South Korean hostage 'beheaded'

Poor guy though, he's just there trying to earn a living and he gets caught up in this nonesense.

Regardless, these people do pervert the teachings of Islam in a despicable and disgusting way.

You have to feel for that poor guy.
 
red said:
yes. The S. Koreans want the US troops to remain- but do they really need to be there? If the North invaded, hopefully the US and the UN would once again send troops to sort it out.

Yeah, let the UN launch a landing on an occupied Koreas that should only take 5 years to organize. How many tanks would Canada send and how would you get them there.

Idiots.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I think you missed one, it keep the hords North of the 38th but then as a Liberal you'd see evil in everything the US does.

OTB

Oops, OTB, you are neglecting your small-liberal values.

Arn't people supposed to do things for themselves? If you read my post you'll note that I suggest the South Koreans have in fact been put into a Welfare-type situation. By relying on the US they have never been encouraged to develop their own military - unlike North Korea, which has been cut off from China for some time. BTW, North Korea has half the population of South Korea. If SK really wanted to they certainly build an army large enough to pummel any invasion on their own. The real threat is nukes, and ground troops are no help there.

Or is it that conservatives like Welfare as long as the military is involved?
 
Goober Mcfly said:
Shot in the dark here, but perhaps because they want the rest of the world's help when Kim Jong Il snaps and launches a full scale attack to "reunite the Koreas"?

Kim Jong Il and the North Koreans do exactly the same way to South Koreans if they tried to cross 38th parallel and overran South Korea. The North Koreans are no better than the Islamists, except they are official "atheists".

That scenarios are not going to happen anytime soon. The only reason why North Korea is still exist because of China blocking the way.

I don't think the South Koreans are stupid enough to unite the Koreas cause the gaps between North and South is as wide as Grand Canyon.

Plus, the South Koreans nowadays aren't exactly as wealthy as the west Germans back in late 80s. The West Germans are still paying a steep price on unification and the former east Germans aren't exactly on equal terms with the west.
 
Drunken Master said:
Oops, OTB, you are neglecting your small-liberal values.

Arn't people supposed to do things for themselves? If you read my post you'll note that I suggest the South Koreans have in fact been put into a Welfare-type situation. By relying on the US they have never been encouraged to develop their own military - unlike North Korea, which has been cut off from China for some time. BTW, North Korea has half the population of South Korea. If SK really wanted to they certainly build an army large enough to pummel any invasion on their own. The real threat is nukes, and ground troops are no help there.

Or is it that conservatives like Welfare as long as the military is involved?

They have 650,000 troops, doesn't sound like they've been put into a welfare role to me.

And you'll note that I started the thread about brining US troops home, I do think the rest of the world should start looking after security issues instead of being lazy and letting the US do it, in fact our neighbor to the North would be a perfect example.

OTB
 
sweet guy said:
Kim Jong Il and the North Koreans do exactly the same way to South Koreans if they tried to cross 38th parallel and overran South Korea. The North Koreans are no better than the Islamists, except they are official "atheists".

That scenarios are not going to happen anytime soon. The only reason why North Korea is still exist because of China blocking the way.

China blocking the way of what? China is subsidizing them, but I don't know what way they are blocking.

sweet guy said:

I don't think the South Koreans are stupid enough to unite the Koreas cause the gaps between North and South is as wide as Grand Canyon.

Plus, the South Koreans nowadays aren't exactly as wealthy as the west Germans back in late 80s. The West Germans are still paying a steep price on unification and the former east Germans aren't exactly on equal terms with the west.

I think the German reunification is the perfect metaphor for what will (and probably should) happen.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Yeah, let the UN launch a landing on an occupied Koreas that should only take 5 years to organize. How many tanks would Canada send and how would you get them there.

Idiots.

OTB

Mind your manners.
 
onthebottom said:
China blocking the way of what? China is subsidizing them, but I don't know what way they are blocking. OTB

China will use whatever it takes to block the "unification" between the Koreas not because North Koreans are Chinese friends. Far from it, the North Koreans are bunches of ingrates in the eyes of the Chinese.

China keeps North Korea around for selfish reason, that is to prevent the Americans and South Korean forces at the doorstep at Yalu River.

Do you have any idea how volatile the situation will be?

