Small claims court question

ShawnBoy

Member
Feb 10, 2003
63
0
6
A part of the parking garage roof where I live fell on my car and dented the hood.. it's not a lot of damage, only about $500, but more than I feel I should have to pay. Soooooo, I want to take them to court.

My questions are.. do I have to pay for the repair before taking them to court, or can I take them based on the estimated repair cost? Should I have a lawyer represent my case, and if so, can I claim his fees as well? And finally, how do I actually go about opening a case? Do I just go to the city courthouse and tell them I want to open a small claims court case?

Thanks in advance.
 
Before you do this...do they have any signs or disclaimers on their tickets with words to the effect of "we are not responsible for damages..."? If so, you might be out of luck.
 
None. And the damage was caused by structural failures and the general state of disrepair of the parking garage. I would think that even if such signs did exist, that they (the building) would still be responsible to make it a safe parking area.
 
The building manager has basically told me to shove off. He originally was going to pay for the cost of the repair, then when I provided quotes for $500, said he'd give me $200, but I'm not willing to accept so little.

At this stage, he's said that he won't pay anything; my only remaining option is small claims court.
 
If they dont give you cash, do a Soprano on them and take out the guy's knee.....just joking...these things are a lot of effort to get an additional $300 and payment is difficult to enforce even if you win.
 
If you go the small claims court route, it may be a long time before you even get a hearing (try a year!) and a lot of effort and time. For what its worth, I say try to get something from them and let it go. A lawyer's letter might work.
 
ShawnBoy said:
A part of the parking garage roof where I live fell on my car and dented the hood.. it's not a lot of damage, only about $500, but more than I feel I should have to pay. Soooooo, I want to take them to court.
ShawnBoy am I correct in presuming this took place in Ontario?
 
Its real easy to start the process, go to the courthouse building and they will tell you the procedure. Hearing will be in four to six weeks.
 
We do small claims court without our lawyer, I just talk to him on the phone to get quick advice, then we process it on our own. He says that it looks bad to have a lawyer in small claims court, judges don't like it. You can look it all up in the Ontario government website, it will tell you the local court, you can print the forms from the site and take them in filled out. Get a high estimate from a body shop, then add expenses for lost time, etc., so that you have a cushion to settle.
 
ShawnBoy said:
…edit…My questions are.. do I have to pay for the repair before taking them to court, or can I take them based on the estimated repair cost?…edit…
You're gonna get it fixed anyway, so why wait? Your position is that their garage damaged your car to the tune of $…, and since you shouldn't be out of pocket as an innocent parker, they should pay for it.

If anything, I'd think you'd be more believable on the amount w/ a paid invoice rather than an estimate. And rust over time just increases the damage. But you'd want to back it up w/ a couple or three quotes to show it represented a reasonably standard charge for the work.

And you'd also want to record the damage/injury before the repair, to add weight to the assertion that it was 'their' damage. In these days of cameraphones, one might hope you'd snapped the dent w/ the piece of concrete still lying there, along w/ the matching divot above.
 
Small claims costs in Ontario is under $150 but you can add this cost into your claim. Go to your local courthouse and get the paperwork - I've done this before and it does not take that long. Fill out the approiate forms but make sure you have all of their information....address, contact info, and be prepared to fill out the form detailling the entire course of events. Make sure to grab a copy on 'How to Fill Out A Successful Claim'. This will go a long way to making your claim successful. After you fill it out you will hand it to a person that works for the courts. They will go over it and make sure you have filled in everything correctly.

The next step is to have the claim 'served'. This can be done 2 ways - either you present the claim to the person (s) or you hire a server company to do it. Hiring the company (mileage + small fee) allows them to deliver and have the reciepant to sign official documents to verify reciept. To find a good server company call a lawyer's office locally and just ask them who does their serving. Get the number and your off and running.

Upon reciept the defendant has I think 10 days to file a response with the court. If this is missed you win however much your going for with no questions asked. If they respond by the required time a date is set at the court where YOU filed. Court dates will occur between 1 and 3 months away. What usually happens next is that the people you are suing dont have the time to deal with something like this. As a result they have the option to make a deal with you. Say they will give you $400 and this way they do not have to waste a day in court. If they do not make an offer the date will be set and off you go. PM me if you got any questions.

BTW - you can go ahead and get the car repaired. As long as you keep the reciepts and estimate they will still be obligated to pay for the repairs. Also you will need at least a couple of estimates to go along with the claim filing to make your case.
 
If I were you I would avoid small claims court...

It's not worth the time, effort, and stress, especially over $500. You should have taken the $200 when they offered it.

I'm speaking from experience here, I would never ever go to small claims court, or file any lawsuit for that matter, it's not worth the mental anguish, and yes there's plenty of mental anguish and stress even if you're the one filing the claim and are the plaintiff.
 
Don't listen to VinnyBuff. Small Claims Court can be a lot of fun, assuming you win and the guy you're claiming against dosn't skip the country.

