http://www.europac.net/commentaries/stalemate_toronto
John Browne
July 2, 2010
Last week, global attention was focused on Toronto as the G-20 gathered to
confront the growing financial and economic worries darkening the global
economic horizon. In an irony worthy of Orwell, the representatives of
the world's top 20 economies (19 countries plus the European Union)
managed to ignore the out-of-control spending contained in Western
governments' budgets and instead unite behind a banner that they called
"financial responsibility." This is akin to a group of Mafiosi holding
a summit on business ethics.
For the sake of indulgence, let us grant that "responsibility" is
a relative term. And although the leaders of the EU have committed
themselves to massive bailouts of their more profligate members, they
are at least showing some remorse after the fact. This stands in sharp
contrast to President Obama, who shows no such regret. While the Europeans
tried to stick closely to their declared aim of "responsibility," it was
clear that the American delegation was working a somewhat different angle.
From my perspective, President Obama and his team had three main goals:
First, the US Administration sought to win wide support for Fed Chairman
Ben Bernanke's spend, spend, spend policy. On this front, there appears
to be not the slightest daylight between the programs recommended by
the Fed and the Treasury. This degree of concord runs contrary to the
Fed's supposed independence.
Based on recent statements made by Chairman Bernanke and other influential
economists to whom Obama has shown fealty, the United States now seems
poised to embark on a second round of stimulus. The latest salvo of
weak economic data (unemployment, manufacturing, home sales) greatly
increased the likelihood of such an outcome. The American position
roughly boils down to: prop up the economy endlessly with boatloads of
taxpayer dollars, then worry about debt after the economy can stand on
its own. This hypothesis posits that the spending itself will heal the
economy and that the politicians will remember their pledge to tackle
the debt if it does.
But in matters of financial history the Europeans seem to have clearer
memories and fewer illusions.
Led by the Germans, who well recall the infamous Weimar inflation in
the 1920's (which brought the Deutsche Mark from 12 to the dollar in
1919 to 4.2 trillion to the dollar by 1923), the Europeans are at least
talking about ways to stop the spending before it's too late. The German
position has been buttressed by the new Liberal-Conservative Coalition
government in the UK. It has long been noted that the UK faces some of the
most daunting debt challenges in Europe. With the recent drama in Greece
providing a clear cautionary tale, Prime Minister David Cameron has voiced
his determination to face the music and make hard cuts. There is early
indication that these words will result in an actual austerity budget.
Confronted with this block of resistance, it appears that Obama backed
down. The subject was side-stepped. The final agreed communiqué provided
only that the G-20 nations have agreed to cut their deficits in half by
2013. It's a weak promise, with a vague timeline; but its intent flies
in the face of what the Americans wanted.
Second, Obama was determined to head-off any further calls by the likes
of China and Russia for the US dollar to be supplanted as the world's
international reserve currency.
The G-20 meetings are conducted in the strictest privacy. This is
particularly true of the bilateral meetings between particular members,
the most important of which were probably those of China and the United
States (the G-2). In these meetings, starting possibly even before the
actual G-20 meetings, America achieved two considerable points: China said
it would allow the Yuan to float more freely at an unspecified future
date, and they agreed not to push publicly again for the US dollar to
be removed from its uniquely privileged position as the international
reserve currency. How this coup was accomplished is a matter for future
historians to uncover, but China's growing internal labor protests may
have played a role.
Meanwhile, Russia has been making bolder statements against dollar
hegemony. Russian President Dmitry Medvedev has called on central banks
to reduce their dollar holdings and for the IMF to create a supranational
reserve currency based on a basket of national currencies. Despite China's
silence on the issue, central banks appear to be taking Medvedev's cue.
Third, under the guise of climate change spending, the President
most probably hoped to push for greater wealth redistribution from the
developed to the emerging world. The German government is facing a vote of
no-confidence for sending aid to Greece, so it almost goes without saying
that discussion of increasing aid outside of the eurozone was met with
bewilderment. It appears that for the sake of unity, this plan was also
dropped. With the global recession intensifying, dissent in the top ranks
of political leadership is rightly to be feared. In the end, a compromise
was reached which amounted to little more than an agreement to disagree.
So, it appears Obama was 0 for 3. Despite some progress in Sino-American
relations, he did not successfully achieve any of his policy goals at
the summit. If anything, the weakness of the final communiqué convinced
me that our helmsman hasn't the vaguest clue how to steer the ship.
