Tankless Water Heaters

yes but you get what you pay for
 
You must have been watching the same episode of This Old House that I saw. The one on the show was gas, elecric tankless water heaters are also available. I can only speculate that the product is new and people are not willing to be the first to try it. In theory it is more efficient to heat water when you need it rather than to heat it and store it. The device will also go down in price when more people use it, the price is very high now compared to a old style water heater.
 
Guy I know installs them.... pretty much all the new homes he does these days are going tankless. Plus he's doing more and more retrofits when existing hot water tanks need replacing and the owners decide to go tankless.

Advantages: unlimited hot water, takes up a lot less space

Disadvantages: doesn't always click on if you only want a "trickle" of hot water, more expensive upfront cost

The payback cycle has gotten better now that the price has come down some the last few years. Used to be you never really got your money back until pretty much the end of it's life cycle (or worse), now they are apparently paying off a bit sooner so you do actually save some money over going the traditional route.
 
I've talked to people who have looked into it and they said it's worth it so long as you have a unit big enough to supply your household and, more importantly, you're going to live in the house long enough to make back the investment.
 
They use them where energy is expensive...

They generally seem to use them were energy is expensive (Lot of them in South America), so i would guess they work. Plus you can take as long a shower as you want, so that's always nice.
 
They are ok for small volume of hot water, but if want you want water in the kitchen and have a shower at the same time, forget it. They have been in the UK for decades.
 
Yes they do indeed save money.

A buddy of mine installed a whole house model and found that the savings on gas alone was $25 per month. He also bought his outright from a big box store so he is saving the monthly rental fee on the old hot water tank. So that was another $20 per month in his case. So based on that alone it wouldn't take but a few years to pay off the cost of the unit. The bad part about owning outright is that he is responsible for repairs to the unit if there is a problem. That was just what he ran into right around the US thanksgiving holiday last year. A main computer board broke and he was without hot water for 6 or 7 days due to the part coming from somewhere in the USA.

Other things to consider on a tankless water heater is the power goes out you have no hot water. My buddy also reports that it takes a bit of time for the hot water to kick in so there is some waste of water going on while it heats up.

Cheers
 
Other things to consider on a tankless water heater is the power goes out you have no hot water.
Iif you live in a location where this is not an unknown issue, you probably should have a back-up generator with the water heater being one of the circuits.

Plus even with a hot water tank - it isn't going to last that long without any electricity.
 
The Japanese have had them for many years, and they like to fill bath tubs with them with no problem. I don't know anyone here who has one but they have proven themselves overseas.
 
… edit… My buddy also reports that it takes a bit of time for the hot water to kick in so there is some waste of water going on while it heats up.

Cheers
Your old fashioned water tank 'wastes' all the water in the pipes between it and that tap you just turned on while you wait for the hot to arrive. If the tankless was installed in the same location, it cannot waste significantly more than that. It's the same distance. I measured just over a litre waste after install, but tankless water arrived at max temp, w/o a ramp-up. Since they're so small, the smart location is as close to the point of use as possible. I was able to shorten the pipe run by twenty some feet.

That trickle of hot you got used to adding to the cold stream before you splashed it on your face in the morning though, that's worth thinking about: the old tank had already heated that water a few times over the night, but only using a standby sort of amount of gas. The new unit's heating full out, even for that minor flow. Likely more economical nonetheless, but it's turned me into a basin filler.
 
I can only speculate that the product is new …
If it is what I am thinking of, the product is not new. If you spend any time in either NZ or the UK, there is a good chance you will be living in a place that has them. Generally, I did not have any problems with them but I don’t really know what my bills would have been without them, so I cannot compare.
 
I think it may be because we have the lowest electricity prices in the world that the payback would not come as quick as other places.
 
I think it may be because we have the lowest electricity prices in the world that the payback would not come as quick as other places.

Probably depends on the recommendor, but the guy I know who installs them would never recommend electric if gas was an option. Not sure of all the technical details, but apparently the electric version doesn't heat up as fast or as much (not sure which) as compared to equivalently priced gas unit. (which makes sense given that I believe in that tank water heaters, gas heats up the water faster than electric)
 
I don't know. You guys watch a lot of TV but those shows (this old house is a fine example) are not based on living frugally. a quick glance at Canadian Home Depot shows 8 gpm for 1200 bucks. Then you need installation on top. and maintenance. and you're on the hook to repair it if it breaks later. Since it's a full home unit, you still have waste in the pipes. So that savings is gone. So the only saving is the standby. hmmm. If you worry about that, insulate your hot water tank better. and in the winter, the heat leak is free as it's inside your house anyway.

Doesn't look like a good deal to me. Now, a little one under the kitchen sink may be nice. If I were rich.
 
and you're on the hook to repair it if it breaks later.

If you are deathly afraid of repairs, you could always use a small electric water heater as a backup tank. It is straightforward to have a backup water heater plumbed in, with valves to connect and disconnect it from the water supply.

Turn on the electric when the in-line fails.

Otherwise, if you have Natural Gas, always use a gas fired heater. They cost much less for operation. I'm not sure that the savings for the in-line heaters is present however. My best estimate of my gas usage for water heating was about $20 per month. It takes a long time to save $1200 dollars by improving the efficiency, when the total expense is $20/month.

In-line gas pays for itself against electric, because all gas fired heaters are much less costly to operate than the electric heaters.
 
If you are deathly afraid of repairs,...
That's a funny exaggeration. My hot water tank costs 11 bucks a month to rent. If it fails, and they all do, they will send 3 guys with a new one and install. all for free. What's that worth to you? It's worth a lot to me. If I had to estimate, I'd say about $600 or $700. The cost of repair is usually not taken into account when savings are discussed. I'm not against in-line. It's just the way it's marketted.
 
I bought my old gas water heater outright. The arithmetic at the time showed I'd be making money compared to rental after just less than five years. Never had a service call, nor on the previous one that came w/ the house we owned for over a decade.

Seems to me that "…deathly afraid of repairs" pretty accurately describes the only really good reason for renting. Three years trouble-free on a bought unit will buy that first service call, and if my experience is anything to go by, you may sell the house first.

As cooks will tell you, gas will get that water hot faster from cold than electricity. So it's far and away the best bet for tankless HW. But if you don't care about fast because you're cooking up 250 litres and holding it on standby, you don't care about that.

Another bonus: if you heat w/ hot water the tankless unit may replace your old boiler.
 
So the only saving is the standby. hmmm. If you worry about that, insulate your hot water tank better. and in the winter, the heat leak is free as it's inside your house anyway.

Absolutely correct. This is the one key piece of data manufacturers of tankless water heaters conveniently omit. If you live in the tropics, standby loss is a big waste. If you live in Ontario, you heat your home (on average) 8 - 9 months per year. During this time, standby "loss" is a wash. So if you take whatever savings are quoted, and only count about 30% of that, you'll have the true number.