Stranded at sea for 5 months - complete incompetence?

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,862
5,520
113
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-41772323

Is it possible to have a functioning sailboat and not make any headway for 5 months? Also, why on EARTH would anyone embark on such a journey without emergency satellite distress communications. This stuff is not expensive at all. Seems very odd that they had a sailboat, sails and were not able to make any progress.
 
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-41772323

Is it possible to have a functioning sailboat and not make any headway for 5 months? Also, why on EARTH would anyone embark on such a journey without emergency satellite distress communications. This stuff is not expensive at all. Seems very odd that they had a sailboat, sails and were not able to make any progress.
o
I agree, Ive sailed in many places in the world and I cant see not having a satellite com or even a working VHF radio. However they did say the mast wasn't functional and the motor wasn't working seem odd to loose both. I think we'll hear more of this story.
 
The ladies and the dog(s) shown in the photo look healthy
emerging from 5 months drifting. They didn't seem to have
had to struggle to survive. The move based on their adventure
is going to be a boring one. The director can always throw in
some lesbian love scenes to spice things up though.
 
I’m calling bullshit on this. For all the reasons people have mentioned plus the only shark that grows to 30’ is a harmless whale shark.

I say they are bucking for a book deal, they don’t look that stressed or tired. No one goes 5 months stranded anywhere and comes out looking that healthy
 
The shark encounters definitely interest me. That would be weird for a whale or basking shark to do (slap tail on boat repeatedly) and pretty big for any aggressive shark (30ft) as far as I know.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doldrums. Maybe?

A real sailer might be able to shed more light on this, but I imagine it’s not the last of this we hear. Strange story as it’s written on BBC.
 
To describe this as peculiar is stretching the bounds of the language!

They were aboard a sailing vessel but they don't seem to have done much sailing, they say the engine failed but they should have been only minimally running the engine since without a great deal of extra fuel aboard there is no way that they could have powered from Hawaii to French Polynesia.

Perhaps they were totally dependent on GPS and had no power for the same after the engine failed, but prudent sailors going out of sight of land learn celestial navigation and in their case even a decent plastic sextant would have sufficed. Further even a course card (sail x days on a compass course of y, then change course to z for 3 days) should have gotten them to a position where if they had conserved the batteries on the GPS they would have been in good shape.

As to the Doldrums (ITCZ), Guam is 13 degrees north of the equator, Oahu 21 degrees north of the equator. Yes French Polynesia is about 17 degrees south of the equator but still there are often thunderstorms (which provide wind even if you have to taken in two or three reefs on your sails) in the ITCZ, and further this is the area they should have been saving their engine and fuel to get through.

Most peculiar of all is that they decided to cross the Pacific Ocean without an EPIRB, or indeed a SSB Marine Radio (VHF FM is useless when you are hundreds of miles from those you are attempting to contact).
 
To describe this as peculiar is stretching the bounds of the language!

They were aboard a sailing vessel but they don't seem to have done much sailing, they say the engine failed but they should have been only minimally running the engine since without a great deal of extra fuel aboard there is no way that they could have powered from Hawaii to French Polynesia.

Perhaps they were totally dependent on GPS and had no power for the same after the engine failed, but prudent sailors going out of sight of land learn celestial navigation and in their case even a decent plastic sextant would have sufficed. Further even a course card (sail x days on a compass course of y, then change course to z for 3 days) should have gotten them to a position where if they had conserved the batteries on the GPS they would have been in good shape.

As to the Doldrums (ITCZ), Guam is 13 degrees north of the equator, Oahu 21 degrees north of the equator. Yes French Polynesia is about 17 degrees south of the equator but still there are often thunderstorms (which provide wind even if you have to taken in two or three reefs on your sails) in the ITCZ, and further this is the area they should have been saving their engine and fuel to get through.

Most peculiar of all is that they decided to cross the Pacific Ocean without an EPIRB, or indeed a SSB Marine Radio (VHF FM is useless when you are hundreds of miles from those you are attempting to contact).

Better coverage here, I feel. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/oct/26/two-women-dogs-rescued-five-months-lost-at-sea

Sat phone went overboard on day 2. Mast broke after engine failed.

I was thinking the same thing about the SSB.

And yet they stored 100 days of food? Seems weird to be that overprepared, yet wreckless for not turning around when you lose the sat phone or the engine.
 
Damn women drivers. It's even worse when they use a boat.
 
Better coverage here, I feel. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/oct/26/two-women-dogs-rescued-five-months-lost-at-sea

Sat phone went overboard on day 2. Mast broke after engine failed.

