Soccer Question from new fan

Nad Smith

Well-known member
Nov 23, 2004
1,668
143
63
I have been enjoying watching fifa and pan am soccer. Never really watched the game before. Why are they limited to 3 substitutions per game? They have 23 players on roster. Even an injured player cant be replaced unless you use one of your 3. I am guessing this is the way it has been for centuries...but it doesn't make much sense to me. I did figure out why the goalkeeper wears a different uniform.
 
Subs are a tactic for coach to delay the game or a least slow the pace of game down if his or her team is under siege. Also it allows the coach to change teams tactics and playing structure. But for the most part it slows the game down which is also not good for broadcasting/TV. That's why there are only 3 allowed. Imagine unlimited subs what the game would be like? It would be like watching baseball when a team brings 10 new pitchers in an extra innings game.
 
Interesting reason...but I suspect it goes back before tv. Like baseball, I expect once you are taken out of a game - you can't go back in. And they have the added time feature. Or maybe a coach would make tactical subs at half time. I don't know, I am just asking. A lot of players riding the bench
 
It's also a tactics changer, if you are down a goal you might take off a midfielder for an attacker in the last few minutes. In the opposite case you would replace an attacker with a defensive player. In friendly (exhibition games) matches that number of 3 is pushed up to 5.
 
When it comes to soccer, the only answer I can think of is who cares on any question. However the women do play with more honour than the men.
 
When it comes to soccer, the only answer I can think of is who cares on any question. However the women do play with more honour than the men.

Ok I usually stay away from these ignorant trolling posts but this is a one timer, who cares about soccer? Ah let's see about 7 billion people, the World Cup dwarves just about anything you like (the Leafs, Oskie wee wee or whatever) but then again you live in an insular world which probably expands to your strip plaza in Huntsville or Scarborough. Why would you post in a discussion if you didn't care about except to be a troll? I don't like the CFL at all so I completely avoid the discussions on it, let me leave you with this troll boy, humans have different ways in dealing with birth, death, marriage etc but the one single thing that is constant on this planet are 22 players, 2 nets and one ball, that's why it's called the beautiful game.
 
in answer to the question...it has always been this way...soccer teams way back did not carry 23 players..most only carried enough to make 3 subs.
 
yes, but couldn't they change it? Seems weird to not be able to make more subs..maybe at half time or for an injury.....as I said I've been enjoying watching. I wondered about the players who don't get into games while their family is in the stands. I remember when my son was second string on his high school basketball team. Wasn't much fun to watch. (parental add-on...he was much better in baseball)
 
Historically no substitutions were allowed. A player could get injured and the team would have to play with 10 men. Since this made no sense FIFA changed the rules to allow substitutions. I can't be bothered to look up when this occurred but I am sure if you googled it the answer would be there. Cheers
 
My take would be that if anything they should probably reduce the number of substitutions, as mentioned above more often than not a team in the lead just uses them late in the game to run time off the clock. I cannot see them ever increasing the number of substitutes as fitness is such an important part of the game...often you will see good teams score decisive goals late on and part of the reason for this is that having controlled the tempo much of the match they have worn down their opponents while remaining fresher as it is always more tiring to be under pressure and defending. If they increased the number of subs you would see alot more team successfully parking the bus and playing for a scoreless draw as their players could run themselves into the ground defending and be swapped out by more guys who would do the same. Endless substitutions tend to work better in sports like hockey and NFL football where both teams are seeking more explosive bursts whereas soccer is much more tactical in nature and the ability to stay fit for 90 minutes is a key element.


yes, but couldn't they change it? Seems weird to not be able to make more subs..maybe at half time or for an injury.....as I said I've been enjoying watching. I wondered about the players who don't get into games while their family is in the stands. I remember when my son was second string on his high school basketball team. Wasn't much fun to watch. (parental add-on...he was much better in baseball)