Suing the government

Platon

Active member
Oct 21, 2013
383
201
43
Brian Peckford who was involved in creation of the Charter is suing the government for violating it:
 
Last edited:
I do not have the time nor the interest to watch a 90 minute video. What did the government violated?
 
I do not have the time nor the interest to watch a 90 minute video. What did the government violated?
To be specific they infringed on the right of Canadians to move freely. The guy explains why the clause which allows for suspension of constitutional freedoms does not apply in this particular case. I suggest you watch/listen as it provides an interesting perspective on current events.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: whitehill_21
To be specific they infringed on the right of Canadians to move freely. The guy explains why the clause which allows for suspension of constitutional freedoms does not apply in this particular case. I suggest you watch/listen as it provides an interesting perspective on current events.

Not sure what the rights to move freely relies on but unvax travel restriction do fall under the authority of the Minister of Health through emergency orders under the Quarantine Act and of the Minister of Transport through interim orders under the Aeronautics Act.

Basically it's 2 different minister that had their orders linked together to be able to implement such mandate (which were applied in many other countries).
 
Not sure what the rights to move freely relies on but unvax travel restriction do fall under the authority of the Minister of Health through emergency orders under the Quarantine Act and of the Minister of Transport through interim orders under the Aeronautics Act.

Basically it's 2 different minister that had their orders linked together to be able to implement such mandate (which were applied in many other countries).
If you are not sure and you haven't listened to the podcast why make an argument? You don't know what the guy is talking about and you are trying to discuss it 🤦‍♂️
 
  • Like
Reactions: whitehill_21
If you are not sure and you haven't listened to the podcast why make an argument? You don't know what the guy is talking about and you are trying to discuss it 🤦‍♂️


It looks like he is arguing that the vaccinations are ineffective, so there is no good foundation for travel restrictions based on vaccination status.

I'm thinking this is a win for the government.

“Despite the confirmed science that the vaccine does not stop people from getting or spreading the virus and the repeated warnings from the WHO, it’s clear the federal government is out of step and arbitrarily restricting Canadians fundamental rights and freedoms,” says Keith Wilson, Q.C., lead counsel for the legal challenge. “It is profoundly disturbing that a marginalized group in Canada—the unvaccinated—are essentially prohibited from leaving the country,” he adds.
 

It looks like he is arguing that the vaccinations are ineffective, so there is no good foundation for travel restrictions based on vaccination status.

I'm thinking this is a win for the government.
JCCF files suit, enough said.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
It looks like he is arguing that the vaccinations are ineffective, so there is no good foundation for travel restrictions based on vaccination status.

I'm thinking this is a win for the government.
To be more specific he's arguing that the current emergency does not threaten existence of the state/country and as such cannot be used to justify suspension of constitutional freedoms.
 
Last edited:
People can read it for themselves. It is very much about the vaccines.


And I might add, it is a lot less painful than 90 minutes of youtube.
Right, you're missing about 85 minutes of it and so you miss the part where the guy says it in plain English yet you're still trying to convince me what it is all about. Did you bother to read section 2 (e) Charter violation, specifically 2 (e) 40 c v-vi?
 
Right, you're missing about 85 minutes of it and so you miss the part where the guy says it in plain English yet you're still trying to convince me what it is all about. Did you bother to read section 2 (e) Charter violation, specifically 2 (e) 40 c v-vi?

Did you read the actual court doc? Jesus fucking christ... I am not going to listen to a moron on youtube when i can read it in plain english.
 
Did you read the actual court doc? Jesus fucking christ... I am not going to listen to a moron on youtube when i can read it in plain english.
I begin to understand why we have a coward in hiding for a "leader" and the country is going down the drain at a dramatic pace. And yes don't bother with the "moron on youtube" I doubt it will be helpful ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: whitehill_21
I begin to understand why we have a coward in hiding for a "leader" and the country is going down the drain at a dramatic pace. And yes don't bother with the "moron on youtube" I doubt it will be helpful ;)

Have you read the actual court doc? Not sure why you are preferring to not think for yourself.
 
Have you read the actual court doc? Not sure why you are preferring to not think for yourself.
Have you read what I replied to you before? Or do you just jump to conclusion after the first couple of words you see, is that how you read the doc? Did you see this in my reply: Did you bother to read section 2 (e) Charter violation, specifically 2 (e) 40 c v-vi?
 
Have you read what I replied to you before? Or do you just jump to conclusion after the first couple of words you see, is that how you read the doc? Did you see this in my reply: Did you bother to read section 2 (e) Charter violation, specifically 2 (e) 40 c v-vi?

Yes, the sections that focus on vaccinations as violations of charter rights, as I've been saying? People can go read for themselves. Have a great day...

For example...


2(e) 40. The Vaccine Provisions of the Decision are a violation of the Applicants’ Charter rights....

c.Section 7: life, liberty, and security of the person, by prohibiting air travel unless
the Applicants receive an experimental medical procedure contrary to their will and
without their fully informed consent, which violates The Nuremberg Code (1947),
interferes with their bodily autonomy, subjects them to the risks of harmful side
effects or death, and impedes their ability to move freely across the country
internationally, all in a coercive manner that is arbitrary, overbroad, and grossly
disproportionate;
 
Yes, the sections that focus on vaccinations as violations of charter rights, as I've been saying? People can go read for themselves. Have a great day...

For example...


2(e) 40. The Vaccine Provisions of the Decision are a violation of the Applicants’ Charter rights....

c.Section 7: life, liberty, and security of the person, by prohibiting air travel unless
the Applicants receive an experimental medical procedure contrary to their will and
without their fully informed consent, which violates The Nuremberg Code (1947),
interferes with their bodily autonomy, subjects them to the risks of harmful side
effects or death, and impedes their ability to move freely across the country
internationally, all in a coercive manner that is arbitrary, overbroad, and grossly
disproportionate;
Exactly, the argument is that the Decision is arbitrary, overbroad and grossly disproportionate. You omitted the part I cited specifically:
v. Section 7 Charter rights can only be infringed in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice. The principles of fundamental justice require that the impugned legislation not be grossly disproportionate, arbitrary, or overly broad;
And later in (f)
43: The Bill of Rights has among its objects the affirmation of the dignity and worth of the human person in Canadian society, and the respect for the rule of law. It is paramount to other federal legislation and regulations and is quasi-constitutional in nature. The Aeronautics Act and the Decision must be construed and applied as not to abrogate, abridge or infringe, or to authorize the abrogation, abridgment or infringement, of the rights and freedoms recognized and declared in the Bill of Rights.
45: The Decision was not made by due process of law. Among other things,
a. The Decision was not subject to legislative controls customarily applied to the introduction of a new law. As a result, Canadians did not receive the benefit of multiple readings or parliamentary debate and scrutiny;
b. The Minister of Transport has made the Decision in an overly broad manner, without due consideration of the rights of the Applicants; and
c. There was no, or insufficient, stakeholder engagement or consultation prior to the Decision.
So the argument is a little more than just "vaccine ineffectiveness" like you suggested prior.
 
Right, you're missing about 85 minutes of it and so you miss the part where the guy says it in plain English yet you're still trying to convince me what it is all about. Did you bother to read section 2 (e) Charter violation, specifically 2 (e) 40 c v-vi?
So the video is more reliable than the actual application to the courts?