I was thinking the same thing about the SSB.

And yet they stored 100 days of food? Seems weird to be that overprepared, yet wreckless for not turning around when you lose the sat phone or the engine.
Two days from Hawaii, they should have sailed back.

Sat phone should not have been on deck or should have been attached to the vessel via a lanyard of some type.

I'd be interested to learn in what way "the mast broke" it certainly doesn't look broken in any of the photographs, the rigging looks sound and in the video the mast certainly isn't banging back and forth as the boat rolls in the seas. If it was a turnbuckle on a stay a) irresponsible not to have spares on a long voyage like this b) the wind should have allowed some sailing on their "good tack".

If you are going to cross the Pacific you need to have both a SSB Marine Radio and an an EPIRB!
 
The ladies and the dog(s) shown in the photo look healthy
emerging from 5 months drifting. They didn't seem to have
had to struggle to survive. The move based on their adventure
is going to be a boring one. The director can always throw in
some lesbian love scenes to spice things up though.

They can always add in a violent and exciting shark pack attack and then a scene where they eat one of the dogs due to starvation.

But you had me hooked with the lesbian love scenes (as long as they are two hot babes).
 
Two days from Hawaii, they should have sailed back.

Sat phone should not have been on deck or should have been attached to the vessel via a lanyard of some type.

I'd be interested to learn in what way "the mast broke" it certainly doesn't look broken in any of the photographs, the rigging looks sound and in the video the mast certainly isn't banging back and forth as the boat rolls in the seas. If it was a turnbuckle on a stay a) irresponsible not to have spares on a long voyage like this b) the wind should have allowed some sailing on their "good tack".

If you are going to cross the Pacific you need to have both a SSB Marine Radio and an an EPIRB!

Totally. Ordinarily, I’m not a story behind the story kind of guy at first glance, but the peril seems almost intentional.

91ba90e7af44078477f59d1c77957430--funny-shit-funny-stuff.jpg
 
Two days from Hawaii, they should have sailed back.

Sat phone should not have been on deck or should have been attached to the vessel via a lanyard of some type.

I'd be interested to learn in what way "the mast broke" it certainly doesn't look broken in any of the photographs, the rigging looks sound and in the video the mast certainly isn't banging back and forth as the boat rolls in the seas. If it was a turnbuckle on a stay a) irresponsible not to have spares on a long voyage like this b) the wind should have allowed some sailing on their "good tack".

If you are going to cross the Pacific you need to have both a SSB Marine Radio and an an EPIRB!

This puzzles me too. The mast, rigging and sails look perfectly fine. They should have been able to make some headway even with a damaged mast, sail, etc. I've done a sailing trips around Lake Ontario and take extra flares, spare GPS, batteries, etc. Extra gear is not expensive and would have been helpful to these ladies.
 
This puzzles me too. The mast, rigging and sails look perfectly fine. They should have been able to make some headway even with a damaged mast, sail, etc. I've done a sailing trips around Lake Ontario and take extra flares, spare GPS, batteries, etc. Extra gear is not expensive and would have been helpful to these ladies.

Lake Ontario is just a bit different than one of the worlds largest oceans!
 
Lake Ontario is just a bit different than one of the worlds largest oceans!

Well no shit Sherlock!

My point is that you bring enough safety gear and backups regardless of where you are going. The ladies also likely did not file a sail plan with the coast guard. That is the most basic thing they should have done. When they were overdue the coast guard could have went out for them.
 
Well no shit Sherlock!

My point is that you bring enough safety gear and backups regardless of where you are going. The ladies also likely did not file a sail plan with the coast guard. That is the most basic thing they should have done. When they were overdue the coast guard could have went out for them.
Further not having an EPIRB, or even a PLB when attempting to cross the Pacific Ocean!!
 
The story today is that they were only trying to 'cross' to Tahiti, an eighteen day sail. Which just underscores the importance of remembering you can drown in a soup bowl, and being just as prepared and aware crossing the street as undertaking a trek across the desert.
 
Last edited:
Indeed the Newport - Bermuda race typically takes five to six days, that doesn't mean you can attempt it in a day sailer!

Take a look at the safety requirements pages on the website for this coming June's race.
 
Ive done some long distance sailing before and 18 days on the ocean is no picnic no matter how experienced you are. No one I know would attempt a trek like that with out the proper equipment. The other thing that bothers me is the boat is no more than 40 with an 11 to 12 foot beam which couldnt possibly hold enough food for two people and two dogs for 6 months, and unless they had a reverse osmosis on board which needs electricity to run what did they do for water.I think the truth is going to come out about this and it will have been all BS