. I know this is a foreign concept to all the Liberal supporters out there.

I find it funny that some on this board are quick to critisize the measley 1% reduction in the GST. If you can't appreciate the extra cash in your pocket, you should be able to appreciate the fact that a campaign promise that was kept. When was the last time that happened?

If I recall, about 13 years ago, a funny looking guy from Shawinigan promised to abolish the GST altogether. Which party was that?
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Considering it's a 1% saving on GST, you only make purchases of $200 a month?????? You must ride a bicycle home to your cardboard box.

You can scoff at the savings if you want, I'll say thank you very much Mr. Harper!

Have you ever bothered to consider what "purchases" you make that get charged GST?

I make purchases each month that comes to far more than $200, but all the major ones (shelter & food) are GST exempt.

Gas may technically have a GST component, but since it is all hidden, who the hell knows if I got that cut or the oil companies.

Also, car insurance technically may have a GST component as well, but the insurance company hasn't notified me yet as to the my new lower payment, and the automatic payments haven't changed any since the GST cut. So either I'm wrong and there is no GST on insurance, or as usual, we are getting screwed by another set of right wing pirates.

As for "scoffing" at the savings, there is no savings ... the Cons are eliminating a Liberal personal income tax cut, which more than makes up for any imagined GST savings you think you're getting.
 
Nothing will ever deter crime, and when you through one scumbag in jail another will take his place. With that said i much rather see career criminals locked up forever.
 
Except when you do implement a "tough on crime" punitive justice system you always end up with more crime than if you have a system that concentrated on prevention and rehabilitation.

So your way of thinking adds to the problem you are demanding be fixed ... they used to think that it was so obvious that the heavier something is, the faster it would fall to the earth. No one could convince them that weight did not matter, because good old "common sense" told them that anyone claiming a light object fell at the same speed as a heavy object has a screw loose, or was trying to con them ... yes, it sure sounds "right" that having laws that are tough on crime would be the correct way to go about reducing crime, but like that old "heavy object fall faster than light object" myth, it just isn't so.
 
woolf said:
I make purchases each month that comes to far more than $200, but all the major ones (shelter & food) are GST exempt.

I guess you don't go to too many restaurants.

You can argue that a 14% reduction in a sales tax is insignificant if you want. As for me, I've grown tired of the idiocy.
 
Woolf, next time you drop 80K on a Vette or 100 for a Rover or 115 for the XKR the savings in GST alone will pay for a few SP's. While the average savings per person on incidentals is small, it is significant money when you buy capital type goods. Also consider the direction of the tax change, it was a DECREASE which I'll take any time over an increase. Farking liberals.
 
a 14% reduction of 15% IS insignificant.

Ok, let's say I am a relatively well off (and I am all things considered) and I take my family out to a $40 lunch every weekend. 1% of $40 is 40 cents. A whole month of this wild savings will net me another $1.60.

Yes, I'm sure there are some single guys out there making as much or money than I, and eat at restaurants every day, and after spending $1200 a month on restaurants they actually save whole $12.

Now we must also remember that the CPC did away with the Liberal $500 increase in the income where tax would not be paid, and the 1% cut in the lowest tax bracket.

That means in order to get this 1% meaningless GST break I will be paying 15.25% tax on that $500, losing $76.25 on that.

Then there is the loss of the 1% cut on the lowest income tax bracket (or in reality 1.25% since they not only killed the cut of 15% to 14%, but added another 0.25% on top for good measure. So my income between $8,648 - $36,378, or $27,730 will be taxed an extra 1.25%; So I lose another $277.30 on that little deal.

OK, so I'm losing $277.30 + $76.25, or $353.55 in income tax reductions. So how much do I have to spend on GST taxable items before I break even?

It works out that I have to spend $35,355 (or almost $3000 a month, almost $750 a week) on GST taxable items to make up for those income tax increases.

So let's see, I pay about $50 a week on phone, cable and Internet, and let's say another $50 a week on gas, then let's just say I buy so much toilet paper and cleaning products that I spend another $50 a week on those. So that leaves me with another $600 a week I need to spend to break even. So if I was "smart" I'd be out there spending another $100 a day on restaurant food so I can compensate for my income tax increases ... is that the kind of "idiocy" you're talking about?
 
LancsLad said:
Woolf, next time you drop 80K on a Vette or 100 for a Rover or 115 for the XKR the savings in GST alone will pay for a few SP's. While the average savings per person on incidentals is small, it is significant money when you buy capital type goods. Also consider the direction of the tax change, it was a DECREASE which I'll take any time over an increase. Farking liberals.

But the GST cut was suppose to be a cut that was meant for low income earners, and while the direction of the GST might be "DOWN", the direction of your income tax is going UP ... in the lowest tax bracket from 14% to 15.25%.

If all your salary is in the lowest tax bracket, then you're going to have to spend every cent of it (before taxes) on non rent and food items in order to see a break even point between the "gain" in GST, and the loss in income tax cuts.

