tell me how or why?

21pro

Crotch Sniffer
Oct 22, 2003
7,829
1
0
Caledon East
why is it that Canadians think we are somehow going to escape the global crisis or not be effected as badly here as in the US? What is worst is this belief is perpetuated and propagated in our media... trying to calm panic and sedate the nation... in my opinion, people are buying into it here in Canada. Not enough action is being done by the common person. People still want to borrow money, people still wish to carry debt. That worked before, it won't work in the future. I wish people would wake up to this realization.

At the very core of the US problem, us Canadians are involved... Think about it: When a backhoe digs into the ground in Pleasantville, USA, starting work on a new home, it sets off a chain reaction of purchases that ripples through the North American economy.

Each new home generates hundreds of thousands of dollars in purchases ranging from labour, Lafarge cement and Abitibi lumber all the way to DVI lighting chandeliers, Barrie's CanPlas plumbing piping and other consumables such as big-screen TVs.

Unfortunately for Canada, this great economic engine is still gearing down. At the height of the housing boom in 2005 and 2006, Americans were breaking ground on new homes at a rate of more than two million a year. In December, housing starts fell to a new postwar annual low of 550,000. Recessions have little regard for national boundaries - least of all the 49th parallel.

The effects of the longest and deepest U.S. slump in decades have been rapidly spreading northward for months.

1. It all starts with Canada's heavy reliance on exports to its southern neighbour. The percentage has slipped over the past decade, but nearly 80 per cent of Canadian goods exported still go to a single foreign customer: the United States. And those exports contributed roughly 22 per cent of economic activity. Add in services, and the U.S.-centric orbit of the Canadian economy is even more pronounced.

Americans aren't just buying fewer homes: it's cars, computer software, potash and a whole lot else.

U.S. businesses are retrenching at an alarming rate, buying less and demanding lower prices.

2. Exports aren't the only conduit for the radiating U.S. economic pain. As the world's largest consumer, the United States helps set the price of the major commodities that Canada depends on for much of its wealth: oil, forest products, minerals and agricultural products.

The price of oil has plummeted to well below $40 (U.S.) a barrel from more than $147 as recently as six months ago. Other commodity prices have also fallen, though not as sharply.

With the eastern part of the country already in recession, the commodity price already is causing a crash in the west, too. This year, the economy is expected to shrink in every province, except Saskatchewan. The United States officially slipped into recession in December of 2007.

We didn't feel the effect of what was going on in the U.S., but we are going to. I believe that we will feel the 2nd phase of the recession... we are in that second phase of the recession now. The second wave is coming from the auto industry and the drop in commodity prices.

3. Tighter credit in the U.S. quickly led to the same in Canada. The U.S. problems have also migrated northward through the credit markets, upon which companies on both sides of the border rely to finance their operations.

To a large extent, the Canadian economy is integrated north-south, not east-west. Think about it.... where does the oil from Alberta go? the Natural gas from Saskatchewan? the high tech and produce in the maritimes? forestry? ... manufacturing? we do 80% and above of all of this work solely for the US, not ourselves and not the rest of the world. 80% goes south! So, the Canadian economy gets hit from all of these channels. don't get me going on the water from our great lakes after seeing my beachfront shoreline recede 18 feet over the last 6 years...

If you look back over recent decades, the correlation between U.S. and Canadian economic cycles, it's a virtual perfect match. I believe It's almost impossible to avoid the U.S. fate.

Canada suffered more than the United States during the recessions of the early 1980s and 1990s, weighed down by higher interest rates and government deficits.

This US problem is now becomming OUR PROBLEM... just wait and see. Canada CAN'T and HASN'T insulated itself.
 
I think the main thing to keep in mind is that while historically strong US financial institutions are failing, Canadian banks are ranked as the most stable in the world, meaning that those who have money in banks don't need to fear it disappearing quite the same way the states have.

It wont be good here either though, just less bad.
 
but the Canadian banking system is not a model or measure stick for any other part of the economy, except maybe it will help real estate values support themselves.

a bit off topic, but a strong banking system is one that charges it's consumers alot in fees and gives low savings rates... yep, that sounds like a Canadian bank in a nutshell.
 
The Canadian economy on its own is much stronger, without the housing bubble and underwater mortgages, with solid banks, etc. But 21pro is right, our economy is so tied in with the US economy, so we will suffer too. It should not be nearly as bad as there, because we have the credit and stability, but when exports plummet, it will have a big effect here.
 
Unlike the U.S., Canada headed into this recession with both a healthy fiscal and trade SUPLUS so I think (hope) that we are in better shape to weather the storm. Also, the sub-prime mortage debacle blew up in the U.S. before it gained much of a foothold in Canada. What is unfortunate is that some of our Canadian banks have U.S. operations. What Canada really needs is to LOWER its production cost of goods and services. This means that the public and private unionized workers have to stop being so greedy.
 
I don't know if the number has changed, but I remember back in december hearing that forclosure rate in Canada was at an all time low and below one percent. Not a bad place to be.
 
Canada is more than real estate and a few strong banks, though. understand this, we are not heading into a real estate recession. not to say home prices won't be affected, as they clearly will do- but, that ain't the reason for concern here in Canada. We are heading into a big JOB LOSS recessionary period that will last a few years. Bankruptcies, closed businesses and lost pensions will be the headlines here in Canada. then you'll start to see foreclosures.

C Dick, that seems to be what most are seeing, but I don't see how we have credit and stability when A) credit has tightened up (especially business credit) and B) what is stable when we can't find a place to market almost anything Canada produces?

In some ways, I do think we are more vulnerable... not stronger.
 
