SOS or HELP

xmontrealer

(he/him/it)
May 23, 2005
12,355
10,391
113
If you're using Morse Code SOS is much simpler.

SOS: dot dot dot, dash dash dash, dot dot dot

vs.

help: dot dot dot dot, dot, dot dash dot dot, dot dash dash dot
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar

Ponderling

Lotsa things to think about
Jul 19, 2021
2,046
1,784
113
Mississauga
If you are on the radio in a plane you say 'pan pan' and everyone else shuts up and recognizes you are communicating an emergency situation.

Mayday also gets a lot more interest than just saying help.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roadhog

NotADcotor

His most imperial galactic atheistic majesty.
Mar 8, 2017
7,200
4,861
113
They say it is better to yell Fire! than Rape!
That is all I know about that.
I'd assume Fire works better than Help at least if you are speaking. Yelling S O S seems awkward and Yelling Sos would just leave people confused.

Or maybe, dial 911.
 

escortsxxx

Well-known member
Jul 15, 2004
3,574
979
113
Tdot
I have a feeling that SOS - other than Morse code, is no longer known by most. If you Know Morse you will know SOS of course but Morse is no longer standard in most areas it used to be (military, airplanes etc) even Amateur radio people don't have to learn Morse at all to get there license..

 
Actually, PAN PAN PAN is not an emergency but requires serious attention but it is a level lower.

SOS of course is only using cw but requires far less power to be heard vs say SSB (voice). Been a ham for 57 years WØJKT and ships in International waters often want licensed hams and HF gear since we can bounce signals off the ionosphere thousands of miles vs the short mostly line-of-sight frequencies the Coast Guard uses or on the "guard" emergency channel of ships and aircraft. There are hams and equipment on the International Space Station which we can talk with but it's also the last resort for emergency communications if their telemetry and normal coms go down which are basically line of site on VHF/UHF.

In the US "mayday., mayday, mayday" is no longer the accepted plain language terminology now required for airplanes, although it still is in Europe and for amateur radio. The proper airline declaration in the US is "I declare an emergency". All sorts of things happen with ATC, the radar screen shows EM, controllers will clear all traffic around you to get out of the way. The controller will ask the nature of the emergency, fuel, and souls on board.

Depending on fuel and nature of the emergency if not immediate may need to dump fuel first to get to a safe landing weight- especially if just took off. A fire in an engine is usually not a direct immediate return since most fires can be extinguished with the usual one of the 3 bottles that can be fired. Planes can fly on one engine - it will still be an emergency but if over landing weight will usually dump fuel. Likewise, if landing gear won't go down etc.

I listen to many of the ATC emergencies recorded. They happen more often than you would like to think but most end safely.

One of my favorites was the young girl on her first solo flight who was informed she lost a wheel on takeoff (small plane). The controller (woman) now knowing how young and inexperienced she was said the usual, "state intentions" She replied in a weak scary voice "can I return to the airport?" She had plenty of fuel and ATC was able to contact her instructor who calmly assured her all was well and another chase plane went up to try and guide her in. It is very difficult to land when one of your side wheels is gone- especially to keep on runway as land. She crashed off the runway but was unhurt.

And of course, there was the SW airline where the female pilot declared an emergency mentioning "we have lost a passenger out the window." The controller said. "What??...never mind" and just went into emergency proceedings.

There was another incident where a bird smashed the window and the pilot was sucked out but was able to hang on as the pilot dove down so he would have enough oxygen. Amazingly he survived.

I recall hearing a few incidents at the Toronto airport including the big crash a few years ago spilling onto the highway.

BTW I enjoyed being in a 737 cockpit (actual out-of-service 737) doing a flight simulation at the Flight place on the Northside of Toronto Airport. It was so real after we landed somewhere in NY I actually thought for a moment we still have to fly back to Toronto...ah... no just open the door.
 
Last edited:
.. even Amateur radio people don't have to learn Morse at all to get there license..
You (Canadians) have a weird regulation that you can still qualify for a license without passing the usual test if you take the morse code test:" 3) For the purposes of this Part, an Amateur Radio Operator Certificate with a Morse Code (12 w.p.m.) Qualification is equivalent to an Amateur Radio Operator Certificate with a Basic Qualification with Honours..

I have run into this too if I operate under the 1952 US/Canada treaty in Canada, I have certain classification rights if I had to take a code test to get my license. Which I did in 1964 when it was required in the US (13 wpm) even though its no longer required by International Agreements. I had to learn it but have never used it.

I have been operating US remotes from my hotel room in Canada but doing it under my US license since I am operating just US stations (from Toronto hotel). However, from the US I can not operate Canadian-based remotes. unless I get also licensed in Canada. Gets confusing and I have a big note on my ham page (QRZ) don't point beams toward my Pheonix address, I am not operating from there - I have 3 big mountains and big hill around me that limits my having an effective big beam and tower at my own home.
 
  • Like
Reactions: escortsxxx
Toronto Escorts