Snowden and Manning

Apparently, Snowden and Manning are asking President Obama for pardons.

He should pardon them. If Hillary is immune and Petraeus is rehired, why not Manning and Snowdon.
 
Not going to happen. President Obama has already stated that he believes Edward Snowden should present his case to a jury. As to Bradley Manning, the President is concerned about his "legacy" pardoning or communing the sentence of Bradley Manning would do even more damage than President Clinton's pardon of Marc Rich.
 
Save for the fact that pardons and commutations aren't law but rather (either directly or by inheritance) the Royal Prerogative of Mercy.

In your twisted mind there must be a big difference.

Hillary and Petreaus goes free, Manning and Snowden are punished severely. Compute that.
 
pardoning or communing the sentence of Bradley Manning would do even more damage than President Clinton's pardon of Marc Rich.
I think one condition of the Marc Rich pardon is that he never return to these United States while still alive. It is a form of exile. Yes, still controversial.
 
There is a difference whether or not you like that there is.

There is an element of politics to pardons and clemency, and that is what you actually are objecting to.

Sounds like Trump may object to that as well.
Donald J. Trump ✔ @realDonaldTrump
Happy New Year to all, including to my many enemies and those who have fought me and lost so badly they just don't know what to do. Love!
 
There is a difference whether or not you like that there is.

There is an element of politics to pardons and clemency, and that is what you actually are objecting to.

One type of justice for the powerful, another for the regular people. I understand you love it, I don't.
 
I would take Snowden back if he tells us everything of value about Russia (a little bit of horse trading) but I think he will likely die in a skiing accident before he ever leaves Russia. Somehow I doubt Snowden will ever leave Russia alive, maybe not even dead.
 
One type of justice for the powerful, another for the regular people. I understand you love it, I don't.
No one is owed pardon or clemency, it is entirely a gift, the prerogative of mercy.

Hence the problem with your line of argument Danmand is that it's a bit like the Bonnie Raitt lyric "''Cause I can't make you love me if you don't." What you are arguing is but damn it you should love me, but as probably most of us know from experience that just doesn't work, and neither is it that the Sovereign or the President or a Governor can be forced to pardon someone or reduce their sentence because "it isn't fair."
 
You are obviously at the bottom of the barrel when you have to use Country and Western lyrics to argue your point.

Your position is indefensible, it stinks to high heaven.

PS: There has never been a single case in history of the powerful, the strongmen rulers and mass murdering dictators, who have not been able to find lawyers to justify their crimes.
 
What you look down your nose at Bonnie Raitt?

Hmm, are you one of those musical snobs who when they hear the William Tell Overture don't at least give a passing thought to The Lone Ranger?
 
I'll break this down for danmand:

Manning, convicted of a crime, doing his/her time.
Snowden, Suspected of a crime, has run to Russia to avoid judgement.
Patraeus, convicted of a crime, served his time.
Clinton, not charged, presumed innocent until proven otherwise.
 
I'll break this down for danmand:

Manning, convicted of a crime, doing his/her time.
Snowden, Suspected of a crime, has run to Russia to avoid judgement.
Patraeus, convicted of a crime, served his time.
Clinton, not charged, presumed innocent until proven otherwise.

A little more detail is needed:

Manning, sentenced to 35 years in prison
Snowden, not charged, presumed innocent until proven otherwise
Petraeus, sentenced to 2 years probation.
Clinton, not charged, presumed innocent until proven otherwise