Skilled Trades shortage?

newtohobby

New member
Jul 22, 2006
445
0
0
I keep on hearing on the news how we are so short on skilled trades workers and how we are gonna have to bring in more immigrants to fill these positions up. No offence to any immigrants or anything, but hearing how the government wants to fund and help the immigrants find jobs in canada, shouldn't they help out the real canadians first? Canada is a great place in my opinion but for immigrants it was their choice and the risk they were gonna take. So I believe us canadians should get first dibs on jobs and help first. thats my opinon.
 
They wouldn't have to bring in immigrants to do the job if Canadians really wanted to do them. There is a lack of people going through the apprenticeship programs in school. There has been this deficiency for numerous years now. Do Canadians want to work the long hours involved in trades jobs, i think that is the question that needs to be asked
 
What you term as "real" Canadians are basically lazy on average. There is great opportunity for anyone to progress their career and rewards if they are willing to put the effort in to it.

I see nothing wrong with letting immigrants into Canada because that is basically how Canada was built. We stuck all the "really real" Canadians on Indian reserves and let them open up Casinos with no tax. I don't like that but they are the "real" Canadians, not us.

I do have to admit our government doesn't have a clue how to run a country. I think Govt should be run like a business. Privitization would help in some counts but it's not the utlimate answer to fix what our government screwed up so bad.

Anyways, in my humble opinion I still love Canada. I feel safe here. :p
 
Canadians do get "first dibs" on those jobs.. but there is a shortage because most canadians do not want to do those jobs. Schools push people to go to university. The only kids that are pushed to go into the trades are "slow" kids.
 
There's tonnes of opportunities for "real Canadians" to learn trades here. Just enter "trades ontario" into your search engine.
 
How many parents want their kids to grow up to be a plumber or a roofer? How many parents want their kids to grow up to be a doctor or a lawyer?

We have a shortage of skilled trades because our society devalues work done by trades, and gives a large value boost to lawyers.
 
Compromised said:
We have a shortage of skilled trades because our society devalues work done by trades, and gives a large value boost to lawyers.

Bingo.

Also, sorry to burst the other poster's bubble, but Canada has always relied on immigrants to perform a lot of the "unskilled" trades work. Europeans in particular. It's funny that those same people who came to Canada with little to no skills are now complaining about future waves of immigrants in the same situation!

Canada's economic future depends upon immigration. You may not want to hear that, but it's the truth. In order for a capitalist economy (which we are) to survive, it must continually grow. And to continually grow means that the population must continually grow to purchase more of everything. And with a declining birthrate, the only way to increase population is via immigration.

The real underlying crux of the "problem" of immigration is that the immigrants are no longer Europeans but are now visible minorities and people just don't like that fact. In short, it's racism. Sure there's lots of weak "justifications," but at the end of the day there's just a lot of Canadians (white or otherwise) who don't want to see another "paki" coming to Canada.

There's also a shortage of skilled professionals (e.g., doctors/nurses), but that's due more to problems with credentials and the fact that all Western nations are fighting for skilled immigrants.

As for addressing the shortage of skilled trades, I have definitely seen a recognition of the problem and concerted efforts to address it over the past 5 years or so. Government funding is becoming available and the stakeholders are looking at ways to provide help. It's a very slow change in mindset, but I can also see the corner being turned on parents recognizing that maybe working in the trades might not be so bad, especially when "little johnny" bombs out of university after the first year. Not to mention that every Canadian wants to be a middle manager or professional and no one wants to be the worker bees that support those positions. As the numbers of skilled trades continues to decline and the rates of pay correspondingly go up, tradeswork will become more and more popular.
 
As stated repeatedly, yes we have a shortage of skilled or unskilled trades because those here don't want to do it.

I've talked this over with many of the people I've hired and fired over the past while and here's the scoop on the why:
1) Too much physical exertion: who the hell wants to carry 4 x 8 sheets of ply/drywall/MDF back and forth for hours on end? Damn things are heavy
2) Too hot too cold: who the hell wants to work in minus 40 or plus 40 temperatures?
3) Dirty
4) Unappreciated. When I was working for a developer, the new owners had no appreciation of the amount of work hours that went in to putting their condo together. Being independant again, my customers (for the most part) appreciate the amount of time and effort I put in.
5) Cost of tools: Most trades require someone to supply their own tools. Personally I have probably close to 10 grand worth and I still need a few things. For eg: I probably have $500.00 worth of clamps alone, never mind all the 18 v batteries at $100.00 each, drills, power saws, hand saws, biscuit jointers etc etc etc

One thing that does help the appreciation factor is that many homeowners are now trying it themselves. Now there are many things someone with just half a brain can do but I am finding a lot of the time now I'm out there fixing up things they've fuct up totally.

I worked for a cabinet shop and we had some interns with us from a local high school. Talk about lazy. I mean, we had to pry them off the floor and almost drag them by the ear to get them to move. Plus they didn't want to learn the basics and do the grunt work before jumping into the complicated joinery type operations. For eg: every door I've ever made takes a lot of sanding to get it baby's ass smooth. Not a ONE wanted to listen to what we tried to teach them, not a one thought it was a valuable skill, even tho someone could make a career of properly sanding wood (which is an integral part of the final finishing aspect).

ANyhow, bottom line is I will welcome anyone who truly wants to learn, but if you don't? Get the hell outta my face and stop wasting my, and other's time. I don't care who you are or where you come from too. Funny thing: we had one guy working for us, I jokingly said "where the hell you from, BF zombabwe? He said: actually I am from zimbabwe but I don't know where BF is lol.
 
