Tax Questions: late returns.

Hard Idle

Active member
Jan 15, 2005
4,952
21
38
North York
If a person - lets call him Barney - has not filled returns for a while (ok, a long while) and wants to start getting caught up, does he have to file them chronologically (from the when he first stopped filling) or can Barney start with last years and work his way back to the year where he owes alot?

Would filling a couple of returns now only put him on the radar of the collectors and prompt a demand for the other years, or would they be glad to be getting something and wait to give Barney a chance to get caught up on his own?

Barney probably gets a few hundred back for most years, but owes a few thousand for one year and still doesn't have enough to settle up. Is better to just wait until there is enough money to pay it all?
 
If it's best to file all the years at the same time then discuss an instalment plan with CCRA if anything is owing after that. CCRA will not release a refund until all the years are processed.
 
Hard Idle said:
If a person - lets call him Barney - has not filled returns for a while (ok, a long while) and wants to start getting caught up, does he have to file them chronologically (from the when he first stopped filling) or can Barney start with last years and work his way back to the year where he owes alot?

Would filling a couple of returns now only put him on the radar of the collectors and prompt a demand for the other years, or would they be glad to be getting something and wait to give Barney a chance to get caught up on his own?

Barney probably gets a few hundred back for most years, but owes a few thousand for one year and still doesn't have enough to settle up. Is better to just wait until there is enough money to pay it all?

If Barney has not received a demand for a return or a request for a return from CRA then Barney should seriously look into CRA's "voluntary disclosure" program whereby CRA waives all penalties if you voluntarily disclose back taxes owing. To be "voluntary" Barney must be disclosing something CRA has not already begun an investigation into, and CRA has not already demanded a return for. CRA has to not know it is owing for it to qualify. Barney should go out of his way to make sure he files that voluntary disclosure for the year that has back taxes before doing ANYTHING else, and ASAP notify CRA that he intends to file a voluntary disclosure for that year--he can file the intent to do so before he actually files the return. Barney should get a good tax accountant to help him if he doesn't know how.

Interest will not be waived on the back taxes, but CRA in addition to interest charges large penalties up to perhaps 50% of the taxes owing by now. It is very much in Barney's best interest NOT to have to pay those penalties!!

If CRA has already sent Barney a request for a return or a demand for a return then Barney is screwed and it just doesn't matter what he does, other than he should pay the outstanding ASAP to stop the interest/penalties clock.

ps - even if Barney doesn't have enough to settle, filing the voluntary disclosure is key as it will substantially reduce the penalties owing, and CRA will work out a reasonable payment plan with Barney for what's due.
 
Barney has made less then $12000 of gross income for 5 of the past 6 years, and had NO known income in 2001. Most of those years, Barney comes out ahead on his taxes (minuscule refund + GST refund) so he was thinking he could wait until his Credit years add up to about the same amount as what he owes for the one year he slipped up.

We're talking fairly small amounts of money. CRA has shown no interest or awareness of Barney since all of this started. The cost of going after him would exceed the amount owed, but you never know, the odd time they go for it anyway.
 
Barney should talk to my friend Bob.

Bob never filed his income tax for 10 years. He was told by a CR agent that it was OK not to file as long as he owes no money. He finally did file though he was told that he could only go back 5 years. There was only one year of all those 10 years that Bob was worried that he might owe money. He was told that even though he was only allowed to go back 5 years the government may choose to look at and check him out for more then 5 years back if they think there has been some gross misrepresentation or attempt to avoid paying taxes owed. Lucky for Bob the government just took the 5 years filed and did not go back and look at the year Bob was worried about. Bob was very happy. He ended up getting back over $2,500. including GST refunds for all those five years combined. He was so happy he went to Montreal and spent almost the entire $2,500. in one weekend partying and hobbying. True story.
 
Hard Idle said:
**Barney has made less then $12000 of gross income***,

How is barney livin??????????


**and had NO "known" income in 2001.**

Can anybody say fraud??

Barney may want to file voluntarily ASAP to close the statute of limitations, which remain open when no return is filed. Chances are the RC will look at them as voluntary compliance and mark 'em closed. barney dont want RC askin the 2 above questions.

