'Temp Agency' Pros and Procedures

GoLeafsGo

New member
Jul 23, 2003
414
0
0
Toronto
There have been a few threads lately about people switching professions or looking for new jobs etc. It sorta got me wondering about the whole agency thing. If someone has been away from the workforce and needs to get their professional life back on track, would an agency such as any of the ones listed below be a good place to turn?

www.adecco.ca
www.manpower.ca
www.drakeintl.com

How does the process work? You would apply online or in person with one of these agencies? They bring you in for an interview and proficiency tests etc. Then once they're aware of your skills and goals etc., they place you with an employer? With no cost to the cadidate?

If anyone (especially any recruiter types) can provide further light, please do. I guess I'm most interested in knowing more about the relationship between cadidate and agency and what the candidate can expect when he goes in for his appointment with the agency.
 
They all work slightly differently, but the basic process is the same. These companies are basically the middlemen between you and the companies. The companies pay them for each successul hire.

You should visit them directly and they will ask you questions about your skills and what kind of job you're looking for. Depending on the position, they may ask you to take a test. For example, I went to manpower because they put out an ad for a telemarketer. I had submitted my resume and they called me for an interview. They then gave me a skill-assessment test. Because I passed the test and screening interview, they arranged an interview with the company. I failed it, and never heard from them again.

There is no cost to you whether you get hired or not.
 
For example.....

Companies pay Agencies $15-20.00/hr to staff it's positions and pay the employee $10-14.00/hr. Ususally the agency is under a 3 month contract and after the 3 months if the temp works out the company can hire him. There is usually alot a crap jobs to sort through but I do know some people who found something through agencies.....
I have had alot of jobs and never have I landed a good one through a want ad or an agency.... Search out companies that have postions that you're interrested in and call them directly to see if they're hiring.... ask friends but not you're best friends....(keep them as best friends and not work friends :) ) friends of friends and thier friends. Post your resume free online and list it under the type of job you seek......
 
GoLeafsGo said:
There have been a few threads lately about people switching professions or looking for new jobs etc. It sorta got me wondering about the whole agency thing. If someone has been away from the workforce and needs to get their professional life back on track, would an agency such as any of the ones listed below be a good place to turn?

www.adecco.ca
www.manpower.ca
www.drakeintl.com
Temp agencies tend to specialize in certain fields eg:technology, Banking, manufacturing, govt etc. You should do some research before calling the agency.
Several years ago I found good contract work via temp agencies: one was a 12 month contract with a high tech firm, the second was a 12 month contract with the Feds, the third was a contract with a Financial instituition
which turned into a FT job after a 6 month stint as a "temp".
 
A person I know used to regularly get temp agency office jobs 10 years ago. Recently she tried again, and found that that the industry had changed a lot. There are now a lot fewer agencies, and fewer jobs available. It used to be that she could get work whenever she wanted it, but not anymore.
 
The problem with employment agents is that your salary ends up being less than it otherwise would b/c your employer has to pay the agent. You can probably do the same job on your own, but that requires a lot more legwork on your part. And if you haven't been networking (shame on you), an agency might be your only choice.

But for the lower paying, lower skilled jobs, there's no reason you shouldn't be able to find employment on your own.
 
If your in school still, it's alright. If you are out of school, your better off finding work on your own.
 
While temporary agencies do seem like a great option, they are not without their disadvantages. I'm reminded of an old joke I used to hear about Real Estate Agents -- but it really applies better to temp agents.

Q. What's the difference between a Ued Car Salesman and a Temp Agent?
A. The Used Car Salesman knows when he's lying to you.


I started up with the temp agencies two years ago. Lured in by advertisements for progressive positions that simply did not exist. Big mistake. It took about a year for me to understand that they operate on a platform of double standards and lies. They put out "Cattle-Call" ads to attract talent -- put them through skills assessments and interviews to create the impression there is a position on the horizon, and then throw them into the pool of revolving-door factory and telemarketing positions. They do more to hurt your career prospects than help. By the time you are through with them your resume will read like a crack-addicted chronically-unemployable job-hopper.

Some managers think that hiring temps gets them out of having to comply with employment laws, Many businesses use temporary employees just as they would permanent employees, except that the temps don't receive the normal fringe benefits that permanent employees receive. Try working as a temp for 40 hours per week for months alongside permanent employees who are receiving the benefits associated with full-time employment, and see what it does for your morale.

And as C Dick said earlier -- the job market is not the same now as it was even 10 years ago. They are all sucking from the same teat of "Revolving-Door" such as Factory, CSR and Telemarketing. They rely on revenue from the employer and therefore put up their policies -- which do make attempts to circumvent fair hiring practices. They exercise discrimination, deprive employees access to medical appointments and contact withthe outside world --even during breaks -- that is if breaks are offered. I had one manager who said we were not allowed to check messages at home during breaks because the messages might contain information that would distract us from our duties during working time.

