suing for slander/defamation? Worth it?

ILOVETHIS

Member
Jun 12, 2006
452
2
18
Personally I don't think its worth it but I have a friend that wants to. They went to a job interview a while back and was notified by the hiring company that they had received a bad reference. Didn't say who it was , just co worker from the company. They didn't get the job but thinks they didn't get was because of the bad reference. They have an email stating they got a bad reference but no mention of a name, just a claim from "x company".

They want to sue but I don't think it worth it. Not enough information. Even if there was, its too much of a hassle.
 
They should talk to a labour lawyer like Howard Levitt.

The advice he gave me years ago was never give a "bad - do not hire" reference.
 
They should talk to a labour lawyer like Howard Levitt.

The advice he gave me years ago was never give a "bad - do not hire" reference.

Here's an article by Levitt actually: http://business.financialpost.com/e...-letter-can-be-a-legal-landmine-for-employers

Basically, "reference letters enjoy qualified privilege if the employer honestly believes the contents, even if objectively untrue and defamatory." So to succeed you'd have to prove that the bad reference was given maliciously.
 
Not worth it. Unless your friend can prove the bad reference was made maliciously, the lawsuit will not succeed.
 
From the info in your post things look very thin. Your friend does not have the name of the bad reference nor does he have what was said. It is time and money wasted to pursue this matter.
 
That is why if i know i was on bad terms with a previous employer i will leave that company off my resume
 
Personally I don't think its worth it but I have a friend that wants to. They went to a job interview a while back and was notified by the hiring company that they had received a bad reference. Didn't say who it was , just co worker from the company. They didn't get the job but thinks they didn't get was because of the bad reference. They have an email stating they got a bad reference but no mention of a name, just a claim from "x company".

They want to sue but I don't think it worth it. Not enough information. Even if there was, its too much of a hassle.

Ask Brian Burke how far he got.
 
They should talk to a labour lawyer like Howard Levitt.

The advice he gave me years ago was never give a "bad - do not hire" reference.

I've given a "bad - do not hire" reference a few times, but always verbally.

FAST
 
Here's an article by Levitt actually: http://business.financialpost.com/e...-letter-can-be-a-legal-landmine-for-employers

Basically, "reference letters enjoy qualified privilege if the employer honestly believes the contents, even if objectively untrue and defamatory." So to succeed you'd have to prove that the bad reference was given maliciously.


So if the bad reference can be inaccurate (but not malicious), perhaps the applicant should try to find out from the prospective employer as to what was said so that he can be given an opportunity to respond or explain.
 
The essence of defamation is malice, which has a special meaning in defamation cases.

When the former employer is asked for a reference, he is said to be responding on an occasion of qualified privilege; he has the right and is expected to express his honest opinion, even if mistaken, even if defamatory.

The plaintiff would have to prove that the former employer responded with actual malice -- meaning something like "he was out to get him" -- and that seems practically impossible on the simple facts described.

Above and beyond that, in this case the plaintiff would have to prove he actually suffered damages. The loss of a job opportunity -- as opposed to the loss of his existing job -- does not imply a financial loss.

Otherwise, even if he wins, he runs the risk of getting a judgment for $1 and be saddled with paying the defendant's costs of defending the claim.

The chances of the plaintiff winning this case are minuscule, at best. The risk of having to pay both his own and the defendant's costs is huge


As for you, you fucked up feline, Alexander Pope was thinking of you when he wrote about the coxcomb bird:

The coxcomb bird, so talkative and grave,
That from his cage cries cuckold, whore, and knave,
Tho’ many a passenger he rightly call,
You hold him no philosopher at all.


Perry
 
I have to admit one thing, you fucked up feline... you make me laugh... you are one of the biggest jokes around! :nod:

Thanks!

Perry
 
I have to admit one thing, you fucked up feline... you make me laugh... you are one of the biggest jokes around! :nod:

Thanks!

Perry

Perry,

Is that laughing or cackling? It is hard to tell. Maybe the Head Cackler bit you when he was giving you head. You know, that cackler that shows up to help you once in a while. I think he is trying to recruit you as a side kick.
 
I have worked for 2 large Crown Corporations, 1 large international IT company and mid-size software companies. The direction from all HR groups was basically the same...if you are called for a reference you were to only state that "yes, so and so was employed between Date A and Date B." We were never to divulge any performance ratings, positive or negative. It was critical in a unionized environment to be extra careful.
Keeps it simple no matter how much you hated the former employee.

A friend just retired as VP HR for a large NA retailer and it is their policy to NEVER check references provided by the applicant. Waste of time. Instead, in addition to all of the psyhcometric testing, they now explore your comments, picture postings, etc on social media to get a more truthful picture of who you really are outside as that does translate to who you will be inside.

On Terb we all have phony handles. for posting I do the same on Instagram, Facebook, etc and they all link to non-descript hotmail / gmail addresses. I do have my real name Instagram and FB but they just have pictures of fluffy cats and useless shit that my mom posts. I never posted on those accounts. If ever asked by an HR type I would provide those "clean" accounts.