Swiss Bank Pleads Guilty - why?

afterhours

New member
Jul 14, 2009
6,315
4
0
It does not seize to amaze me how long is the arm of US law enforcement.
I am sure these bankers had a good reason to plead, but can anyone guess why did they agree to plead and to pay millions in fines?
The plea agreement https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B0SLTNWD-Z3YSHRGRThEbmhrQmc/edit?pli=1 stipulates that it does not protect individuals, and three bank managers indeed have been indicted, but not the bank directors. Was there an unwritten promise not to go after the directors?


Wegelin & Co. Admits It Helped Americans Avoid Taxes With Secret Accounts

Wegelin & Co., founded in 1741, plans to shut after the matter is closed.

However, the private bank, which plans to close its doors once the matter wraps up, is the first to plead guilty to a criminal charge in the U.S. government's probe.

The broad investigation, which began in 2008, has set off tensions between the U.S. and Switzerland over its bank secrecy laws. U.S. authorities have pressured the Swiss for the names of Americans with Swiss accounts.

Meanwhile, Swiss authorities last year gave banks permission to provide some information to U.S. authorities. They have since been hoping to reach a sweeping settlement with the U.S. that would address handing over information about Swiss accounts to the U.S. and the U.S. taxing of assets held in Switzerland.

Otto Bruderer, Wegelin's managing partner, entered a guilty plea on the bank's behalf at a hearing in Manhattan federal court on Thursday and said the bank, between 2002 and 2010, knew U.S. taxpayers maintained secret accounts at Wegelin in order to evade U.S. taxes.

"Wegelin was aware that this conduct was wrong," Mr. Bruderer said during the hearing. "However, Wegelin believed that, as a practical matter, it would not be prosecuted in the United States for this conduct because it had no branches or offices in the United States and because of its understanding that it acted in accordance with, and not in violation of, Swiss law and that such conduct was common in the Swiss banking industry."

As part of its plea, Wegelin, based in St. Gallen, Switzerland, agreed to forfeit $15.8 million and give up another $20 million representing the amount of taxes avoided as a result of its conduct. The bank also faces a fine of between $14.7 million and $29.4 million.

Sentencing is set for March 4.

Wegelin sold its non-U.S. operations to Swiss retail bank Raiffeisen in January 2011 in a bid to protect its assets from charges it had helped U.S. clients avoid paying taxes

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323874204578219572734283146.html
 
A bank with a conscience. I thought those were extinct....

I have no idea how big this bank is, but $20 million representing avoided taxes seems very low. Besides which, why would the bank itself pay that? I can understand paying a fine for improper conduct, but it seems their clients are the one's who should be paying the avoided taxes (plus interest :evil:).
 
Generally because the costs of contesting the case are more than the penalty assessed, and any guilty plea can't be held against individuals.

It is a shame that a bank which has survived this long is going out of business.

Might one add that this all came to pass because a Swiss Bank employed someone who seemingly felt that his loyalty lay not with the bank or Swiss law, but rather with the concept that no one should be able to shield money from taxes. So he sang to the U.S. IRS.
 
Generally because the costs of contesting the case are more that the penalty assessed, and any guilty plea can't be held against individuals.

It is a shame that a bank which has survived this long is going out of business.

they initially chose not to show up in US court though...why change of mind? must have been big hand twisting, no? there is three pending indictments against client advisers...

how would the US physically go after them is my question
 
how would the US physically go after them is my question
Certainly any assets in the U.S., then any assets outside Switzerland in states with which the U.S. has tax treaties or the ability to twist arms.

I rather agree that the arm of the IRS is overly long.
 
Certainly any assets in the U.S., then any assets outside Switzerland in states with which the U.S. has tax treaties or the ability to twist arms.

I rather agree that the arm of the IRS is overly long.

But Wegelin sold its non-U.S. operations to Swiss retail bank Raiffeisen in January 2011 in a bid to protect its assets from charges it had helped U.S. clients avoid paying taxes...
 
But Wegelin sold its non-U.S. operations to Swiss retail bank Raiffeisen in January 2011 in a bid to protect its assets from charges it had helped U.S. clients avoid paying taxes...
They must have something or an interest in something, either that or exposure in places that have solid tax treaties with the U.S.A.

