Stereotypes

Adrenaline

Banned
Mar 26, 2009
381
0
0
What are your thoughts on racial/religious stereotypes? Are they fair, unfair, accurate, inaccurate?

I think they're unfair in the sense that it groups all people of one race and religion with the same behaviours and traits. For example, the stereotype that all Asians are bad drivers. Statisically they may be the worst drivers on average, and from personal experience you may see that they're the worst drivers, but there are over 2 billion Asians in the world, I'm sure at least a handful are excellent drivers, so the stereotype really isn't fair.

On the other hand, some stereotypes are accurate when you look at the racial or religious group as a whole. Not all Asians are bad drivers, so individually the stereotype is inaccurate, but as a whole they likely are the worst group. Not all Muslims are violent terrorists who abuse, rape, and torture women, but as a whole they're probably the most likely group to be terrorists. Not all blacks are criminals, murderers, and unintelligent, but statisically as a group they're more likely to be criminals and perform poorly in school and on IQ tests than the general population.

Some stereotypes are driven by statistics, so while they may be accurate in general, they're likely to be completely inaccurate when it comes to individuals.

What are your thoughts?
 
Stereotyping is fundamental to human intelligence, and in most cases, a perfectly normal and harmless behavior that helps us get through our day. Our brains are simply not powerful enough to fully evaluate the complexities of every situation and make rational/logical decisions about what to do--we would be overloaded.

By way of example of what I mean, you have a stereotype in your mind about what sort of behavior you expect from a waitress or a store clerk. You have in your mind a set of "All waitresses..." generalizations: You expect her to be polite. You expect her to wait on your order. You expect her to become impatient if you screw around. You expect her to be able to close transactions. This is essentially a stereotype, but since it is not based on race/religion/etc it is not controversial and in fact a useful tool that allows you to interact with strangers. It's a mental shortcut that allows you to get through your day without difficulty.

The problem is that this natural cognitive crutch gets applied to groups of people on controversial factors like religion or race. You see a few examples or hear of a few examples, maybe from biased and unreliable sources, maybe from racist sources. This gives you an impression of what "all Muslims" are like that is potentially not only wrong, but highly damaging. Moreover it adds up overall to a denial of the basic human rights of people in the stereotyped group when these general principles are encoded into systemic social and political bias.

Because of the way our minds evolved stereotyping is an inherent human behavior, but when it comes to race, religion, etc., it is one that we must fight against in order to treat everyone fairly.
 
Ug, word to the wise - if you're going to quote stats, at least make sure that they are actual...stats. Otherwise that just makes them something you're pulling out of your limited experience. Your experience has value, but NOT to the level you are trying to take it.

"Not all Muslims are violent terrorists who abuse, rape, and torture women, but as a whole they're probably the most likely group to be terrorists..."

Do you mean Muslims in America? In Khadar? In the world?
In the states, more terrorist acts have been commited by White men than anyone else. And it makes sense that in Pakistan for instance, more terrorist acts are committed by Pakistanis. In a Muslim country, more terrorist acts will be commited by Muslims than others. Do you get what I'm saying? Where in the world did you get your statement from?


"Not all blacks are criminals, murderers, and unintelligent, but statisically as a group they're more likely to be criminals and perform poorly in school and on IQ tests than the general population."

Blacks from Chicago? In all of Canada? In Zimbabawe? Total crimes commited by Blacks in Toronto? By people in general? Without stats, how is what you said anything other than a stereotype?

Maybe you should think a bit longer about what you're trying to say.


What are your thoughts on racial/religious stereotypes? Are they fair, unfair, accurate, inaccurate?

I think they're unfair in the sense that it groups all people of one race and religion with the same behaviours and traits. For example, the stereotype that all Asians are bad drivers. Statisically they may be the worst drivers on average, and from personal experience you may see that they're the worst drivers, but there are over 2 billion Asians in the world, I'm sure at least a handful are excellent drivers, so the stereotype really isn't fair.

On the other hand, some stereotypes are accurate when you look at the racial or religious group as a whole. Not all Asians are bad drivers, so individually the stereotype is inaccurate, but as a whole they likely are the worst group. Not all Muslims are violent terrorists who abuse, rape, and torture women, but as a whole they're probably the most likely group to be terrorists. Not all blacks are criminals, murderers, and unintelligent, but statisically as a group they're more likely to be criminals and perform poorly in school and on IQ tests than the general population.

Some stereotypes are driven by statistics, so while they may be accurate in general, they're likely to be completely inaccurate when it comes to individuals.

What are your thoughts?
 
