Sometimes it works

Do you think we see similar results in Canada?

Yes, I think we do. Doesn't mean we can't strive for improvement. But I wonder where Fuji's friend would have ended up without that extra help. Some people would rather see her on the street selling her body for her next hit of crack, and eventually in jail. What does that cost the taxpayer? And what is the cost to society if she has a baby along the way? How much money is saved in that case. And economics aside, is that the kind of society we want to strive for?
 
Just to add a completely unhelpful and uselessly idiotic comment, I suspect that we would all be better off if much like all criminal, all welfare recipients got a bullet in the back of their heads.

That's it for my snide, stupid, extreme right wing idiocy this morning.

Now back to your regularly scheduled programming.

Cheers! :)
 
Good to hear about a positive welfare story...she also became self-motivated (once given an opportunity) so she would have made it eventually - good to know she is going to make it quicker than most!
 
Just to add a completely unhelpful and uselessly idiotic comment, I suspect that we would all be better off if much like all criminal, all welfare recipients got a bullet in the back of their heads.

That's it for my snide, stupid, extreme right wing idiocy this morning.

Now back to your regularly scheduled programming.

Cheers! :)

..... and the purpose for this post was? Thanks for coming out, now back in your box.
 
Fuji...I'm happy for your friend. It just too bad that her story tends to be the exception more than the rule. In the states we have so many people that seem happy to take advantage of the system. I don't care for government imposed charity. I would probably be willing to do more for people in tough times if I didn't know that the government was forcefully taking money out of my hard earned paycheck and wasting part of it on people who are scamming them. Do any of you think that if we got rid of welfare, donations to efficient organizations that help people when they need it would rise and the purely lazy scammers would be on their own?
 
Do any of you think that if we got rid of welfare, donations to efficient organizations that help people when they need it would rise and the purely lazy scammers would be on their own?

Rises in donations might recover 5% or 10% of what would be lost.

I also think it can be pretty hard to tell those who would benefit from those who are cheating the system. When my friend was on welfare she sometimes lied about paying rent with her welfare money, she would fake that, and then stay with a friend. That was so she could have some extra cash to fund activities you probably wouldn't approve of. I can assure you she did not live an upright Christian moral life while she was on welfare, she partied hard, she got drunk, no doubt experimented with drugs a bit. She did, however, get herself through highschool during that time, despite all that, and in the end she jumped on the opportunity for a real job when it came her way.

So, if you had detected at the time that she had misled a little about where "rent money" is going, would you have kicked her out of your charitable program and assumed she was just a lazy bum exploiting the system?
 
Fuji...I'm happy for your friend. It just too bad that her story tends to be the exception more than the rule. In the states we have so many people that seem happy to take advantage of the system. I don't care for government imposed charity. I would probably be willing to do more for people in tough times if I didn't know that the government was forcefully taking money out of my hard earned paycheck and wasting part of it on people who are scamming them. Do any of you think that if we got rid of welfare, donations to efficient organizations that help people when they need it would rise and the purely lazy scammers would be on their own?

So because of this person you heard about who was a leech, who might be entirely fictional, or this person you saw at a bus stop who you could just tell was lazy, you know that people taking advantage of the system are the rule? Certainly you couldn't have gotten this conclusion from the data, which makes it overwhelmingly clear that people who take advantage of the system for the long run are a miniscule minority.
 
So because of this person you heard about who was a leech, who might be entirely fictional, or this person you saw at a bus stop who you could just tell was lazy, you know that people taking advantage of the system are the rule? Certainly you couldn't have gotten this conclusion from the data, which makes it overwhelmingly clear that people who take advantage of the system for the long run are a miniscule minority.
Yes, sadly there is a minority who scam the system. Fuji's example shows that when given an OPPORTUNITY, people on welfare will help themselves and get off of welfare. It is the lack of opportunity which discourages people and they end out on welfare for extended periods of time.