Survivor Bullshit

Heh, people can say what they want about Survivor not being to their taste but the fact that it's still on and still garnering huge ratings speaks for itself.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Heh, people can say what they want about Survivor not being to their taste but the fact that it's still on and still garnering huge ratings speaks for itself.

Who was it that said that there's no underestimating the taste of the public?
 
revolver said:
I guess I've been under a rock too. What does jumping a shark mean?

The term "jumping the shark" refers to the point where a TV show does something really silly, and goes downhill from there. It has its origins from the episode of 'Happy Days' where Fonzie actually waterskis over some sharks. According to critics, the show stopped being any good at that point.

I have watched all the Survivors, and some are better than others, but I still find the show entertaining. The show is silly and contrived, of course, but that doesn't mean it doesn't make for good trashy TV. Like others, I like Stephanie too, she is clearly the star of this edition of Survivor. I agree Probst egged on the bony ass chick to quit, but ultimately, it was her decision to actually do it.

Does anyone else think Stephanie is reminiscent of a younger, hotter, Tyne Daly?
 
It's important to remember you're watching a very heavily edited version that goes to air.

The Tribal Council meetings we see last for only a few minutes, they very well could be 2 hours for the contestants. I had the same opinion as many here that Probst affected the final result, but knowing how they edit..those questions could have been in the first few minutes of 2 hours of questions.

Recently an article on The Apprentice spoke on the fact that several of the Board room Meetings to deternine who left went nearly 5 hours in length.

These shows are tailor made week by week, and with the advantage of knowing what is coming up in the next few weeks they edit them to make us watch.

The second most important sweeps in the US start April 28th and end May 25th. You will see all you favorite shows come to season finales during this time.

After that..enjoy the ones you didn't watch on summer reruns!
 
anon1 said:
Who was it that said that there's no underestimating the taste of the public?

Don't know, don't care. Who says your taste is any better? Not to mention that it's funny people who can't stand Survivor somehow find the time to follow this thread and comment on it... :rolleyes:


I agree with the point about the show being heavily edited. No doubt. But what matters is the final product that comes across on the tube, and if that leaves a perception of jury tampering then the producers have got a problem. Maybe Probst brow-beats players on a regular basis but it doesn't make it to air; but this time it did and it made the episode look unfair and fixed. Maybe it was just a case of horrible editing, I dunno.
 
which is more entertaining, TAR or Survivor?

I prefer TAR (The Amazing Race) because it is less predictable. TAR concept is about travelling in foreign land and interacting with local people. Survivor is about planning strategy, making alliance and lying.
 
bornonaug9 said:
I prefer TAR (The Amazing Race) TAR concept is about travelling in foreign land and interacting with local people. Survivor is about planning strategy, making alliance and lying.

Survivor is about planning strategy, making alliance and lying...... isn't that what's Boston B's doing on TAR ? :D

I like TAR a bit more though, I must say.
 
Berlin said:
Survivor is about planning strategy, making alliance and lying...... isn't that what's Boston B's doing on TAR ? :D

I like TAR a bit more though, I must say.

One could argue that any competition can be "enhanced" with a little allliance making and lying. I don't see anything wrong with Boston Rob adding a "Survivor" touch to TAR. Obviously the powers that be at CBS wanted Rob and Amber to add a different spin to TAR when they approached them, and that's what they got. It makes for good TV.

Back to Steph and the Tyne Daly thing... No, Tyne Daly was never hot. Not even when she was young and in 'The Enforcer' with Clint. But Steph just reminds of her for some reason.
 
Berlin said:
Survivor is about planning strategy, making alliance and lying...... isn't that what's Boston B's doing on TAR ? :D

I like TAR a bit more though, I must say.

You are talking about the exception. More uncontrollable elements in TAR, like flights and connections. Decision on " Fast Forward" and "Road Block" lead to different outcomes.

Like the last show, Fast Forward is actually the head shaving ritual that Brandon and Nicole rejected in Amazing Race 5, yet Joyce made the decision to go ahead and do it. As this was an elimination leg, a choice of keeping her hair potentially would have cost them the entire game. it
 
Survivor undoubtedly requires good strategizing if you want to be the winner. You've got to figure out what you're going to do, what everyone else is going to do, and how it will all play out in the end. It's like playing chess with a whole bunch of different people all at the same time.

The complexity of it all is why a lot of the, ahem, "simpler" folk don't often make it to the end. The exception is when someone is brought along for the ride in an alliance; which is a strategy in and of itself if you can turn the tables on your "benefactors" later on.
 
THANK GOD Steph got the boot this week. My disgust in Probst's interference has been laid to rest. Phew!
 
