Taserville USA and now Canada too

S.C. Joe

Client # 13
Nov 2, 2007
7,138
2
0
Detroit, USA
http://www.lastchancedemocracycafe.com/?p=1114


Happy Thanksgiving in Taserville


Even when judged by the often troubling standards of “routine” law enforcement use of tasers, a recent incident out of Utah is particularly disturbing. If you haven’t seen the video, it’s worth investing a few minutes: as a citizen in an allegedly free nation you need to know what’s being done in the name of enforcing your laws.

Digby has the YouTube link here.

This particular incident is bad enough that it won’t surprise me terribly if the officer involved ends up being reprimanded, notwithstanding the normal tendency of police forces to protect their own. But there’s more at stake here, obviously, than the isolated actions of one zap happy law enforcement officer. We are dealing, instead, with the broader trend toward increasing police use of tasers, not in self-defense, but to compel compliance with police orders, or even just to punish back talk.

And what’s particularly troubling is the fact that all this is happening within the context of an increasing consensus within this country that when a street cop issues an order to a citizen, even in a non-emergency situation, that citizen is duty bound to snap to attention, regardless of the validity of the officer’s actions.

But that isn’t freedom. And if freedom doesn’t exist in the streets where people actually live, then what’s the point of it anyway?

Believe it or not, the common law actually recognized a legal right to use reasonable non-lethal force to resist unlawful arrests. That’s how seriously it took the right of a citizen to be free from wrongful restraint. Modern statutes and court decisions have moved away from this position — probably wisely given the risk of violence — but the underlying point remains valid: the fact someone carries the commission of a law enforcement officer gives that person no greater right, outside of the carefully defined powers of their office, than anyone else to boss other citizens around.

Here, of course, we’re not talking about merely bossing people around, but running 50,000 volts of electricity though them. And to use what is for all intents and purposes an instrument of torture to compel compliance with the non-emergency orders of a street cop isn’t just abusive: it’s un-American.

As I noted a year ago in discussing another controversial taser incident:

Presumably this same technique could be used to good effect to breakup any politically motivated sit in. Instead of carrying the protesters off to the paddy wagon, just zap ‘em until they finally crawl over to it themselves.

But there are lines you simply don’t cross in a liberal democracy, like, oh, say, torturing suspects (yeah, I know). And allowing the government to use high-voltage electrical shock as a method of compelling compliance to its dictates is one of those things. You can’t do that and still use words like republic and democracy to describe yourself as a nation: They just don’t fit anymore.

This is a road we’ve already gone far too far down.

This entry was posted by Steve on Thursday, November 22nd, 2007 at 12:55 am and is filed under Comment. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
3 Responses to “Happy Thanksgiving in Taserville”

1. Again Says:
November 22nd, 2007 at 2:43 am

when no one is reading the site

how do you know that ? ;-)

We are dealing, instead, with the broader trend toward increasing police use of tasers, not in self-defense, but to compel compliance with police orders, or even just to punish back talk.

yes, and it seems that no one cares, isn’t it? The same with the omnipresent spying - no one cares

but both show the same: there is no respect for “the people” in general anymore, can’t be - everyone must buy respect now - by lawyers, by bodyguards, by your ruling friends in goverment and industry

and if you cannot buy respect on your own - you are just a loser, not worth an ounce of fair treatment or even help and support

that’s the first (but actually the most important and always and ever to avoid) step towards the final countdown for democracy: the loss of respect for each and any person, regardless of class and caste

Stanford prison experiment
“You can create in the prisoners feelings of boredom, a sense of fear to some degree, you can create a notion of arbitrariness that their life is totally controlled by us, by the system, you, me, and they’ll have no privacy… We’re going to take away their individuality in various ways. In general what all this leads to is a sense of powerlessness. That is, in this situation we’ll have all the power and they’ll have none. — The Stanford Prison Study video, quoted in Haslam & Reicher, 2003.”
2. Larkrise Says:
November 23rd, 2007 at 1:41 am