Low income families just got royally screwed, and you all believe that they did you a favour. The Cons conned you again.
 
Can't compare the two areas. Income taxes and consumption taxes touch on different areas.

The lib $500 increase in base threshold was not an absolute savings but a ratchet up of the base that the lowest marginal rate would be applied to. You can not say that it then represented a $500 savings to each taxpayer.

The reduction in the GST applies to all people who spend money Also the GST rate went from 7 to 6 that was a 14% reduction in the fed component. DO NOT try to cloud the issue by combining GST and PST from the old 15% combined to the new 14% in a FALSE attempt to show a reduced impact. The Ontario 8% component remained unchanged.
 
LancsLad said:
Woolf, next time you drop 80K on a Vette or 100 for a Rover or 115 for the XKR the savings in GST alone will pay for a few SP's. While the average savings per person on incidentals is small, it is significant money when you buy capital type goods. Also consider the direction of the tax change, it was a DECREASE which I'll take any time over an increase. Farking liberals.

woolfy says he's buying a new car. He also says he's successful. If I purchased the last car I bought a year later, I would have saved $800.

Woolfy reminds me of my ex-wife, the more money you give him, the more he bitches.
 
LancsLad said:
Can't compare the two areas. Income taxes and consumption taxes touch on different areas.

The lib $500 increase in base threshold was not an absolute savings but a ratchet up of the base that the lowest marginal rate would be applied to. You can not say that it then represented a $500 savings to each taxpayer.

The reduction in the GST applies to all people who spend money Also the GST rate went from 7 to 6 that was a 14% reduction in the fed component. DO NOT try to cloud the issue by combining GST and PST from the old 15% combined to the new 14% in a FALSE attempt to show a reduced impact. The Ontario 8% component remained unchanged.

Ok, 14% of 7% is insignificant as well.

I didn't say it was a $500 saving, I said it was a $76.25 loss.

Most people earn income, and especially those who spend money, on which GST can be applied, so income tax is just as important as GST. It's not as though there are two classes of people. One class that pays income tax, and another class that pays GST.

And if we examine those people who will not be affected by the income tax increases, we have people who earn $8,648 or less. Now after rent and food (which are not GST taxable) how much money do you suppose is left to spend on that Vette so they can get that big GST break?
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
woolfy says he's buying a new car. He also says he's successful. If I purchased the last car I bought a year later, I would have saved $800.

Woolfy reminds me of my ex-wife, the more money you give him, the more he bitches.



You may be onto something there. I bought $200K of cars in '05, that same purchase after Jul 06 would have saved me enough for a few more SP visits. See the Tories are good at "stimulating" the economy.
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by woolf
a 14% reduction of 15% IS insignificant.

Actually, it's a 14% reduction of 7% not 15%

Quote:
Originally Posted by woolf
is that the kind of "idiocy" you're talking about?


Yes

Sorry, I made a mistake. I actually didn't bother to check up on your statement:

You can argue that a 14% reduction in a sales tax is insignificant if you want.

When you said it was a reduction on sales tax, I assumed that because the PST (provincial SALES tax) is a SALES tax, and the GST (is a goods and service tax) that you had already done the figuring and used both taxes.

Fortunately that's the only figure I relied on from you, so the rest of my numbers are correct.

So other than making the mistake of relying on you to properly word your statements, the facts remain that the income tax increases totally wipe out any possible savings from a 14% GST cut.
 
woolf said:
Sorry, I made a mistake. I actually didn't bother to check up on your statement:



When you said it was a reduction on sales tax, I assumed that because the PST (provincial SALES tax) is a SALES tax, and the GST (is a goods and service tax) that you had already done the figuring and used both taxes.

Fortunately that's the only figure I relied on from you, so the rest of my numbers are correct.

So other than making the mistake of relying on you to properly word your statements, the facts remain that the income tax increases totally wipe out any possible savings from a 14% GST cut.

LMAO.....you really are pathetic.....I said it was a 14% reduction on a sales tax. I consider GST a sales tax, but I know how you get bogged down in semantics.

Anyway, you're the guy with all the answers......you should have been able to follow along.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
woolfy says he's buying a new car. He also says he's successful. If I purchased the last car I bought a year later, I would have saved $800.

Woolfy reminds me of my ex-wife, the more money you give him, the more he bitches.

I didn't say I was buying a "new" car, and I said I was relatively successful given the average income.

I'm not complaining because I'm being given money, because in fact I've not been given any ... if anything I've had money taken away from me.

I'm going to buy a 2nd car, and it's not going to be over $10K, so at best that's $100 in GST savings, which doesn't make up for the $353.55 the CPC is grabbing from me in income tax increases.
 
Apples and oranges again woolf. Larger capital purchases are generally not made yearly on things like cars, boats,houses etc. However, most people do make them at some point and that is where the savings kick in.

It really seems to piss you off that a gov't in power actually did something to benefit the wealth producers in Canada. That in itself speaks volumes.