Steph just couldn't overcome the odds against her. It is still amazing to me how her tribe lost every immunity challenge. If she had been in a halfway competitive tribe, she'd still be in the game.
 
It was kinda anticlimatic. The guy who jumped off isn't going to be remembered for trying to redeem himself; he's going to be remembered for being a quitter.
 
I missed the final show but I take it Tom won? Does anyone know what the final vote count was?

My guess is Tom won handily. I'm guessing Caryn, Steph, the weird showgirl chick, Greg and Coby all voted for Tom. The only two who I could imagine voting for Katie were Jenn and Ian, but I could also have seen them voting for Tom. This ending kind of reminds me of the African installment, where the final two were Ethan and some very forgettable woman named Kim. Kim basically got to the finals by accident, and had done nothing up to that point to distinguish herself. She got there because she never pissed anyone off, and no one ever considered her a physical threat. Ethan got nearly every vote.

Katie was one of the weakest Survivor finalists ever. I thought the jury did a very nice job of summing up her "game"... Useless in camp, pathetic in challenges, and just kind of mean and nasty to be around. How the hell did she get as far she did?

I thought Ian's offer to step down was a misguided noble gesture. His so-called "best friend" Katie, wouldn't have done that for him in a million years. Maybe he figured he had no chance to win against Tom anyway in a jury vote, so why not go out looking like a classy guy? Ian's bigger mistake was the slip of the tongue he made earlier which made Tom realize he would betray Tom.
 
I think Katie only got 1 vote, and it was from the gay guy who didn't like Tom (I could be wrong, but I never heard Probst say what the final tally was since Tom got the 4 votes he needed after Probst only read 5 votes). Katie didn't stand a snowball's chance in hell and I think Ian vs. Tom would have been a much more interesting finale.

IMO, Katie really was useless and didn't deserve to win. Yes, she made it to the final two (b/c the person who deserved it more dropped out) but I in no way think she worked as hard to get there as Tom or Ian.
 
Keebler Elf said:
I think Katie only got 1 vote, and it was from the gay guy who didn't like Tom (I could be wrong, but I never heard Probst say what the final tally was since Tom got the 4 votes he needed after Probst only read 5 votes).

I guess it doesn't really matter, because Tom won no matter how you look at it, but I always like to conjecture...

Coby didn't like Tom because Tom was an alpha male who didn't let Coby play in his reindeer games. But I don't imagine he liked Katie much either. I guess he could have gone either way.

Janu didn't like Katie because Katie was a bitch to her. She was voting for Tom.

Steph may have felt a little betrayed by Tom, but she had respect for his game. I don't see her voting for Katie.

Greg was definitely betrayed by Tom, but I think he was betrayed more by Katie. I think he voted for Tom.

Caryn seemed to have bonded with Tom, even though she was never officially in his alliance. She and Katie didn't get along either. She voted for Tom.

Jenn felt disrespected by Tom, and may have voted for Katie.

Ian probably felt loyalty to both, but my guess is he voted for Tom.

I agree Ian/Tom would have been a more interesting final, but I think Tom still wins. I also think this was a relatively poorly played game. In previous installments, when there is someone who is clearly a physical threat, that person gets taken out. Ian had ample opportunities to get rid of Tom and turn the game in his favor, but he never did. I guess it is admirable that he felt loyalty to Tom, but that's not how the game is played.
 
Planning Strategies, Making Alliances and Lying

bornonaug9 said:
I prefer TAR (The Amazing Race) because it is less predictable. TAR concept is about travelling in foreign land and interacting with local people. Survivor is about planning strategy, making alliance and lying.
So is the Amazing Race. But the right couple won.

It's all in the editing, and because it's do or die for BIG cash, anything goes. You see what they want to show you, for RATINGS.

They should have done a few episodes all at once, before hitting the TV. Now people try to copy what they saw on previous episodes, and OUTPLAYING, is copying rather than thinking on their own(OUTWITTING). There have been a couple of sideways manouvers that paid off to advance someone in the game, and "Jonny Paycheck" was probably the sneakiest with his dead grandmother.

There will always be favourites, who bring the ratings up. I think they should do a live Survivour, and let America vote the person off, based on tape shown thursday night. Let the tribe pick 2 poeple, and let us vote them off. Hey American Idol seems to work with the public voting people out.
 
Survivor 13 is going to be filmed in Canada.
Next summer Mark Burnett & his band of fake reality contestants,will arrive here in Toronto to start production of that year's episode of Survivor.






It's tentatively going to be titled Survivor Jane & Finch :p