I wonder how that cop would feel if he were brutally tasered? It shows a total lack of empathy on his part. This is becoming a serious problem in our society-the inability to feel empathy. The incident also shows that some people are unable to handle power appropriately. Given the smallest bit of power, they misuse it to harm, bully and degrade others. We see this in the workplace, in schools, in churches, and in law enforcement, in government. It has permeated society to a great degree. We are going backward, not forward. When our leaders set the tone, set such an ugly, harmful example, weaker types will inevitably follow the leader, whether consciously or subconciously. If the President and V.P. promote waterboarding publicly and forcefully, claiming, however, it isnt torture, then the use of a taser becomes an appropriate action, no matter the circumstances. The public becomes numbed to cruelty. Stepping over a line is no longer unacceptable, because the line is no longer there.
 
Hes bang on....the police are torturing suspects who will not compel with police orders, or even just to punish back talk.

Not for self defense or because they have to taser them, just to punish them.
 
S.C. Joe;

You have tremendous insight into one of the things that is ailing modern day society, and have put to words what we have been either ignoring, or that to which we have become desinsitised. The taser issue is but one of the telltale signs of what is wrong with us.
 
Remember the movie Demolition Man, where in the future, people are constantly given tickets for uttering profanities?

I wonder if the taser is some prototype of some similar, darker night-marish future.
 
Some police just love to show their powers to the weaker members of society. I bet they would never taser a famous or rich person and would allow them to speak freely.

I read often about police misconduct. Remember the woman that kept saying she was pregnant and the police would not allow her to speak and she lost her child locked in prison? Some police would think that just a simple word of speaking while they are doing their so called procedure is talking out of place and gives them the authority to do whatever they feel is good to show their power and will tell their chief or a judge that you were out of place. It will be them that is believed and not the average person because they are above the law.

What we need is to stop creating weapons and getting more police that have actually felt misfortunes in their youth and actually have some compassion for the rest of humanity. Then they will be more capable of knowing a real criminal. But, it could also be said that they see lots on their jobs and it hardens them.
 
Jade4u said:
But, it could also be said that they see lots on their jobs and it hardens them.


Just what they need to be able to do on the job...like shooting to kill somebody...weeds out people who have too much compassion for others.

Not everybody can "shoot to kill a person"..even if they are a danger to others....but if a cop fails to stop them, then they are let go....for good reason but then that means the most caring people in life can not be a police officer out on the streets.

They go to work in a hospital being a nurse, doctor or care giver. They are not able to become a police officer even if they try too.
 
Jade4u said:
Some police just love to show their powers to the weaker members of society. I bet they would never taser a famous or rich person and would allow them to speak freely.

Only if he wouldn't let go of the $15,000 in his hand. Then it's a free for all when the cash goes flying.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
Bump, for those who may not have seen this.
 
shakenbake said:
S.C. Joe;

You have tremendous insight into one of the things that is ailing modern day society, and have put to words what we have been either ignoring, or that to which we have become desinsitised. The taser issue is but one of the telltale signs of what is wrong with us.

........not.

The taser is a sign of what is RIGHT with us. We have designed a weapon intended to stun someone rather than kill them. To boot, we have limited the availability of this weapon to those who are trained and authorized (by a democratically elected government) to use it. If something were wrong with us, we would deny the police access to this lifesaving device, and simply expect them to use a firearm against people they perceive to be dangerous. But we don't do that, because as a society we value life.

Bottom line - tasers are intended to SAVE lives, not end them. That is a wonderful thing, and yes it sucks, absolutely sucks, that people die.

What is required is an in-depth analysis of all taser incidents in the past ten years, to determine how many of those incidents would have resulted in the police using a firearm to kill a person, instead of simply tasing them (thus saving their lives).

Why do you guys hate the police so much?
 
CapitalGuy said:
........not.

