I think so! This is ridiculous legal shenanigans...and costly to tax payers. Not to mention hard on the victims family!
CBC News:
The B.C. Court of Appeal has overturned Kelly Ellard's second-degree murder conviction and ordered a fourth trial for her in the death of teenager Reena Virk, who was found beaten and drowned in a Victoria waterway in 1997.
Ellard was found guilty in April 2005 on a third trial after a jury deliberated for five days following five weeks of testimony. She was sentenced to life in prison and was to serve seven years before seeking parole.
Virk was 14 when she was swarmed and beaten under a bridge in Saanich on Vancouver Island on Nov. 14, 1997, by a group of teenagers who were mainly girls, police said.
Battered and bloodied, Virk managed to get up and stagger across the bridge toward a bus stop to make her way home. But two of the original attackers dragged her back, hit her again and left her in a waterway.
Reena Virk's body was found eight days after she was swarmed and beaten under a bridge in Saanich on Vancouver Island on Nov. 14, 1997. (CBC)
The Appeal Court decision Friday means Ellard, now 25, has the right to a new trial.
She had faced two previous trials. In the first trial in March 2000, she was found guilty of second-degree murder but the verdict was overturned on appeal. The second trial, which was granted on grounds that the Crown didn't give her a fair trial, ended in a hung jury in July 2004.
CBC News:
The B.C. Court of Appeal has overturned Kelly Ellard's second-degree murder conviction and ordered a fourth trial for her in the death of teenager Reena Virk, who was found beaten and drowned in a Victoria waterway in 1997.
Ellard was found guilty in April 2005 on a third trial after a jury deliberated for five days following five weeks of testimony. She was sentenced to life in prison and was to serve seven years before seeking parole.
Virk was 14 when she was swarmed and beaten under a bridge in Saanich on Vancouver Island on Nov. 14, 1997, by a group of teenagers who were mainly girls, police said.
Battered and bloodied, Virk managed to get up and stagger across the bridge toward a bus stop to make her way home. But two of the original attackers dragged her back, hit her again and left her in a waterway.
Reena Virk's body was found eight days after she was swarmed and beaten under a bridge in Saanich on Vancouver Island on Nov. 14, 1997. (CBC)
The Appeal Court decision Friday means Ellard, now 25, has the right to a new trial.
She had faced two previous trials. In the first trial in March 2000, she was found guilty of second-degree murder but the verdict was overturned on appeal. The second trial, which was granted on grounds that the Crown didn't give her a fair trial, ended in a hung jury in July 2004.