BTW, I don't think any sane mainland Chinese will shed any tears to Kim Jong Il. How worse will that be when you are the master who feed your own dog and the dog in return bite its feeder? That's exactly what's going on between China and North Korea.
 
sweet guy said:
China will use whatever it takes to block the "unification" between the Koreas not because North Koreans are Chinese friends. Far from it, the North Koreans are bunches of ingrates in the eyes of the Chinese.

The really reason is to prevent the Americans and South Korean forces at the doorstep at Yalu River.

Do you have any idea how volatile the situation will be?

Would it be worse than having a mad man with nukes, a million troops and a starving population at your border? Even the status quo seems tense. Best we just come home and let the Kim's figure it out.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Would it be worse than having a mad man with nukes, a million troops and a starving population at your border? Even the status quo seems tense. Best we just come home and let the Kim's figure it out.

OTB

Kim Jong Il is trying to extort his way to feed his crumbling country and the Americans, Japanese, Russians and hell even the Chinese are getting sicked and tired of his tricks.

He may be brutal but he is definitely not crazy. By comparison OBL is not as rational compared to Kim. Kim knows too well his quest for half a dozen of atomic (not nuclear) weapons is like a high risk wire act.

He is successful in antagonizing both China and the United States. He may take the bet that as long as he has WMD, the Americans will have second thought to wreck havoc to North Korea.

This is kind of stupid as you feel you are "safe" from the biggest "bully" in town when you have a hand size steak knife and taunt that bully, where in reality your biggest "bully" possesses an axe razor sharp enough to behead you with ease!
 
its too bad they couldn't save that guy but he was dead the second he was captured anyway. Good to see south korea not submitting
 
sweet guy said:
Kim Jong Il is trying to extort his way to feed his crumbling country and the Americans, Japanese, Russians and hell even the Chinese are getting sicked and tired of his tricks.

He may be brutal but he is definitely not crazy. By comparison OBL is not as rational compared to Kim. Kim knows too well his quest for half a dozen of atomic (not nuclear) weapons is like a high risk wire act.

He is successful in antagonizing both China and the United States. He may take the bet that as long as he has WMD, the Americans will have second thought to wreck havoc to North Korea.

This is kind of stupid as you feel you are "safe" from the biggest "bully" in town when you have a hand size steak knife and taunt that bully, where in reality your biggest "bully" possesses an axe razor sharp enough to behead you with ease!

The answer is going to have to be the threat of UNSC sanctions on North Korea. If the US and China could agree then North Korea would buckle under, imagine what would happen if the country was blockaded from the sea and China cut the power.

There is always a chance that Kim will see the light before then but I'm not optimistic.

OTB
 
Drunken Master said:
Why not just do it with massive military support from the South Koreans themselves?

We're skirting the issue here; the US miltiary presence in South Korea is a Cold War anachronism. The US presence in SK has only accomplished two things: 1) It has kept the S. Koreans from militarising themselves, and 2) It has given the Americans sufficient "facts on the ground" to allow them significant influence in SK's government and, more importantly, their economy.

So we're agreed; Koreans out of Iraq, Americans out of Southern Asia. That God we cleared that up.

The fact is that South Korean leadership really WANT the US troops there. And they rather send their troops abroad and have US troops in S.Korea than vice versa. They know that 37K US troops will not stop a N.Korea invasion. But they do know that N.Korea will have to go through them and if N.Korea does, it wil automatically, with no delay, bring the US into the war because N.Korea just smacked around 37K American troops.

The US troops are a tripwire and S.Korean leadership fully understands this, even if the civilian population doesn't fully understand the ramifications. The current S.Korean president was actually elected because of his stance against US Troops in Korea! Liberals and university students voted in mass for him. But once he got in office and began his efforts to get them out, the US pondered pulling out and then President Roh really understood what that meant and started to backtrack heavily to the point where he was embarassed to the point of begging the Americans to leave some troops in South Korea.

An automatic confrontation w/the US is the #1 thing that is preventing N.Korea from invasion.
 
Drunken Master said:
BTW, North Korea has half the population of South Korea. If SK really wanted to they certainly build an army large enough to pummel any invasion on their own. The real threat is nukes, and ground troops are no help there.

