St. Barts?

If you're looking for "high class" you might want to consider the Cayman Islands. Most offshore operations in the financial industry are based in the Cayman Islands and that's where all the wealthy hedge fund managers stop off between their flights.
 
FWW It is a French collectivité d'outre-mer (just like Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon), although interestingly it was Swedish for about a century from the late 18th to the late 19th centuries.
 
Have been a couple of times. It is very expensive for what you get, the currency is Euros, and I thought the beaches were okay. Lots of good food available.

Not my first choice of islands to go to.
 
It's not far from St. Martin, but I didn't go. Just heard some other lady's account with my GF at the time while lounging in the pool. It's sparsely populated from what I understand, not over-commercialized, with celebrities owning villas there on that island paradise.