The taser is a sign of what is RIGHT with us. We have designed a weapon intended to stun someone rather than kill them. To boot, we have limited the availability of this weapon to those who are trained and authorized (by a democratically elected government) to use it. If something were wrong with us, we would deny the police access to this lifesaving device, and simply expect them to use a firearm against people they perceive to be dangerous. But we don't do that, because as a society we value life.

Bottom line - tasers are intended to SAVE lives, not end them. That is a wonderful thing, and yes it sucks, absolutely sucks, that people die.

What is required is an in-depth analysis of all taser incidents in the past ten years, to determine how many of those incidents would have resulted in the police using a firearm to kill a person, instead of simply tasing them (thus saving their lives).

Why do you guys hate the police so much?
I don't hate police. I rather respect them, and admire them for what they do for us, most of them. However, there are a few bad apples that need to be removed from the force.

In my eyes, and no one will convince me otherwise, the four RCMP officers were bullies. The Taser was involved in the death of a man who did NOT deserve to die, and the actions of the officers contributed or caused his needless death. It will remain to be seen what caused his death, and if the Taser was the major cause, or the choke-hold that caused him to stop breathng was the major cause.

The bottom line is that a man died at the hands of the police, whom he trusted and who we trust to protct our own lives. Why did this man have to die an unnecessary death at the hands of the police who were supposed to protect lives? He did not die in the ten hours previous to the police arrival. Did being shot by the Taser, at least twice, save HIS life in the end? On the other side of the coin, the murdered RCMP constables did NOT deserve to die, either. Where were their Tasers, by the way?

So, did the Taser save this man's life? Maybe, there is something seriously wrong with the RCMP, the Vancouver Airport Authrity and the Immigration officials. However, I personally have a deathly fear of high voltage that may cause me to go into coronary fibrillation. Do you?
 
It should be that the use of the taser by police should be treated and regarded the same way as when there is a police shooting of a suspect.

As in...every time a taser is used to subdue a subject there needs to be an investigation by SIU.

I doubt that will happen, because the genie is out of the bottle....police use the taser with impunity, even if the suspect dies.

The taser is being used as a method of punishment. The RCMP officers in the Vancouver incident were not in fear for their lives. It was not a situation where they had to choose between using their guns, or being killed or injured.

There was four of them...versus one unarmed suspect. If they had tasered him once...maybe...but this incident became premediated murder when they tasered him a second time, and then piled on, with one of them cutting off the suspects breathing with a knee on his throat. And then not even attempting to save his life with CPR.

They just let him die.
 
Look in the old days cops had the baton and pepper spray.

Batons caused broken bones and in rare cases pepper spray caused suffocation.

The TAZER can about as a neuro interrupter and showed promise as a no lethal weapon against aggressive perps. based on reality it still is.
 
have you heard the latest in the lame cover-up????

The Cunning Linguist said:
It should be that the use of the taser by police should be treated and regarded the same way as when there is a police shooting of a suspect.

As in...every time a taser is used to subdue a subject there needs to be an investigation by SIU.

I doubt that will happen, because the genie is out of the bottle....police use the taser with impunity, even if the suspect dies.

The taser is being used as a method of punishment. The RCMP officers in the Vancouver incident were not in fear for their lives. It was not a situation where they had to choose between using their guns, or being killed or injured.

There was four of them...versus one unarmed suspect. If they had tasered him once...maybe...but this incident became premediated murder when they tasered him a second time, and then piled on, with one of them cutting off the suspects breathing with a knee on his throat. And then not even attempting to save his life with CPR.

They just let him die.

I believe that I heard on the Current an Airport Chaplain trying to blame the victim's death on nicotine addiction. Sure, smoking is bad for you. But, any lame excuse is a good one for some one who should have been diong his duty to try to help the newcomer. Now I have heard everything! Even the anti-smokers are now trying to get mileage out of one poor man's fate! That 'Man of the Cloth' can go fark himself.