The 8 White Identities

You kinda miss the point of this thread. The thread was started by Oracle, who was playing his usual game of finding the most outrageous "woke" quote or news item and posting it, so he could then argue with and insult any non far righties who came onto the thread. He does this 2 or 3 times every day.

Then people came on and called him out and then there were comments that the news item could be a hoax and that maybe the subject of the article was okay to teach university students, but not high schoolers. Then the thread evolved into an argument about "white privilege". Phil said that articles like that degraded race relations and he got called by Paola, who said that race relations were way worse - from a Black PoV - when Blacks were slaves.

No one demanded any form of restitution or payments.
I didn’t miss the point. My original question was to ask the definition of white/black because I don’t think generalizations are healthy to believe in. The thread evolved into race and slavery. Kinda proving my point that holding all people to a stereotype or generalization based on skin colour is not a healthy belief.
 
If you continue to judge people today based on actions other generations did yesterday you will have a very heavy heart in this world. It’s clear you hold some bitterness. Slavery existing and it was horrific. ( all wealthy land owners did it, irrelevant of race)

What do you want the generations of today to do about it.

No one is judging people on past actions, many white peoples current actions perpetuate racism and racist stereotypes and misinformation.

That being said, white people and even me as a light skin, racially ambiguous mixed raced woman benefit from white supremacy and the systems of superiority it has created. I do my part to try and dismantle racism where I see it, I expect white people to their part too.

The trans Atlantic slave trade wasnt based on class, anyone who says this is either ignorant or obtuse. There is sufficient evidence from that period that shows that white people thought Black people were a less evolved "species" of homo sapiens. There is writing that shows that white people thought Black people couldn't take care of themselves and therefore needed their masters to control them. History and existing academia doesn't substantiate any of the ramblings most of you in this thread have been advancing. My only solace is that the younger generations are well educated on these matters and that we will hopefully see progress from it.
 
If you continue to judge people today based on actions other generations did yesterday you will have a very heavy heart in this world. It’s clear you hold some bitterness. Slavery existing and it was horrific. ( all wealthy land owners did it, irrelevant of race)

What do you want the generations of today to do about it.
I read this woman's, I mean she/her as she would like to be addressed, reply to a video I posted on the first page. More than once too- it's a very impressive word salad. Google word salad if you get sec. I was going to reply but I needed more time than I had and responsibilities took precedence. When I came back it became quite clear what I suspected after reading her word salad from her subsequent posts.

She's bitter and I left it alone. To answer your last question- take the knee.
 
No one is judging people on past actions, many white peoples current actions perpetuate racism and racist stereotypes and misinformation
Judging by this thread you do exactly the same thing
 
No one is judging people on past actions, many white peoples current actions perpetuate racism and racist stereotypes and misinformation.

That being said, white people and even me as a light skin, racially ambiguous mixed raced woman benefit from white supremacy and the systems of superiority it has created. I do my part to try and dismantle racism where I see it, I expect white people to their part too.

The trans Atlantic slave trade wasnt based on class, anyone who says this is either ignorant or obtuse. There is sufficient evidence from that period that shows that white people thought Black people were a less evolved "species" of homo sapiens. There is writing that shows that white people thought Black people couldn't take care of themselves and therefore needed their masters to control them. History and existing academia doesn't substantiate any of the ramblings most of you in this thread have been advancing. My only solace is that the younger generations are well educated on these matters and that we will hopefully see progress from it.
Hopefully see progress? Lol. It’s not 1955 Alabama. Btw, the world isn’t flat either. You’re being very Obtuse
 
Hopefully see progress? Lol. It’s not 1955 Alabama. Btw, the world isn’t flat either. You’re being very Obtuse

Uh huh, well this has been very fun but I have 3 research papers due in the next week and unlike yall I have to actually critically engage with academic readings and present logical arguments instead of spouting off misinformation and buzzwords while using logically fallacies like straw man arguments and red herrings
 
Yeah, sure you do :rolleyes:
Im a full time political science student. I have a paper due on Aristotles "art of rhetoric" book 1 chapter 4 tomorrow, an analysis of the development of NGO self regulation in 6 African countries on Friday and a "take home exam" which is 2 sort essays one on populist movements like trumpism and brexit and the other on theories of why non-violent movements are often more successful due Tuesday, then a midterm on Platos Gorgias and Aristotle art of rhetoric Thursday and an outline for my paper on whether markets caused the financial crisis or too much government intervention for my international political economy class due Friday :-) then I'm going on my Ontario tour and I hope none of you book me lmao. But I'll also have to prepare my legal arguments for the osgoode moot tournament ;-) so my availability will be limited on my tour anyway. Really I'm just coming to snuggle Mena and her puppy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Im a full time political science student. I have a paper due on Aristotles "art of rhetoric" book 1 chapter 4 tomorrow, an analysis of the development of NGO self regulation in 6 African countries on Friday and a "take home exam" which is 2 sort essays one on populist movements like trumpism and brexit and the other on theories of why non-violent movements are often more successful due Tuesday, then a midterm on Platos Gorgias and Aristotle art of rhetoric Thursday and an outline for my paper on whether markets caused the financial crisis or too much government intervention for my international political economy class due Friday :) then I'm going on my Ontario tour and I hope none of you book me lmao. But I'll also have to prepare my legal arguments for the osgoode moot tournament ;-) so my availability will be limited on my tour anyway. Really I'm just coming to snuggle Mena and her puppy.
I took a political science course once. The secret to get a good grade was to repeat back to the professor his lessons and conclusions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phil C. McNasty
I took a political science course once. The secret to get a good grade was to repeat back to the professor his lessons and conclusions.