21pro said:
but a strong banking system is one that charges it's consumers alot in fees

Didn't our friend Jack Layton say that the Canadian banks should follow the model of the insolvent British banks and not charge service fees?
 
I'm not suggesting we're not in trouble. But you asked why people are saying it wont be as bad here as the US, and the lack of bank failures and a stable real estate industry are why. Doesn't mean are GDP isn't about to get battered, but imagine if it was all three. wait you don't have to, you can look at it across the border
 
I doubt Layton truly understands what he criticizes most of the time.

besides the foundation for our legal system, pretty much everything else done in England is opposite to Canada. Britain imports almost everything. The British consumer holds more debt than Canadians or Americans... oh and the banking thing? Britain's banks rely on short term funding instead of deposits, exposing them to very high risk. they have a very thin capital cushion which makes them extremely vulnerable. not doable here in Canada.

so Layton says what makes the typical Canadian think without much thinking that what Jack has to say is smart. All Joe 6pack hears is 'not charge service fees...' and he's content. He doesn't know that that model wouldn't work here. plain and simple.
 
the Toronto Star rebuffs your stance.

http://www.thestar.com/Business/article/576540

All I can speak to is my own experience. I work for a large company, just acquired by a much larger company last summer, both US based. Both companies have "branches" in Canada.

Our parent company just told us last week that our bonuses for 2008 were being frozen(i.e we won't be getting them till the economy improves), and any "merit" raises were also being frozen.

The catch is, the Canadian part of the business is doing quite well....although we did not make our forecast budget(20% over last year's numbers), we came quite close (18%). So, we had significant revenue growth.

But the panic and retrenchment taking place down in the US is spilling over here in Canada.
 
Cause if they came out and said sell your homes & stocks, take all your cash out of the banks, hang on to your cash, don't buy new anything, cars, tv's, appliances...were going down like the USA :p what would happen, lol.

The key is jobs, as long as there is good paying jobs things will be OK. Maybe the USA will get a few now...think clean energy but its going to take some time.
 
Cat just laid off 20,000 workers today, what are all these workers going to do with kids and mortgages. This is a cleansing of sorts, take out the trash and see who's left standing. Although these bailouts make my blood boil.

I think the world is overpopulated and is leading to most of the problems and this will eventually lead to the end of the world as we know it, 9 billion by 2050, JMHO.

Sprint-8000 jobs, Phizer cuts dividend in half.
 
21pro said:
C Dick, that seems to be what most are seeing, but I don't see how we have credit and stability when A) credit has tightened up (especially business credit)

In some ways, I do think we are more vulnerable... not stronger.

The latest stats from the Bank of Canada would seem to indicate that lending, even business lending is still growing in Canada. I think much (not all) of the credit tightening is anecdotal - the numbers don't seem to bear it out.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20090124.RTICKER24-2/TPStory/?query=bank+lending

BUSINESS TICKER: NORTH AMERICA: FINANCIAL SERVICES: BANK LENDING
'Credit is flowing in Canada,' data show
CP
January 24, 2009
Amid widespread calls for Canada's banks to provide more credit to hard-pressed consumers and businesses, new numbers from the Bank of Canada indicate they're doing exactly that. Chartered bank assets were up last month in most categories. Yesterday's weekly report from the central bank, the first to include December data, tallied $47.6-billion in personal loans, up by a negligible $27-million from November but almost 9 per cent more than in December, 2007. Credit card balances, meanwhile, swelled by more than 5 per cent during the month to $53.4-billion, up 10 per cent from a year earlier. "The reality is that credit is flowing in Canada," TD Bank economist Craig Alexander said in an interview. On the business side, bank loans to Canadian residents for commercial purposes rose 1 per cent during December to $191.8-billion, up 4.7 per cent on the year. The banks' residential mortgages stood at $452.5-billion, off by 0.7 per cent from November, extending a declining trend since July's peak as realtors reported sharp drops in home prices and sales volumes.
 
The Cunning Linguist said:
Our parent company just told us last week that our bonuses for 2008 were being frozen(i.e we won't be getting them till the economy improves), and any "merit" raises were also being frozen.

Obviously, you don't work for Merrill Lynch. They looted the corporate cookie jar days before being acquired by B of A. (This is the equivalent of Bush taking all the White House furniture before Obama became president.) Up until the very minute John Thain was fired, he was plotting to fire 30,000 Bof A employees and replace them with Merrill staff. Nice guy, eh? BofA acquiring Merrill is like inviting Ghengis Khan into your house where your wife and daughters live.
 
Rockslinger said:
Obviously, you don't work for Merrill Lynch. They looted the corporate cookie jar days before being acquired by B of A. (This is the equivalent of Bush taking all the White House furniture before Obama became president.) Up until the very minute John Thain was fired, he was plotting to fire 30,000 Bof A employees and replace them with Merrill staff. Nice guy, eh? BofA acquiring Merrill is like inviting Genghis Khan into your house where your wife and daughters live.

yes....I read that thread over in the politics and international forum.

those bastards deserve to be roasted on a spit.


there is absolutely no integrity or morals in corporate American(or Canada).
 
With 40,000 or so more job cuts being announce just today, the worst is still to come I am afraid. We will see but where are these people going to go...Wal Mart pay's min wage and has just one guy opening the doors on black Friday.

I'm watching my dollar's...this summer I wanna still have party cash in hand.
 
S.C. Joe said:
With 40,000 or so more job cuts being announce just today, the worst is still to come I am afraid.

The "Big Guy" said that we hit the top of the market in July, then he said that the worst was yet to come. He is rarely wrong and that is why he is the "Big Guy". The "Big Guy" is waiting to see the Budget tomorrow PM and see what that means for our project team.