Subway Line to York U

Plan B

Race Relations Expert
Jun 7, 2008
1,055
5
38
Finally, some transit development in this city which is long overdue. So perhaps in 2015 you can ride the subway a few more stops. If there are no delays that is. Wouldn't above ground light rail transit make more sense in this city? It would be much cheaper, and faster to build.

http://www.thestar.com/News/GTA/article/467117
 
Plan B said:
Finally, some transit development in this city which is long overdue. So perhaps in 2015 you can ride the subway a few more stops. If there are no delays that is. Wouldn't above ground light rail transit make more sense in this city? It would be much cheaper, and faster to build.

http://www.thestar.com/News/GTA/article/467117

"World class" cities don't do things cheaper and faster. :D
 
Yeah but Toronto gets heavy snow in the winter...I seen that in Miami and it was a little scary up there going around the turns too--like if it jump the tracks I knew I was dead :(

Its too bad it wasn't done long ago

Edit....sure the snow could get knock off but where would it fell, likely somewhere else its not welcome.
 
The big problem with light rail is finding clear laneways through dense urban environments. It can be prohibitively expensive, if not impossible, to build above ground. If Toronto was all undeveloped land, then it would be a no-brainer.

Building underground is more expensive but at least you don't have to worry as much about acquiring land.

I think the GTA needs to continue to expand its subway and GO rail systems. Yeah, it may be expensive and it may not be expanding (today) in an area that I find useful, but remember, it's all about "baby steps." I'd rather see a little bit of progress than endless debate with no results.
 
TTC is currently studying LRT in their "Transit City" initiative.

It is proposed to build LRT lines on 7 different locations, however, it is still very very much up in the air.

They call it LRT. I would call it "Dedicated Street Car Lanes" like we currently have on Spadina, Queens Quay, and the contentious "St Claire"

There was so much controversy and public opposition to the St. Claire Dedicated Street Car line that I think they decided to change the name to LRT. To me though, LRT is something like what Calgary is building, or what Toronto currently has in Scarborough.

They are currently studying lines on:

Eglinton - stupid imho. Should be a subway, especially when you hear that several kms are going to be underground street car, and believe it or not, there is debate on whether the tunnels should be built to be converted to subway at a later date. Beyond stupid. Build the freaking subway NOW.

Sheppard - also stupid. Should extend the existing subway.

Lakeshore - there are several studies being done on this one as Joe Pantalone (Deputy Mayor) is pushing hard for an LRT on Dufferin running from the Ex, right up to the Dufferin Subway. (Keeping in mind that construction of the Dufferin Jog Elimination Portal is scheduled to commence this fall.

Don Mills - meh, whatever, I live in the west end.

Jane - many doubt that this will ever be built as buses currently serve it pretty well.

www.transitcity.ca

Keeping in mind TTC is in the process of taking bids to buy new streetcars, however, no-one bidding could meet the spec that TTC wanted. Not even Bombardier.

It's now back to the drawing table.
 
In Chicago, the subway runs right in the middle of the freeway, like on the Allen Expressway in Toronto. One thing that might make sense is to knock off one lane on each direction of the 401, and build a subway there. Or would this make traffic worse?
 
Plan B said:
In Chicago, the subway runs right in the middle of the freeway, like on the Allen Expressway in Toronto. One thing that might make sense is to knock off one lane on each direction of the 401, and build a subway there. Or would this make traffic worse?

Problem is, the 401 is owned by the province (MTO).

I doubt they'd be willing to give up turf to the city, especially when you consider MTO has just laid out billions to add 1 lane to the express between 427 and 404.

Also, the big cost associated with subways is not the cost of constructing the tunnels, it's the cost of building the stations.
 
I really think they need a subway along either King or Queen. Those streetcars are pack to capacity during rush hour. I would be very surprised if the ridership of such a route would not pay for its operating costs and have a surplus left over for the rest of the system. However, an extension to York is also good
 
Yes, I've often said that a Queen Street Car is needed from Victoria Park to High Park, or Even Sherway Gardens.

