T.E. Lawrence - or - Everything old is new again

Aardvark154

New member
Jan 19, 2006
53,709
3
0
An interesting article in the Sunday Times (London)

Countering a lot of "conventional wisdom."

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/article1496223.ece

To summarize:

Many of the 4,500 soldiers involved in Nato’s biggest offensive against the Taliban, will be recalling the words of Twenty-Eight Articles: Fundamentals of Company-Level Counterinsurgency based on TE Lawrence’s Twenty-Seven Articles, a guide for British officers working with Arabs during the First World War which has circulated like wildfire among those fighting in Afghanistan and Iraq. It’s fundamental argument is that Counterinsurgency differers from counterterrorism. Counterterrorism is enemy-centeric “destroy the terrorists then the problem goes away.” Counterinsurgency recognizes that the problem is a quiescent population which is preyed on by a hostile element, so instead of going after that, you should go and protect the population and try to win their allegiance.

Perhaps the most important [rule] is “know your turf”. “In Afghanistan the population don’t exercise choice individually, it’s collectively. You win or lose this place a village or valley at a time.” After more than five years in Afghanistan, the US military now understands that. “If you watch the way American forces operate, the first thing they do before they even deploy a soldier is engage with the local population and talk to their leaders. A lot of American operations now are planned by sitting down with the provincial governor, the military and police chief and local villagers. That would have been unimaginable back in 2001.” That pattern didn’t emerge by accident. America, unlike European countries, has rotated its troops back to the same areas each time so you have people operating in Afghanistan who have done two or three stints in the same place. They know the villages, know the valleys, know the people and know what not to do from mistakes made last time.”

The Europeans have been making a lot heavier use of air power than the Americans. Most people killed by American troops - which is relatively low compared with the Europeans - have been killed in direct rifle fire, in one-on-one engagement where people are actively shooting at the Americans and they take them out, so there’s a pretty high chance they are killing the right people.”

The article also points out the false analogy with Vietnam, pointing out that the Taliban are all from Pashtun tribes which only make up between 23% and 40% of the population. “The potential appeal of the Vietcong was unlimited. All Vietnamese could see something for them in the Vietcong agenda. But that’s just not the case with Taliban.
 
Last edited:
DonQuixote said:
Lawrence was the author of insurgency warfare.

Its good to see him getting his due respect.
I continue to recommend his classic history
of combat against the Ottoman Turks in
the Arabian Peninsula:
The Seven Pillars of Wisdom.
Too bad Lancs doesn't have an interest
in history.


He does indeed. I quite like the story of lawrences' life. he was an extremely complex and conflicted individual. He was WW1's version of Orde Wingate who was just as odd a soul.
 
Morning Don.

papa is in a feisty mood this morning.


Britain has produced more than its share of colourful characters.

I fellow I know once told me that the expression "thinking outside the box" does not apply to the English because they refuse to recognize the existence of the " box".
 
LancsLad said:
Morning Don.

papa is in a feisty mood this morning.

Try and help him. He won't listen to me.