Tankless Water Heaters

I own my own tank. it's a conventional tank. I see NO NEED to ever rent a tank from Enbridge.

In 96 my original tank was installed by Enbridge (then Consumer's Gas) as a rental. It was a 40 gallon Rheam. I bought it out from Enbridge in late 99 after they kept jacknig the rental rates. (50 cents here, a buck there - basially, the rental side of things is unregulated, so they can jack the prices whenever it suits them - and boy, it suits them. Typically tanks these days don't break down till they buy the farm. A typical conventional HWT lasts 12 to 15 years in Toronto. (Less in places with hard water.). If you do the math - the cost of buying, vs. renting, (assuming no breakdowns) it's vastly superior to buy a tank. (And even if it breaks down, you can buy a new one for less than fixing it.))

Anyway, after 13.5 years I replaced my original Rheam. The originail Rheam had actually not popped its clock and was still working away. I just figured I didn't want to pull a Tony Soprano and come down the stairs to 3 feet of water in the basement.

The new tank is a 50 gallon conventional gas fired unit by G.E. with a 9 year warranttee from Home Depot.

This link says $679.00, but I think it was less than that. Like $589, or something there bouts. Whatever.

http://www.homedepot.ca/webapp/wcs/...artial&Ntx=mode+matchall&N=0&Ntk=P_PartNumber

I'm not on equal billing - so my gas bill is my gas used. Typically in the summer with the Rheam, it would run me $25.00 a month for gas (given no rental)

Even if tankless saved me 20% (which I doubt) it would be a savings of 5 bucks a month, or $60 bucks a year.

The thing I like about the old school tank is that it tends to be a pretty simple technology and unless it pops, it will deliver all the Hot Water I need with 0 maintenance.
 
I have been debating tankless vs tank heater for about a year. My house is brand new (about a year old now) and the rental unit that was included costs me about $15 per month. The digital valve on it has failed three times since I've been here and (I've been told by the repair guys) will continue to do so. I was going to get a tankless unit since the rent is on $20 per month and it occupies less space AND (most importantly) does not run out of hot water. I didn't do it right away because I needed to get a water softener first or the warranty would be void. Have the water softener, but I'm still on the fence about it.

These are all over the place in Europe, but the difference is that they are usually very small units and installed at each location where hot water is needed. One in the kitchen, each bathroom, etc. This is the only method in which these units are truly efficient. You have almost zero "pipe loss" since the heater is right there. The only reasons to install these in our NA constructions is to save space and have continuous hot water availability. There is no real cost savings over tank heater.
 
From the information that I have read here and on the internet I do not think it is cost effective to have a tank less water heater in Canada. I have serviced my own tank water heaters in my rental properties and it is very simple and inexpensive to repair or replace. The parts to repair a tankless water heater are much more complicated and expensive.
 
Comparing standard and tankless, 'pipe loss' is a wash—so to speak—if you install in the same location, futurelegend. But there are energy savings if you only heat the water you actually use when you use it, vs. heating 250 or so liters and keeping it hot all day while no one's home, and all night while everyone's in bed just so you can run out of hot water in the six hours when everyone's using it at once. The heat-up cost may also be a wash (depending on the design efficiency of the two heat exchangers) but the eighteen hours of standby's all saved cost for tankless.

Even if you don't want to muck up the bathroom decor.
 
Except during the 8 - 9 months of the year we call heating season.

That depends on how hot you like to keep your furnace room.
That waste heat is not useful heat, the outside of a hot water tank shouldn't feel hot if its insulated properly, and its not going to heat your house.

I saved $75/month from a crappy, hydro toronto tank to a new Japanese tankless, and its been running fine for 3 years so far.
 
I'm in my basement quite a bit. You can hear when the tank comes on quite easily.

To be honest, I never (and I'm being serious) hear the damn thing come on if someone is not drawing hot water. Hell, I've gone away for a weekend, shut it off, come home, turned it back up and it still doesn't fire up.
 
This comes down to what you want to do. You can try to justify getting it or nt getting it according to savings or not savings, but really, the difference is so slim, it's too close to tell. If you're the kind of guy who wants to look green, then get it. If you don't care then do whatever. It won't matter in the long run. Let's face it...if a visitor wants to see your whole-house in-line tankless hot water system, that's pretty exciting. No-one wants to see your old tank.

To me, renting stuff is better. No worries. If anything breaks while I'm away, my wife can just call the supplier. They'll fix it for free. That's why I rent my hot water tank, my rogers box and I would rent my laundry if I could too. That's why I get extended warranties on cars. That's why I insure my house. That's why I have insurance on my furnace. Taking away any concern so I can concentrate on having fun is important to me. Others have different priorities. That's ok.
 
I saved $75/month from a crappy, hydro toronto tank to a new Japanese tankless, and its been running fine for 3 years so far.


If this be true then you had one piece of crap tank before you changed.

I just do not understand the costs savings in a rental but that is just me

I can get a new high end heater for 6 or 7 hundred bucks and assume a ten year life that far outweighs a rental
 
Further to flub's comment. Electric heat's not the best way to spend your house heating dollar, as it's very expensive. Though the heat from your water heater isn't entirely 'wasted', you'd do better for your money buying it cheaper at the furnace and at the water heater, and piping it directly where you want it, with minimum loss on the way.

If your gas water heater's not high efficiency, then every time it cycles a major part of it's heat energy wafts straight up the middle and out into the world. Makes them hard to insulate effectively. Even if it is a more efficient direct vent model, it's still cycling on and off unused for most of most folk's 24hr day.

Even back in the dim past when I was a kid, the old, uninsulated water heaters had been replaced by folks too smart to fall for the, '…it's not wasted if it heats your house' line. The old tanks split in half made funky planters.
 
I just do not understand the costs savings in a rental but that is just me

I don't think you ever save money by renting.... you're paying for any problems to be someone else's. Of course you are also at the mercy of their timeline for fixing said problems. (And yes you can pay even more to reduce those timelines). So for renters it's not about saving money.
 
Maybe new to Canada, but have seen them for years in Europe, appears we're behind the times in this area, it will catch on aggressively soon for all the reasons mentioned in this thread.
 
If this be true then you had one piece of crap tank before you changed.

I just do not understand the costs savings in a rental but that is just me

I can get a new high end heater for 6 or 7 hundred bucks and assume a ten year life that far outweighs a rental

This sort of ties into the millionaires vs middle class thread. A lot of it depends on how much can you invest that money for today. Some savvy investors will be able to make more money by investing that money as opposed to just throwing it towards a tank.

IMO everyone should be required to take a finance course in school, it teaches people that money is a function of time. $1 today is not equivalent to $1 a month from now. It also teaches how to identify a worthwhile investment.

I can afford to pay off my current residence, own it free and clear. I choose to invest that money into my business which will more than cover the interest i'm paying on my mortgage.