If they could extend Bloor southwest to Sherway, and build a Queen Line to Sherway, you would have an excellent terminal.

I don't know if I'll ever see that in my life though.

The interesting thing is that up until the early 80's the TTC was always building subway in small pieces. A station here, a few hundred metres of track there. It was a good idea.

I'm happy to see Spadina being extended, however, there is so much more we need to do.

One of the main reasons that I lamented the loss of the 2008 Olympics to Bejing was the fact that so much infrastructure would have been built - like new subway lines.
 
I am all for promoting rapid public transit in Toronto and other cities. However, this transit plan, it seems to me, is only promoting urban sprawl. Subways are great, but with limited public money to invest, Toronto is shifting to LRT. It is cheaper and has a shorter completion time.

I agree with someone that the priority for subway construction should be closer to the downtown core. King St. or Queen St. makes much more sense. Maybe even Eglinton Av. Its hard to say without knowing the ridership numbers. But I can't agree with extending the Sheppard subway. It is a bust as it is. Extending it with LRT is a good idea. The new line to York U should also be LRT. Subways should be used to build up density closer to downtown, not to extend the subway system to the outer borders of the city.
 
james t kirk said:
Problem is, the 401 is owned by the province (MTO).

I doubt they'd be willing to give up turf to the city, especially when you consider MTO has just laid out billions to add 1 lane to the express between 427 and 404.

Also, the big cost associated with subways is not the cost of constructing the tunnels, it's the cost of building the stations.

I think you're wrong on both counts.

The province may very well love to give up the 401 and all its associated maintenance costs. They gave the Gardner to Toronto and it's been nothing but a headache.

How do you figure the bigger cost is the stations? It's extremely expensive to tunnel...
 
Keebler Elf said:
I think you're wrong on both counts.

The province may very well love to give up the 401 and all its associated maintenance costs. They gave the Gardner to Toronto and it's been nothing but a headache.

How do you figure the bigger cost is the stations? It's extremely expensive to tunnel...

Cause I have a knowledge of construction and the construction of Sheppard that you do not. I am in fact, correct on both counts.

The cost of the Sheppard was just under a billion dollars for about 6 km of track.

The contract to tunnel bore was awarded to S. McNally of Hamilton Ontario for just under 100 million dollars.

http://www.mcnallycorp.com/project_profile.php?id=33&action=project_feature

The cost of the line is ALWAYS the stations mon ami. The Yonge Sheppard Station clocked in at 130 million buckeroos. Even the cheapest station on Sheppard - Bessarian was around 30 million bucks.

Stations, especially Yonge where the lines cross, is very complex, requiring virtual relocation of every utility under the intersection at huge costs.

The province will never give up the 401 corridor for an LRT. The Gardiner was a different story because basically it just is the Toronto end of the QEW. The 401 goes right through. Also, the province only gave, (or more accurately forced) the ownership of the portion of the QEW from 427 to the Humber which used to be QEW. The main portion of the Gardiner (from the Humber to the DVP) has always been the property of the City of Toronto.

A far far far better route for an LRT would be the CPR North Toronto Subdivision which runs east / west from Leaside Yard at Millwood to Toronto West Junction at Keele and Dundas. This line passes right through uptown(the old CPR Summerhill Station for example which is now the famous liquor Store.)

You could have commuter stations at Davenport, Spadina, Bathurst, Dufferin and Keele.

The existing track corridor is currently fitted for 5 tracks, with room for 6.

There are only 2 tracks currently being used, though there are also sidings starting at Davenport, running westwards to Shaw Street. Still there is more than ample room on the south side of the corridor where you could easily construct 2 commuter lines utilizing the former Ontario Quebec Railway's right of way (which CPR now owns).

East of Leaside, the CPR follows the Belleville Subdivision, which is ABANDONNED south of Leaside yard all the way down to UNION Station. That big monster of a bridge you see across the ramp from Danforth to the DVP hasn't been used in years.

You could easily and perfectly run LRT from Union Station north to the CPR's Leaside yard where you could then run east / west all the way to Keele and Dundas, where you could hook into the Galt Subdivision that runs to Georgetown. (GO Transit currently owns the Galt subdivision from Union Station running northwest to Toronto West Junction at Keele and Dundas.)

