The 8 White Identities

I'm calling 100% bullshit on this story. In other words, I'm saying this never happened.

The only "news organizations" that are saying this incident happened are right-wing US-based propaganda sites, like the Federalist. No New York City papers -- even right-wing ones like the New York Post -- are even reporting on this incident. If it happened, the Post would be all over it.
The writer exists. He's a neo Hegelian professor in an Afro-American Studies faculty at Northwestern University and in that context, the analysis / 8 categories might have been useful to look at. It pretty much isn't useful, at a high school level.

The issue is whether someone actually tried to teach it at a public high school. I'll forward the story to Scopes and see if they'll fact check it.

Even my rightie law partner didn't believe it was real - before he got really mad about it anyway. LOLOL!!
 
The writer exists. He's a neo Hegelian professor in an Afro-American Studies faculty at Northwestern University and in that context, the analysis / 8 categories might have been useful to look at. It pretty much isn't useful, at a high school level.

The issue is whether someone actually tried to teach it at a public high school. I'll forward the story to Scopes and see if they'll fact check it.

Even my rightie law partner didn't believe it was real - before he got really mad about it anyway. LOLOL!!

Yes, as I said earlier, the story is not about the authenticity of the list itself; the only thing I am calling bullshit on is the idea that a teacher/principal was sending this out to parents.

Good call on sending this to Snopes. Be funny if Snopes did an audit on Terb posts. That would be a HUGE job!
 
The list may be real; what I don't see any reliable evidence for is that a principal from a New York school was sending this list to parents.
I sent the link to Snopes for them to check whether it was actually taught to NYC high schoolers.
 

This is the journalist's base organization. Rightie-whitie political Christians. Rufo's speciality is doing exposes about over zealous teachers who used heavy handed and inappropriate methods to teach kids about race and power.

He's done a few of these. They could be a hoax. OTOH, I can imagine that there are some nutty teachers who might actually do this stuff, perhaps without the sanction of the School Board. There are crazies on all sides.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JeanGary Diablo

This is the journalist's base organization. Rightie-whitie political Christians. Rufo's speciality is doing exposes about over zealous teachers who used heavy handed and inappropriate methods to teach kids about race and power.

He's done a few of these. They could be a hoax. OTOH, I can imagine that there are some nutty teachers who might actually do this stuff, perhaps without the sanction of the SB. There are crazies on all sides.

Its possible it was sent out by one teacher but the chances of it being part of a board's curriculum is pretty much zilch.
Still, no reason for a lot of people not get incredibly upset over it.
 
Here's his bio page: https://afam.northwestern.edu/people/faculty/barnor-hesse.html

And yes, he is teaching this racist garbage to his students


Research Interests:

Post-structuralism and political theory
Black political thought
Modernity and Coloniality
Blackness and Affect
Race and Governmentality
Conceptual Methodologies
Postcolonial Studies

Courses:

Graduate
AFAM 475: Genealogy of Racism as a Concept
AFAM 401: Conceptual Methodologies
AFAM 400: Post-Structuralism and Black Political Thought
Undergraduate
AFAM 380: Unsettling Whiteness
AFAM 375: Post-Colonial African American Studies
AFAM 363: Racism in Western Modernity
 

The principal of East Side Community School in New York sent white parents this "tool for action," which tells them they must become "white traitors" and then advocate for full "white abolition." This is the new language of public education.

More woke madness........
You realize this "news" is from 2015 right?

Way to necro a dead subject 6 years later lol

But yeah it is the "new" ideal
 
  • Haha
Reactions: mandrill
I agree that’s the issue. Labels. They don’t work. Identity politics doesn’t work. Also, I have no idea what the definition of white is. North America white? Whats the definition of black? 6th generation, landed immigrants from Jamaica? As soon as you start believing in generalizations and labels you’re fucked.


That's absolutely not what I meant. A simple anthropology class on race and another on culture will explain your questions, they aren't undefinable, they are in fact actually well defined. Labels will always exist because that is human nature. The issue is white supremacy, and your comment is so obtuse I am not going to further explain anything.
 
Last edited:
Here's his bio page: https://afam.northwestern.edu/people/faculty/barnor-hesse.html

And yes, he is teaching this racist garbage to his students


Research Interests:

Post-structuralism and political theory
Black political thought
Modernity and Coloniality
Blackness and Affect
Race and Governmentality
Conceptual Methodologies
Postcolonial Studies

Courses:

Graduate
AFAM 475: Genealogy of Racism as a Concept
AFAM 401: Conceptual Methodologies
AFAM 400: Post-Structuralism and Black Political Thought
Undergraduate
AFAM 380: Unsettling Whiteness
AFAM 375: Post-Colonial African American Studies
AFAM 363: Racism in Western Modernity


These sound like amazing courses, let me go see if I can take them online and get transfer credits.
 
I agree that’s the issue. Labels. They don’t work. Identity politics doesn’t work. Also, I have no idea what the definition of white is. North America white? Whats the definition of black? 6th generation, landed immigrants from Jamaica? As soon as you start believing in generalizations and labels you’re fucked.
100% agreed. it's not surprising that as identity politics have really taken a hold in the U.S., race relations have been at an all-time low. Expect this trend to continue.
 
^^^^^ please seek professional help
IDK, Phil. The lady has a pretty good point there.

Whites DID rape a LOT of black slaves back in the day. And while Whites might have thought THOSE race relations were pretty good, the Black women who were raped can't have agreed. I attach the Wiki about Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings, which has become notorious.

If whites think "race relations" these days are at an "all time low" because of a little criticism in sociology class, doesn't that mean whites are kinda snowflake-ish? I mean, no one is raping you, are they Phil?

 
These sound like amazing courses, let me go see if I can take them online and get transfer credits.

Yes I'm sure these courses will further enhance his students chances of gaining meaningful employment in society,lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LAS0023