The dream of all Koreans, North and South is one unified Korea. The South wants to achieve this through diplomacy while the North tries achieving this by force (Korean War). Even crazy Kim Il Jong dreams of uniting all Koreans together. In no way does N.Korea want to nuke S.Korea. Japan and the US, sure. But South Korea.. nope. When N.Korea had mid-range missile capability in 1998, they didn't fly it over South Korea but instead they flew it over Japan to make a point. Thus N.Korea has always looked at a ground invasion as the way to take South Korea. Which is why the US troops by the DMZ are so crucial.
 
Don said:
The dream of all Koreans, North and South is one unified Korea. The South wants to achieve this through diplomacy while the North tries achieving this by force (Korean War). Even crazy Kim Il Jong dreams of uniting all Koreans together. In no way does N.Korea want to nuke S.Korea. Japan and the US, sure. But South Korea.. nope. When N.Korea had mid-range missile capability in 1998, they didn't fly it over South Korea but instead they flew it over Japan to make a point. Thus N.Korea has always looked at a ground invasion as the way to take South Korea. Which is why the US troops by the DMZ are so crucial.

And now the US troops are being redeployed farther from the DMZ and being reduced. The redeployment makes sense, a more flexible response to a land invasion, and the reduction also makes sense - it's just too expensive for the US to protect this country forever.

OTB
 
Don said:
The fact is that South Korean leadership really WANT the US troops there. And they rather send their troops abroad and have US troops in S.Korea than vice versa. They know that 37K US troops will not stop a N.Korea invasion. But they do know that N.Korea will have to go through them and if N.Korea does, it wil automatically, with no delay, bring the US into the war because N.Korea just smacked around 37K American troops.

The US troops are a tripwire and S.Korean leadership fully understands this, even if the civilian population doesn't fully understand the ramifications. The current S.Korean president was actually elected because of his stance against US Troops in Korea! Liberals and university students voted in mass for him. But once he got in office and began his efforts to get them out, the US pondered pulling out and then President Roh really understood what that meant and started to backtrack heavily to the point where he was embarassed to the point of begging the Americans to leave some troops in South Korea.

An automatic confrontation w/the US is the #1 thing that is preventing N.Korea from invasion.

Nowadays the new generations of South Koreans have absolutely NO IDEA what the Americans helped to protect South Korea so that for better or for worst, South Korea came out from the third world to one of the most prosperous countries in Asia.

Without the American protection, South Korea would cease to exist. Korea would then be united and many of those "South Koreans" would be starved and brutually oppressed by Kim Jong Il. Who would really know anything on Hyundai, Samsung, LG or hell Tae Kwon Do?

Sure America has its own "fault" like doing nothing and standing by when the ROK army masscred students in Kwon Joo 1982 with American issued weapons but seriously America didn't want to have anything with "Korean internal affairs".

What an irony for China and the United States share similar problem on the Koreas. The Chinese do not get any appreciation from the North Koreans.

The flesh and blood the Chinese voluteers sacrifaced to save North Koreans ass during the 50s only get constant accusation and diatribe for "revisionism" from the North Koreans after China opened up to the world and got wealthier, while at the same time the North Koreans keep on begging and asking for more.

For the Americans, no pun intended the South Koreans are like the battered, abandoned orphan escaped from the abusive family, get good care, nourishment and nuture from the step-parent (the Americans). When the orphan becomes a teenager, and get almost anything he can ever imagine, he wants to be different, independent and stand on his own feet by rebelling to the step-parent.

Problem is without the help of your step-parent, you don't even have the chip to bargain with.

President Roh learns it the hard way. Sure the Koreans are tough and very hard working but without American money, market and quite generous support, Korea goes nowhere.

Imagine when the IMF was not that "generous" to bail out Korea in 97 Asian crisis without the invisible help from the Americans at IMF.
 
onthebottom said:
And now the US troops are being redeployed farther from the DMZ and being reduced. The redeployment makes sense, a more flexible response to a land invasion, and the reduction also makes sense - it's just too expensive for the US to protect this country forever.

OTB

Now that the ROK armed force on every field from manpower, training, to military weapons. It's about time to walk the walk and talk the talk.

If the South Koreans can really stand their own feet by defending themselves from North Korea, they should not bitching the Americans to leave, while a few months later begging and pleading the Americans to stay when the Americans are serious to leave.