All you need to do is come up with a deal with CPR. :)
 
Questor said:
I am all for promoting rapid public transit in Toronto and other cities. However, this transit plan, it seems to me, is only promoting urban sprawl. Subways are great, but with limited public money to invest, Toronto is shifting to LRT. It is cheaper and has a shorter completion time.

I agree with someone that the priority for subway construction should be closer to the downtown core. King St. or Queen St. makes much more sense. Maybe even Eglinton Av. Its hard to say without knowing the ridership numbers. But I can't agree with extending the Sheppard subway. It is a bust as it is. Extending it with LRT is a good idea. The new line to York U should also be LRT. Subways should be used to build up density closer to downtown, not to extend the subway system to the outer borders of the city.

See, here's where you're missing, "the big picture"

The big picture is that it will be incredibly cheaper to extend the subway on Sheppard now as opposed to the future.

How do you ask?

Simple, Sheppard is on the radar for Densification, or Intensification. Basically, building Condos. Perfect I say because there's not a lot out there now anyway.

What you do is when a developer goes to build a condo say at the corner of Don Mills and Sheppard, you tell him, fine, but you need to encorporate a subway station into your basement.

The greedy developers will of course grumble, but they'll do it as long as a subway is in the offing because that will only increase the worth of their land.

Secondly, it will be cheaper to build a subway on Sheppard BEFORE it gets all built up and it's coming, you can see it now.

It's just a question of foresight.
 
Excellent post above about LRT James T. What you say makes much sense to me.
james t kirk said:
See, here's where you're missing, "the big picture"

The big picture is that it will be incredibly cheaper to extend the subway on Sheppard now as opposed to the future.

How do you ask?

Simple, Sheppard is on the radar for Densification, or Intensification. Basically, building Condos. Perfect I say because there's not a lot out there now anyway.

What you do is when a developer goes to build a condo say at the corner of Don Mills and Sheppard, you tell him, fine, but you need to encorporate a subway station into your basement.

The greedy developers will of course grumble, but they'll do it as long as a subway is in the offing because that will only increase the worth of their land.

Secondly, it will be cheaper to build a subway on Sheppard BEFORE it gets all built up and it's coming, you can see it now.

It's just a question of foresight.
In a perfect world, I would agree with you. But Toronto has long neglected its needs for rapid transit. There is a priority for building subways and LTR to meet today's needs, not the needs of 10 or 15 years from now. My comments about Sheppard LTR were taking today's reality into consideration. I don't believe we have the funds to build it, and I don't believe voters would accept the kind of tax increases that would be required to fund that kind of forward thinking. Toronto remains a city build for cars. Its unfortunate, but its true.
 
The main problem with the city who runs the TTC is that nothing they do makes sense.It is a politically driven system that is a huge cashcow.
 
good to go said:
The main problem with the city who runs the TTC is that nothing they do makes sense.It is a politically driven system that is a huge cashcow.

Absolutely.

The TTC is incredibly political. It's amazing how political actually.
 
The province would never allow the 401 to be cut down by a lane the political outcry would destroy what ever govt wanted to do it.

The city of toronto would not take the 401 on a bet because of the related costs for maintenance .
 
The real story behind closed doors is that the TTC kept trying to get the system in place to fail after the accident.They ran a train over the switch so many times that it overheated,something that could not actually happen as trains are spaced for safety.They blamed it on maintenance problems and the money was awarded to them for additional maintenance.They created a problem to get additional funding.If the truth be known.

The same thing happened this year with the train that derailed at Kennedy station.It was dragging a torque arm that is mounted to the motor frame of the train and they dragged it from Chester to Kennedy station.But upon running the train in reverse at Kennedy ,the torque arm jammed into the timbers holding the rail and the car lifted and derailed the car.

The problem with that fuck-up was that they were re-using the bolts that hold the torque arm up under the train on the mount.They were saving money on a bolt of all things,it failed and thank god no-body was hurt in the accident.