If you win in Ontario, you will also win your court costs if you claim for them at the time. If the loser won't pay after the court decision comes down then you pay alittle more money to the bailif ( also reclaimable) and property can be seized or liens can be attached.

However the process can consume a lot of time and you will not be able to claim lawyer's wages if you're handling the case yourself. You may be able to get compensation for your time if you're self employes.

Before you start an action, I would send a letter to the property manager - matter of fact, cool and calm = specifying the grievance and what you consider a legitimate out of court settlement. Let him know the alternative and what he has to lose - small claims and court costs if he doesn't respond ito you in a certain time. Often they will blink first and try to reach a settlement.

good Luck
 
mikeeman said:
Don't listen to VinnyBuff. Small Claims Court can be a lot of fun, assuming you win and the guy you're claiming against dosn't skip the country.

If you win in Ontario, you will also win your court costs if you claim for them at the time. If the loser won't pay after the court decision comes down then you pay alittle more money to the bailif ( also reclaimable) and property can be seized or liens can be attached.

However the process can consume a lot of time and you will not be able to claim lawyer's wages if you're handling the case yourself. You may be able to get compensation for your time if you're self employes.

Before you start an action, I would send a letter to the property manager - matter of fact, cool and calm = specifying the grievance and what you consider a legitimate out of court settlement. Let him know the alternative and what he has to lose - small claims and court costs if he doesn't respond ito you in a certain time. Often they will blink first and try to reach a settlement.

good Luck

It's fun if you like stress and having your time wasted, it's not worth going to small claims court for $500, no matter what.
 
VinnyBuff said:
It's fun if you like stress and having your time wasted, it's not worth going to small claims court for $500, no matter what.

Well, I'm doing it on a matter of principle as well. Had he taken care of the damage as he originally said he would, as opposed to trying to simply offer me $200 (not even 1/2 or his "fair share" of the repair cost), I'd just let it slide.

Honestly, I don't see it as THAT much of a time sink.. go to the courthouse, get some papers. Fill them out, return them. Drop them off at the property management office. Spend a day in court reading while I wait for my case to be called. If I win, I can do Shawnboy's Dance of Victory and enjoy that smug "I-told-you-so" feeling. If I lose, well, I'm really not out anything, and at least I wasted his time too.

I have lots of pictures of the damage, of the concrete that hit my vehicle, and of the ceiling from where it fell. I've sent them letters, with pictures included, and have given them every opportunity to make it right. I have little concern that I won't win.
 
ShawnBoy said:
Honestly, I don't see it as THAT much of a time sink.. go to the courthouse, get some papers. Fill them out, return them. Drop them off at the property management office.

http://www.ontariocourtforms.on.ca/english/forms/scc/index.jsp

You don't even have to go to the courthouse to pick up the papers, you can fill them out online, print and just make the one trip to the courthouse to file:

http://www.ontariocourtforms.on.ca/english/forms/scc/forms/SCR_07A_Jan2506_CSD_fil.doc
 
ShawnBoy said:
Well, I'm doing it on a matter of principle as well. Had he taken care of the damage as he originally said he would, as opposed to trying to simply offer me $200 (not even 1/2 or his "fair share" of the repair cost), I'd just let it slide.

Honestly, I don't see it as THAT much of a time sink.. go to the courthouse, get some papers. Fill them out, return them. Drop them off at the property management office. Spend a day in court reading while I wait for my case to be called. If I win, I can do Shawnboy's Dance of Victory and enjoy that smug "I-told-you-so" feeling. If I lose, well, I'm really not out anything, and at least I wasted his time too.

I have lots of pictures of the damage, of the concrete that hit my vehicle, and of the ceiling from where it fell. I've sent them letters, with pictures included, and have given them every opportunity to make it right. I have little concern that I won't win.

You also have to go to a pre-trial hearing, that's another wasted day , it only takes an hour or so, but you have to prepare for it, it takes a while.

Also, since the defendant offered you a $200 settlement, the judge may take that into account and reduce the amount in his judgment.

I went to small claims court for the exact same reason as you, to get revenge , I knew I was right, I wanted to be victorious at all costs, but after it was all said and done, I realized it was definitely not worth it, even though I won, but I didn't win everything I anticipated. Everyone's different though, and I think it would be a good experience to at least try small claims court out once, now's your perfect chance so if you really want to, go for it.
 
You will win.

He's obligated to maintain the property in a safe condition.

I sued GM (as in General Motors) in small claims court. It was easy and I got what I was looking for.

I would send him a letter to start with. Fax it to him, keep a copy of the fax receipt along with a copy of the letter. The letter needs to say at some point that he is to respond by December 31, 2007 (say).

BTW, a piece of concrete that falls off of a slab is called a spall.

If you want to see where it's going to spall off next, take a mason's hammer to the concrete, hit the concrete with a normal amount of force and listen to the sound. If it's a sharp ring, it's solid, if it's a dull "thud", then the piece of concrete is delaminated and it's going to spall off in the future.

You could always sick the Building Department on him as a bit of a lesson to him.
 
The garage manager is a prick. I hope you stick it to him good. Good luck, and let us know how it turns out.