Matt
 
fuji said:
If Barney has not received a demand for a return or a request for a return from CRA then Barney should seriously look into CRA's "voluntary disclosure" program whereby CRA waives all penalties if you voluntarily disclose back taxes owing. To be "voluntary" Barney must be disclosing something CRA has not already begun an investigation into, and CRA has not already demanded a return for. CRA has to not know it is owing for it to qualify. Barney should go out of his way to make sure he files that voluntary disclosure for the year that has back taxes before doing ANYTHING else, and ASAP notify CRA that he intends to file a voluntary disclosure for that year--he can file the intent to do so before he actually files the return. Barney should get a good tax accountant to help him if he doesn't know how.

Interest will not be waived on the back taxes, but CRA in addition to interest charges large penalties up to perhaps 50% of the taxes owing by now. It is very much in Barney's best interest NOT to have to pay those penalties!! ...

While I agree with much of the above it is my understanding that by going more than 1 year with taxes owing Barney has committed a criminal offense. I would get advice from a tax lawyer before proceeding. I would not get an accountant. There is no lawyer-client privelidge with an accountant. He/she can be forced to testify against you and reveal all they know about you, i.e. everything you told them.

Scrooge is right in that DioGuardi & Co. is one such firm. They advertise their services on TV here in Toronto. There are others.

A tax lawyer can bring all of the years to CCRA's attention without bringing up Barney's name (due to privelidge). They will negotiate a settlement that may involve waiving most or all of the penalties but likely not the interest. Depending on the amount owed this saving may offset a lot of the legal fees? If the amount owed is small then he may wish to take the risk of identifying himself through the voluntary disclosure program. I'd still pay for 1 hour of a tax lawyer's time to review it before doing this. Just remember that if the amount is really large and recurring for years some jail time or a criminal record could theoretically be involved.

Don't you think he needs to disclose all at once? I would think that disclosing one year at a time would cause them to do a thorough review of the file.
 
MajorMattMason said:
Hard Idle said:
**
How is barney livin??????????

Can anybody say fraud??

barney dont want RC askin the 2 above questions.

Matt

Fraud? Uh, no try Charity Case. Scrounges together some money from sporadic cash jobs, some min-wage type work, and considerable loans and handouts.

Barney has a hard time producing a lump sum of more than $500 (nearly equivalent to a month's budget most of the time...) so any legal or accountant fees will have to be in that neighbourhood.

I'm worried if something happened where he was cornered and forced to produce a payment, he would consider petty crime or loansharks.

Damn the system is stupid. You'd think they'd be happy guys like this aren't collecting welfare, I'm pretty sure the government comes out way ahead on the deal over the course of a decade.
 
Why Not? said:
While I agree with much of the above it is my understanding that by going more than 1 year with taxes owing Barney has committed a criminal offense. I would get advice from a tax lawyer before proceeding. I would not get an accountant. There is no lawyer-client privelidge with an accountant. He/she can be forced to testify against you and reveal all they know about you, i.e. everything you told them.

I am not a lawyer, but--I am pretty sure he has *not* committed any criminal offense. He has not submitted any fraudulent documents or lied about anything. He has not tried to evade taxes legally owing. He has just been really late about filing. The penalties for late filing are plainly spelled out in the act, and they are all fines expressed as a percentage of the taxes due. They are large, though, and they get larger fast--something like 1% per month, plus some immediate initial penalty, plus interest on all of that, so after 4-5 years that can easily be a 50% penalty.

I say this having been in a similar situation in the past, only it was a corproate return and not a personal return that was several years overdue. It is my understanding that the voluntary disclosure rules are essentially the same for personal returns and for corporate. I did use a tax lawyer at the time, but in retrospect, I think a CA could have done just as good a job and charged me much less. The process is straight forward--it's supposed to be one of those proceses that people can access without the services of any lawyer or accountant. In practice, at least talking to a lawyer is a good idea, and having a CA do it rather than trying to do it yourself would seem like a no-brainer if you don't have an actual lawyer do it.


Don't you think he needs to disclose all at once? I would think that disclosing one year at a time would cause them to do a thorough review of the file.

The moment he files that voluntary disclosure they are going to do a thorough review anyway. But ya, there is no point in filing them separately and possibly considerable advnatage. A good accountant might be able to wring some advnatage out of being able to "plan" expenses over 3-4 years...

What I believe he should do IMMEDIATELY is apply for and get a voluntary disclosure number so that he has declared his intent to file one. CRA will give him some number of months to actually file it after notifying them of his intent to do so. If he doesn't do this, and just waits it out, he might get a "demand for a return" in the letter next week from CRA asking for this return.. at which point he can no longer legally go the voluntary disclosure route and that 50% penalty is likely to stick.
 