Stereotypes are an exaggeration of some small truth. It is also a broad statistical average. Of course some stereotypes are more valid than others. Anyway to apply a stereotype to judge an individual is foolish. But it is often used to generalize when a generalization can be useful. For example, the Japanese have a stereotype that they are polite and respectful people. Are all Japanese people like this? NO. But on average they are (compared to other nationalities). So you can generalize and say that if you go to Japan, you will get good service, people will be polite and it is a very safe country.
 
Like my old roommate use to say: stereotypes are useful.
Are they 100% accurate? No. But like others have posted, they are on average correct.
 
A lot of politically correct answers so far. Stereotypes come from somewhere, some are statistically driven, others are exaggerations of truth, many do reflect the general overall behaviours and traits of the racial/religious being stereotyped, however, they don't reflect the behaviours and traits of every individual in the race/religion being stereotyped.

You can't just make up a stereotype, there has to be some grain of truth to it otherwise it's just laughable. Can I say that blacks are poor athletes? That would be a laughable stereotype to everyone, because stats, facts, and personal observation don't support that stereotype. Can I say that Asians are bad at math? Again that would be a laughable stereotype that would be dismissed by just about everyone. Can I say that Islam is a religion of peace? No, because again that would be laughable. Can I say that blacks perform the best in school and on IQ tests? Again I can't, because it's not based on stats, facts, or even personal observation.

To someone who is obsessed with being politically correct, a racial/religious stereotype cannot be true even if it's based on fact, but realistically, in the real world, not all people are alike, and not everyone behaves the same. Some stereotypes are true, not on an individual level, but to say that a certain race/religious group have traits and behaviours that are more common than the traits and behaviours of other races/religious group is not farfetched at all, it's actually based on fact.
 
You can't just make up a stereotype, there has to be some grain of truth to it otherwise it's just laughable.

There are a few problems even when you have a stereotype for which there is SOME evidence.

First, it's not going to fit every individual in the class that you are stereotyping, even if it fits others. If you walk around with the notion that blacks are bad at math, what does that do to the few who are excellent at it? Do they miss out on opportunities they should have had because someone discriminates against them on the basis of their race?

Second, the underlying trends change, and can change quickly. The stereotype is likely to persist long after the underlying grain of truth is no longer true. For example, twenty years ago you likely could have got away with "boys are better students", but no longer--now girls are.

Third, stereotypes are self-perpetuating. Why are blacks better at sports and worse in school? Is that because the stereotype is internalized by blacks, so that they think they should spend more time on sports, and skip math class? A black who had never heard of the stereotype might turn out quite differently!

For all these reasons we need to fight against stereotypes. They do not in reality help us improve our lot when they are applied to race or religion.
 
You can't just make up a stereotype, there has to be some grain of truth to it otherwise it's just laughable. Can I say that blacks are poor athletes? That would be a laughable stereotype to everyone, because stats, facts, and personal observation don't support that stereotype. Can I say that Asians are bad at math? Again that would be a laughable stereotype that would be dismissed by just about everyone. Can I say that Islam is a religion of peace? No, because again that would be laughable. Can I say that blacks perform the best in school and on IQ tests? Again I can't, because it's not based on stats, facts, or even personal observation.

What makes statements like these racist is the underlying assumptions. If your assumption is that asians are smart and black's aren't genetically, then that's racist and impossible to prove. If your assumption is that the cultural stresses on mathematics help asians do better on tests and the lack of cultural resources afforded blacks in north america make them do worse on their tests then that would not be a racist statement. Without that framing, your statements sound racist to me.

Even the comment about Islam and peace can be inferred as racist, without the framing of saying that fundalementalist christians are also sometimes violent and that the only truly pacifist religion might be buddhism.
 
again, mom was right

treat others as you would like to be treated

if you can't treat others as individuals, and insist on grouping them, well, perhaps you are the one with the problems
 
Is there a stereotype for shemales?

All I know is that after watching this video, I'd love to fuck Kimber James in the ass. I don't care that "she" is a shemale. She's hot.

 
Is there a stereotype for shemales?

All I know is that after watching this video, I'd love to fuck Kimber James in the ass. I don't care that "she" is a shemale. She's hot.

OMG...please tell us that was a joke.
 
Last edited:
Why? These things wouldn't become stereotypes without there being a few cases where they are true. It takes someone to observe a person of an identifiable group doing something, and then that observer tells others that all [insert race] people are like that one person.

I didn't say it was right or proper. Just that sometimes stereotypes are true.

I keep reading this and I keep shaking my head.
 
hollywood makes movies filled with racist stereotypes
 
hollywood makes movies filled with racist stereotypes

Have to agree with this one. In media there are all types of stereotypes thrown out based on skin colour or religion. Many people have not even been exposed to someone of a different race or religion yet have a stereotype of them soley based on what they have seen through media. Creates a rather ignorant society judging people based on what media shows.