John Browne
July 2, 2010
Last week, global attention was focused on Toronto as the G-20 gathered to
confront the growing financial and economic worries darkening the global
economic horizon. In an irony worthy of Orwell, the representatives of
the world's top 20 economies (19 countries plus the European Union)
managed to ignore the out-of-control spending contained in Western
governments' budgets and instead unite behind a banner that they called
"financial responsibility." This is akin to a group of Mafiosi holding
a summit on business ethics.
For the sake of indulgence, let us grant that "responsibility" is
a relative term. And although the leaders of the EU have committed
themselves to massive bailouts of their more profligate members, they
are at least showing some remorse after the fact. This stands in sharp
contrast to President Obama, who shows no such regret. While the Europeans
tried to stick closely to their declared aim of "responsibility," it was
clear that the American delegation was working a somewhat different angle.
From my perspective, President Obama and his team had three main goals:
First, the US Administration sought to win wide support for Fed Chairman
Ben Bernanke's spend, spend, spend policy. On this front, there appears
to be not the slightest daylight between the programs recommended by
the Fed and the Treasury. This degree of concord runs contrary to the
Fed's supposed independence.
Based on recent statements made by Chairman Bernanke and other influential
economists to whom Obama has shown fealty, the United States now seems
poised to embark on a second round of stimulus. The latest salvo of
weak economic data (unemployment, manufacturing, home sales) greatly
increased the likelihood of such an outcome. The American position
roughly boils down to: prop up the economy endlessly with boatloads of
taxpayer dollars, then worry about debt after the economy can stand on
its own. This hypothesis posits that the spending itself will heal the
economy and that the politicians will remember their pledge to tackle
the debt if it does.
But in matters of financial history the Europeans seem to have clearer
memories and fewer illusions.
Led by the Germans, who well recall the infamous Weimar inflation in
the 1920's (which brought the Deutsche Mark from 12 to the dollar in
1919 to 4.2 trillion to the dollar by 1923), the Europeans are at least
talking about ways to stop the spending before it's too late. The German
position has been buttressed by the new Liberal-Conservative Coalition
government in the UK. It has long been noted that the UK faces some of the
most daunting debt challenges in Europe. With the recent drama in Greece
providing a clear cautionary tale, Prime Minister David Cameron has voiced
his determination to face the music and make hard cuts. There is early
indication that these words will result in an actual austerity budget.
Confronted with this block of resistance, it appears that Obama backed
down. The subject was side-stepped. The final agreed communiqué provided
only that the G-20 nations have agreed to cut their deficits in half by
2013. It's a weak promise, with a vague timeline; but its intent flies
in the face of what the Americans wanted.
Second, Obama was determined to head-off any further calls by the likes
of China and Russia for the US dollar to be supplanted as the world's
international reserve currency.
The G-20 meetings are conducted in the strictest privacy. This is
particularly true of the bilateral meetings between particular members,
the most important of which were probably those of China and the United
States (the G-2). In these meetings, starting possibly even before the
actual G-20 meetings, America achieved two considerable points: China said
it would allow the Yuan to float more freely at an unspecified future
date, and they agreed not to push publicly again for the US dollar to
be removed from its uniquely privileged position as the international
reserve currency. How this coup was accomplished is a matter for future
historians to uncover, but China's growing internal labor protests may
have played a role.
Meanwhile, Russia has been making bolder statements against dollar
hegemony. Russian President Dmitry Medvedev has called on central banks
to reduce their dollar holdings and for the IMF to create a supranational
reserve currency based on a basket of national currencies. Despite China's
silence on the issue, central banks appear to be taking Medvedev's cue.
Third, under the guise of climate change spending, the President
most probably hoped to push for greater wealth redistribution from the
developed to the emerging world. The German government is facing a vote of
no-confidence for sending aid to Greece, so it almost goes without saying
that discussion of increasing aid outside of the eurozone was met with
bewilderment. It appears that for the sake of unity, this plan was also
dropped. With the global recession intensifying, dissent in the top ranks
of political leadership is rightly to be feared. In the end, a compromise
was reached which amounted to little more than an agreement to disagree.
So, it appears Obama was 0 for 3. Despite some progress in Sino-American
relations, he did not successfully achieve any of his policy goals at
the summit. If anything, the weakness of the final communiqué convinced
me that our helmsman hasn't the vaguest clue how to steer the ship.