One telemarketing position allowed zero sick days -- even for long term hires. They denied one of their top performers time off to attend an appointment she booked with a medical specialist -- an appontment she waited six months for -- booked four months prior to her hire date. She was absent zero days up to the appointment date, made the appointment, and was asked not to come back. Her replacement was far less qualified.

I finally went the route of independant contractor, pounded the pavement with a resume and landed two far better positions for myself than any agency could. One is a work from home position in my chosen field of technical writing, and the other in marketing for a very progressive company.
 
Last edited:
Keebler Elf said:
The problem with employment agents is that your salary ends up being less than it otherwise would b/c your employer has to pay the agent. You can probably do the same job on your own, but that requires a lot more legwork on your part. And if you haven't been networking (shame on you), an agency might be your only choice.

But for the lower paying, lower skilled jobs, there's no reason you shouldn't be able to find employment on your own.
Yes and no. Some companies these days "farm out" some of their hiring. Eg: I know one high tech firm where all hiring for non-core staff is delegated to an outside agency. The only positions for which the company hires directly are s/w developers, engineers etc. So, if you were looking for a marketing or accounting position in this company you would have to go via the agency.
Going via an agency is not a substitute for doing your own leg work ofcourse, but sometimes an agency can help you get your foot in the door much faster than if you were looking for work on your own. The low agency pay is unfortunately just the price you'll have to pay to be introduced to the company but once inside the company it will be easier to network from within. You'll also have access to internally advertised jobs.
 
Fred Zed said:
Yes and no. Some companies these days "farm out" some of their hiring. Eg: I know one high tech firm where all hiring for non-core staff is delegated to an outside agency. The only positions for which the company hires directly are s/w developers, engineers etc. So, if you were looking for a marketing or accounting position in this company you would have to go via the agency.

Good points.

As an employer there are a lot of advantages to using a recruitment firm:

~ They pre-screen the applicants
~ They have a bigger pool of applicants to select from (remember that many candidates may not be actively looking for a job, but are registered with an agency - Candidates a company would fail to attract)
~ The "Fee" can be offset against any advertising costs a company will pay for (advertising in local papers and other resources can cost anywhere from 10-25% of the annual salary of the position)
~ The review and selection process can be time consuming for all managers involved in the hiring decision - Which is a big intangible cost in itself.

As an employee/recruitee:

~ Depending on the position you are applying for, the compensation will be comparable if not better than the full time employees in the same position. Recruiters know the market rates.
~ If the position has the potential to turn into a full time role, you have had the opportunity to review the company to see if you would like to work there
~ It is always easy to continue your job search as a temp worker. It's not like you have to make up excuses when you have an interview.
~ A temp position may be suitable for your life-style.
~ Don't worry about having a resume with various positions listed on it. The old way of thinking was an employee who spent several years doing the same job was classed as a dedicated person. Hehehe, these days it's a sign that they were not motivated to improve their current position, or else they didn't have the skill set to do anything else. As long as the job changes show some sort of career planning or career growth, a smart employer will know that the individual has seen a lot of differing management styles and experienced different workplace environments.

Basically, you have nothing to lose by going the recruitment firm route. After all, you have the final decision to accept a position or not.

PS Fred - I remember when we hired you at the Tech firm. You were such a nice boy.
 
The reputable "outsourcing" firms in the high skills market operate wholly differently than temp agencies.

The traditional temp agency does not bring you on staff and rotates people through jobs that require a bare minimum of skill, usually for $10-15/hr. There are no benefits and no guarantees of employment. The "good" jobs that a temp agency would have would be office assistant, receptionist, or other kind of clerical worker; or perhaps a "good" factory job. I agree they mostly have horrible work.

In the high skills area there are two variations. The first is the "recruiter", who is essentially an outsourced HR person. The recruiter will maintain a bank of resumes on file and will try and match them with positions that come open. Hires work for the company directly, rather than the recruiter, but the recruiter usually earns a 10-20% commission for a successful placement. Your salary/rate will suffer a bit if you find a position through a recruiter owing to the money the company paid to the recruiter--if you'd found the job yourself you might have been able to get a 5-10% higher offer. Nevertheless, many of them are good at what they do and find jobs you wouldn't have. They have a lot of one to three month contracts in addition to permanent full time positions.

The second is the consulting agency, which is most like a temp agency, but different. Many of them are big well known firms: CGI, Delloite & Touche, and so on. The biggest difference is that a consulting agency will bring you on as permanent staff and offer good benefits. They will place their people into their clients offices on as needed basis, shifting you around from one place to another, typically at least a few weeks or months in each location. However, if they can't find work for you, you still work for them and still get paid your salary.

In all my years I have never seen a traditional temp agency place a high skilled position in the technology field. Maybe it happens. I have never seen it. I've seen ads from places like Kelly or Drake suggesting that they do, but if they ever approached me with a candidate I would simply assume they were trying to push an unskilled person on me, as that's my impression of places like that. The good companies treat people much better and try and maintain a reputation for quality that would get blown out of the water if they operated like a Drake or a Kelly.