Hard Idle said:
MajorMattMason said:
Fraud? Uh, no try Charity Case. Scrounges together some money from sporadic cash jobs, some min-wage type work, and considerable loans and handouts.

Barney has a hard time producing a lump sum of more than $500 (nearly equivalent to a month's budget most of the time...) so any legal or accountant fees will have to be in that neighbourhood.

I'm worried if something happened where he was cornered and forced to produce a payment, he would consider petty crime or loansharks.

Damn the system is stupid. You'd think they'd be happy guys like this aren't collecting welfare, I'm pretty sure the government comes out way ahead on the deal over the course of a decade.

I dunno, dude. In the year when Barney made that money he should have paid his taxes. If Barney gets a 50% or 100% penalty applied to the taxes due for that year, it's his own damn fault for not filing years ago. At least if Barney hd filed, even if Barney didn't have the cash, he would only be facing interest and not interest + penalties + interest on penalties.

I will be the first to agree that the tax system can be pretty stupid sometimes, but by intentionally not filing for several years you bring these penalties down on your own head.
 
fuji said:
I am not a lawyer, but--I am pretty sure he has *not* committed any criminal offense. He has not submitted any fraudulent documents or lied about anything. He has not tried to evade taxes legally owing. He has just been really late about filing. The penalties for late filing are plainly spelled out in the act, and they are all fines expressed as a percentage of the taxes due. They are large, though, and they get larger fast--something like 1% per month, plus some immediate initial penalty, plus interest on all of that, so after 4-5 years that can easily be a 50% penalty.

Failure to file a tax return is tax evasion. It is a serious offense. Although perhaps not technically a "criminal" one it can still result in a trip to court, conviction of a offense, fines of up to $25,000 and prison time. See below:

http://www.canlii.org/ca/sta/i-3.3/sec238.html

It is my understanding that these would be in addition to any back taxes owed and late payment penalties as described by you. My advice still stands. See a tax lawyer not an accountant.
 
Why Not? said:
Failure to file a tax return is tax evasion. It is a serious offense. Although perhaps not technically a "criminal" one it can still result in a trip to court, conviction of a offense, fines of up to $25,000 and prison time. See below:

http://www.canlii.org/ca/sta/i-3.3/sec238.html

It is my understanding that these would be in addition to any back taxes owed and late payment penalties as described by you. My advice still stands. See a tax lawyer not an accountant.

I believe for that to apply he has to receive a demand for a return from CRA, and still do nothing, but sure, see a lawyer.
 
I think one only need to go as far as the tax return forms. Last time I looked it says something like "YOu must file a tax return if 1. YOu owe money 2. you want a refund or 3. CCRA ras requested you file one.
 
fuji said:
I am not a lawyer, but--I am pretty sure he has *not* committed any criminal offence.
​
​
why not? said:
Failure to file a tax return is tax evasion. It is a serious offence. Although perhaps not technically a "criminal" one it can still result in a trip to court, conviction of a offence, fines of up to $25,000 and prison time.
​
​
fuji said:
I believe for that to apply he has to receive a demand for a return from CRA, and still do nothing, but sure, see a lawyer.
​
​
I just saw the Dioguardi & Co. TV commercial again this morning. They quite clearly identify the failure to file as a "criminal" offence. They say so twice.​
​
CCRA has the option of whether to file charges or not. If you identify the situation to them through a 3rd party and negotiate a settlement before your name is identified then you will likely not get charged. You will have to pay the taxes and interest, probably along with some penalty.​
​
I suspect that, if true, the practice of only filing charges after receipt of a demand followed by further failure to comply is just an internal policy and not the law. The offence is the failure to file a tax return. The goal of the CCRA is the recovery of the taxes and the discouragement of future tax evasion. The decision to lay charges is discretionary and I wouldn't want to trust a tax bureaucrat on my personal freedom. I suspect that they will decide whether to lay charges based on a number of criteria. Again I point you to this link.​
​
​
This section of the Tax Act clearly states that the offence is the failure to make a return and not “the failure to make a return after we warned you to do it and told you that you were late.”​
 
I think if he files before CRA says anything there will be no problem. He should talk to a lawyer, but be wary of letting the lawyer handle the file, as it could get really expensive. The lawyer will start blabbing on the phone to the accountant, and you'll get billed on both sides. Just get the lawyer to give you advise, and then do it yourself.