Otherwise I agree with you and am left shaking my head.
 
They must have something or an interest in something, either that or exposure in places that have solid tax treaties with the U.S.A.

well, it's either this, or (I would have thought more likely, except it's excluded by the plea agreement) the US threatened to go after directors personally and off the record promised not to do so if the bank pleads
 
Senior employees (read managing partners) were being put under criminal indictments. They would likely have been extradited to the US to face criminal charges of assisting tax evasion. They paid money to avoid prison time.

That's how they got Capone.
 
you think switzerland would have agreed to an extradition?

Depends what treaties the countries agreed to in the past. Given that the bank paid up I guess the partners weren't willing to take the chance. No doubt these guys have the best legal advice.
 
Senior employees (read managing partners) were being put under criminal indictments. They would likely have been extradited to the US to face criminal charges of assisting tax evasion. They paid money to avoid prison time.
Given that Switzerland "caved" regarding their banking privacy laws, you may well be correct.
 
Afterhours, the following legal blogs may explain this better:

http://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/switzerland-responds-to-wegelin-indictme-89106/

http://www.assetlawyer.com/wordpress/?p=1237

The Plea Agreement
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B0SLTNWD-Z3YSHRGRThEbmhrQmc/edit?pli=1


Wangbang, I believe that you are on the right track, apparently Wegelin & Co. was set up like Lloyds (London) so that the Directors had unlimited liability. Which opens another conversation, why on earth they never took advantage of Swiss limited liability laws.

Further by bring criminal charges and leveling IRS penalties against both Wegelin and personally against the bank directors, the US government chased away the bank’s customers
 
It does not seize to amaze me how long is the arm of US law enforcement.

Cease, not seize.
It's miscomprehension between the 2 words, not a spelling mistake. Seize means to take possession of and cease, means to discontinue and stop.
What he meant is that it does not cease to amaze him etc. therefore it doesn't surprise him that it is continuing and not stopping.
 
Last edited:
Generally because the costs of contesting the case are more than the penalty assessed, and any guilty plea can't be held against individuals.

It is a shame that a bank which has survived this long is going out of business.

Might one add that this all came to pass because a Swiss Bank employed someone who seemingly felt that his loyalty lay not with the bank or Swiss law, but rather with the concept that no one should be able to shield money from taxes. So he sang to the U.S. IRS.

Not to mention the reward
 
Afterhours, the following legal blogs may explain this better:

http://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/switzerland-responds-to-wegelin-indictme-89106/

http://www.assetlawyer.com/wordpress/?p=1237

The Plea Agreement
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B0SLTNWD-Z3YSHRGRThEbmhrQmc/edit?pli=1


Wangbang, I believe that you are on the right track, apparently Wegelin & Co. was set up like Lloyds (London) so that the Directors had unlimited liability. Which opens another conversation, why on earth they never took advantage of Swiss limited liability laws.

Further by bring criminal charges and leveling IRS penalties against both Wegelin and personally against the bank directors, the US government chased away the bank’s customers
thanks for the links
it's even scarier than I thought, the US twisting the Swiss govt hand and they in turn go after banks...It's an interesting world we live in.

The Wegelin indictment and asset seizure can also be viewed as a statement that the U.S. has more leverage in the four year old offensive against banking secrecy, that unless the Swiss deliver what DOJ wants, the U.S. can cripple the Swiss banking system and severely affect the Swiss economy. This is exactly why UBS caved to the US in 2009. For UBS to not have revealed the secret UBS accounts would have resulted in extreme U.S. action, with significant negative consequences to not only UBS, but to Switzerland in its entirety. Thus, large banks like UBS and Credit Suisse, with assets in the U.S., had a clear vulnerability to U.S. legal action. Now, it is clear that small banks, even those without a U.S. presence, are also vulnerable.
 
On the other hand Afterhours, it is clear that the banks were deliberately and knowingly violating U.S. Law.
 
Indeed there was a connection. They were facilitating the evasion of tax by U.S. Nationals, and they were using correspondent banks in the U.S.A. to do so.

I am not disputing that US may well assert jurisdiction, I am trying to figure out what has actually been done to get the bank to surrender and most of all, what would have been done if it refused to do so.