Some background on the attacked Yeshiva

gryfin

New member
Aug 30, 2001
9,632
0
0
It turns out it was a fanatic factory that turned out some the most odious characters in the Middle East. Many of its graduates are the among the most rabidly anti-arab settlers in the West Bank and who are bent on expansionism at any cost, including violence. Why any parent would send a child to this place is beyond belief.

Read more:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/962041.html
 
Talk about dumb-assed statement.

You are implying that these kids studying religion are justifiable targets because of what their political might be.

No other comment is needed on your warped world and (im)moral views.
 
basketcase said:
Talk about dumb-assed statement.

You are implying that these kids studying religion are justifiable targets because of what their political might be.

No other comment is needed on your warped world and (im)moral views.

No, I'm not justifying it at all. I'm explaining that in the real world, things don't happen by accident. It was not just a random attack. Why is that hard for you to accept.

And I don't know how anyone could equate what these people were learning with any legitimate kind of religion. Many seemed to graduate with a vicious and violent intolerance of anything that was not consistent with their ideological goals.
 
The non-random nature of the attack was based on the fact that the murdering bastard worked for the school, knew the layout and figured that he would be able to in without a problem.

Saying "things don't happen by accident" or "Why any parent would send a child to this place is beyond belief" is quite simply blaming the victims for being attacked. The only person to blame for this is the sick bastard who chose to kill a bunch of kids.

I don't think you can talk your way out of this.
 
basketcase said:
Saying "things don't happen by accident" or "Why any parent would send a child to this place is beyond belief" is quite simply blaming the victims for being attacked. The only person to blame for this is the sick bastard who chose to kill a bunch of kids.

I don't think you can talk your way out of this.

Sorry chief, but this is the third time in an hour that you are 100% off the mark, so far as I've seen. He's providing us a context for this, not blaming fucking children for getting blown up.
 
More background

Yigal Amir, the killer of former Israeli prime minister Yitzhak Rabin, was a graduate of Merkaz Harav.
 
cypherpunk said:
He's providing us a context for this, not blaming fucking children for getting blown up.

He is not providing context.. there is no context for actions like this.
 
gryfin said:
It turns out it was a fanatic factory that turned out some the most odious characters in the Middle East. Many of its graduates are the among the most rabidly anti-arab settlers in the West Bank and who are bent on expansionism at any cost, including violence. Why any parent would send a child to this place is beyond belief.

Read more:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/962041.html
This isn't any more of an extreme fanatic factory than any Palestinian school that breeds hate and extremism against Jews and the West.
 
slowandeasy said:
He is not providing context.. there is no context for actions like this.
Hmmm....Don't you see the connection?

Hint...
Where do you think A’Q recruits its new young followers in Pakistan? Any guess?!
 
slowandeasy said:
He is not providing context.. there is no context for actions like this.

Of course there is context. There is context to everything.

If there were no context to this then this incident would be the isolated, random act of a complete lunatic, without motive or prejudice, his race and circumstances having no relevance to anything, alone and completely unaffected by any community values in relation to this.

Is that what you believe?
 
More context

Looks like these religious militants serve a government purpose:

"Mercaz Harav yeshiva, stated Olmert, has produced "the finest soldiers for many generations; people who have realized the Zionist faith. This yeshiva – which was founded by Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook – has educated and nurtured tradition and legacy, as part of Israel's resilience."

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3516686,00.html
 
I don't know everything and I'll admit it, unlike many of you who are sure of everything.

But I will say that a school with a particular philosophy will have many students who end up doing all sorts of different things in their lives.

I still don't see any justification for going into that school with an AK-47 and killing whoever happens to be studying there.

Those of you who feel like there is some valid reason to kill a bunch of people simply for what they MAY or may not believe can go to hell.
 
slowandeasy said:
He is not providing context.. there is no context for actions like this.

Of course there is context. Don't forget the IDF attacks in Gaza killed civilians including five teenagers playing soccer for god's sake. I also noticed this killing at the Yeshiva followed quite quickly the call in the Knesset for the expulsion of all Israeli arabs.

Anyone who thinks actions don't have consequences is naive.
 
jazzpig said:
Of course there is context. There is context to everything.

If there were no context to this then this incident would be the isolated, random act of a complete lunatic, without motive or prejudice, his race and circumstances having no relevance to anything, alone and completely unaffected by any community values in relation to this.

Is that what you believe?

Ok..there is context.

Justification is the word that I should have used instead of context.
 
chiller_boy said:
Of course there is context. Don't forget the IDF attacks in Gaza killed civilians including five teenagers playing soccer for god's sake. I also noticed this killing at the Yeshiva followed quite quickly the call in the Knesset for the expulsion of all Israeli arabs.

Anyone who thinks actions don't have consequences is naive.

Context is not the same as justification!! This vicious circle has been in play for a 1/2 century or more.

If you wish, you can go over to Gaza, and ask the terrorists who are sending rockets into Israel to please stop it. While you are at it, perhaps you can ask them to use the money that they would have spent on rockets to develop actual strategies that will build their country.....

If and when you can convince them to stop doing that, you might just have something positive.

In the meantime, there is a war going on, and Israel should be allowed to respond.

Finally, if you noticed the reactions of the two areas.... I did not see any dancing in the streets in Israel after the IDF attacks. What type of people will have their children celebrating terrorist attacks???
 
gryfin said:
It turns out it was a fanatic factory that turned out some the most odious characters in the Middle East. Many of its graduates are the among the most rabidly anti-arab settlers in the West Bank and who are bent on expansionism at any cost, including violence. Why any parent would send a child to this place is beyond belief.

Read more:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/962041.html

So if Israel hit a school in Palestinian territory you would provide the same "context"?
 
Stop and think about intent. Who are the planned targets. Who targets children and students? Who targets military opponents. Yes - there is tragedy on both sides. But celebrating in the streets when innocent people/children are hit, there is no excuse for that behavior. Yes - you know who celebrates that. Did not have to say it.
 
ocean976124 said:
So if Israel hit a school in Palestinian territory you would provide the same "context"?

If Israel hit a school in Palestine, you can bet that the mainstream media would cover the context pretty sufficiently. The fact that the media hasn't reported much on the proposed context is a strong indicator that either the media is biased or that the proposed context is not quite right.
 
Media in an open democracy can cause pain but forces discussion when wrong deeds occur. One sided media (or absent media) only reinforces ignorance for the followers and frustration for the rest of us.
 
There are two entirely different issues involved. I can't imagine someone defending a school shooting in Toronto because the school was run by Christian/Jewish/Moslem fundamentalists.

Was this school run by folks of the sort with whom most of us here on TERB would disagree - yes. But, as the expression goes “what does that have to do with he price of tea in China?” - Nothing, it is merely trying to defend the indefencible!