I have a 3.87 cgpa, I know what I'm doing :) which includes not coming to conclusions on a whole discipline or all teachers based on a single course you took.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
But also, my papers are mostly based on outside research not assigned readings, so you can't repeat the teachings. The secret to a good grade is outlining a coherent argument that supports your thesis based on the required number of peer reviewed articles plus some bcz the required amount alone won't get you an A as As are above and beyond.
 
I have a 3.87 cgpa, I know what I'm doing :) which includes not coming to conclusions on a whole discipline or all teachers based on a single course you took over.
I didn't and I don't. I took it because I needed an easy credit- I was working full time and I had no time to do "research".
 
I didn't and I don't. I took it because I needed an easy credit- I was working full time and I had no time to do "research".

Interesting, I take math and finance classes for my electives as easy grades, I guess we are built different. Most of my classes only 3-5/60 students get an A, so you took an exceptionally easy class, because most aren't that easy and few people can pull off As in a full political science course load given that you get over 60pgs upto 100pgs, of reading a week per class and then have 2 or 3 papers that require 6-12 academic sources outside of the course required readings a term. Very time consuming and rigorous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
Interesting, I take math and finance classes for my electives as easy grades, I guess we are built different. Most of my classes only 3-5/60 students get an A, so you took an exceptionally easy class, because most aren't that easy and few people can pull off As in a full political science course load given that you get over 60pgs upto 100pgs, of reading a week per class and then have 2 or 3 papers that require 6-12 academic sources outside of the course required readings a term. Very time consuming and rigorous.
I learned and practiced speed reading and I always read with a highlighter in my hand and a stack of cue cards to register quotes and sources. That way writing a paper was a 2-4 hours exercise. I also never wrote the actual papers- I dictated the content and I had poor library rats do the actual transcribing; one rough draft and the final draft. Saved myself a tons of time. Oh, yeah, and I ALWAYS read the books starting with the foot notes to access more sources. After all, I was just a poor immigrant boy who could hardly speak English- with cash, but no time.
 
I learned and practiced speed reading and I always read with a highlighter in my hand and a stack of cue cards to register quotes and sources. That way writing a paper was a 2-4 hours exercise. I also never wrote the actual papers- I dictated the content and I had poor library rats do the actual transcribing; one rough draft and the final draft. Saved myself a tons of time. Oh, yeah, and I ALWAYS read the books starting with the foot notes to access more sources. After all, I was just a poor immigrant boy who could hardly speak English- with cash, but no time.

It literally takes days to write and research a good paper and organize notes from 6+ sources and then formulate an argument when you have to review and discuss four theories on a single topic, but yes, this totally happened.
 
Anyway, I find this degree much more difficult and time consuming than my first degree in an engineering field, but that might be because I have a math brain. Political science is difficult because the question and resulting theories of how a political phenomenon came to be isn't as black and white and requires abstract analysis. I find math and science, that isn't at a theoretical level, to be much easier because there is a definitively right or wrong answer.
 
Yeah, sure you do :rolleyes:
Phillip, why would you doubt that she's in university?

Her comments in this thread have been far more sophisticated and intelligent than your own and you - apparently - have a degree from McGill, IIRC. Many of the ladies in the industry work to put themselves through university.
 
I didn’t miss the point. My original question was to ask the definition of white/black because I don’t think generalizations are healthy to believe in. The thread evolved into race and slavery. Kinda proving my point that holding all people to a stereotype or generalization based on skin colour is not a healthy belief.
I get it and in part, I agree with you. But many people are racist - sometimes surprisingly so. My own epiphany moment was when I visited Chicago 20 years ago. First time I'd been to a large US city by myself, except NYC and LA. I went to a model train superstore, as that is my hobby. It was empty, as it was mid afternoon on a weekday. I did the usual "I'm from out of town" intro to the 2 middle-aged hobby store dudes working there. Within 5 minutes, those 2 bland looking white dudes were telling me that Chicago had a "nxxxxx problem". I was shocked. In Toronto, people just wouldn't say that stuff, least of all to a total stranger. They took my white skin as permission to enter the conversation.