I'm looking to change careers and thinking on skilled trades. What type of jobs are we short in the skilled trades? How do you apply for an appreticeship? how much do they usually make?
 
When you consider the weather is not warm here 8 months out of the 12, then you don't have a desirable situation of people wanting to work skilled trades outside.
 
Outdoor Construction is not the only field with skilled trades. There are many that involve stritcly indoor work.

Machining,
Welding,
Pipe fitting

I strongly recommend getting into a union of a large goverment corporation.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Bingo.

Also, sorry to burst the other poster's bubble, but Canada has always relied on immigrants to perform a lot of the "unskilled" trades work. Europeans in particular. It's funny that those same people who came to Canada with little to no skills are now complaining about future waves of immigrants in the same situation!

Canada's economic future depends upon immigration. You may not want to hear that, but it's the truth. In order for a capitalist economy (which we are) to survive, it must continually grow. And to continually grow means that the population must continually grow to purchase more of everything. And with a declining birthrate, the only way to increase population is via immigration.

The real underlying crux of the "problem" of immigration is that the immigrants are no longer Europeans but are now visible minorities and people just don't like that fact. In short, it's racism. Sure there's lots of weak "justifications," but at the end of the day there's just a lot of Canadians (white or otherwise) who don't want to see another "paki" coming to Canada.

There's also a shortage of skilled professionals (e.g., doctors/nurses), but that's due more to problems with credentials and the fact that all Western nations are fighting for skilled immigrants.

As for addressing the shortage of skilled trades, I have definitely seen a recognition of the problem and concerted efforts to address it over the past 5 years or so. Government funding is becoming available and the stakeholders are looking at ways to provide help. It's a very slow change in mindset, but I can also see the corner being turned on parents recognizing that maybe working in the trades might not be so bad, especially when "little johnny" bombs out of university after the first year. Not to mention that every Canadian wants to be a middle manager or professional and no one wants to be the worker bees that support those positions. As the numbers of skilled trades continues to decline and the rates of pay correspondingly go up, tradeswork will become more and more popular.


What happens when we run out of land and resources? This is a lot of blarney put out by banks and other big business. What are the growth rates and birth rates of a country like Switzerland? Why can't a country provide for itself without importing people in order to survive according to economic experts?

x
 
xdog said:
What happens when we run out of land and resources? This is a lot of blarney put out by banks and other big business. What are the growth rates and birth rates of a country like Switzerland? Why can't a country provide for itself without importing people in order to survive according to economic experts?

x

Ok, let's see, we have the same, or larger land mass than the US, but only have the population of New York City and the 5 boroughs? I think worrying about running out of land anytime soon is not really relevant.
 
newtohobby said:
I'm looking to change careers and thinking on skilled trades. What type of jobs are we short in the skilled trades? How do you apply for an appreticeship? how much do they usually make?

If you're thinking construction, then I'd recommend plumbing/pipefitting or electrical. Those tend to lead the pack in terms of wages. You can also work indoors. AFAIK, both require certification of some sort. Your best bet would be to talk to an actual plumber and/or electrician to see what's involved.

Stonemasonry also comes to mind, but I think that would take a lot more training. It's also a lot of hard work lugging those stones around.

I know a guy who got into bricklaying a few years back and he said it was backbreaking labour at first, but now he's learning to actually lay brick and he'll be making really good coin in a few years.

In short, you don't want to end up being a general (unskilled) labourer. If you do, you'll be doing all the grunt work with no payoff down the road.

Many of the trades would love to take you on as an apprentice as they just can't find anyone willing to start at the bottom and do the gruntwork until they've earned their dues. You just have to make it clear that, 1) you're only willing to do the gruntwork when there's a payoff down the road, and 2) you're not going to disappear after a couple weeks/months.
 
tboy said:
I worked for a cabinet shop and we had some interns with us from a local high school. Talk about lazy. I mean, we had to pry them off the floor and almost drag them by the ear to get them to move. Plus they didn't want to learn the basics and do the grunt work before jumping into the complicated joinery type operations.

Papi Chulo said:
The only kids that are pushed to go into the trades are "slow" kids.


Another good area is tool and die maker. It requires some training but it isn't heavy manual labour and is indoor.
 
I'm curious, I look on the jobfutures.ca website and look for the outlook of several skiled trades and the outlook is all fair so I don't really understand the shortage part.
 
Competition

you say canadians get first dibs but looking through the www.jobfutures.ca website, under the work prospects, appearantly we don't get first dibs. There a category for preparing for competition and it states:

You'll be competing with a large number of immigrants.

so how do canadians get first dibs on jobs then?


Papi Chulo said:
Canadians do get "first dibs" on those jobs.. but there is a shortage because most canadians do not want to do those jobs. Schools push people to go to university. The only kids that are pushed to go into the trades are "slow" kids.
 
I tried.

I tried to be a millwright, machinist, plumber and some other stuff. Do you think I even had the chance?

I didn't read the last 1/4 of the page so..

1. My guidance counselors was more worried about his football team. And he graduated some of those players.

2. Every time a contractor came over to our place I would ask where can I go learn this trade? the answer was always.. " I don't know"

3. Once I figure out I needed a sponsor nobody wanted to sponsor me.

4. Then I was asked if I had my own tools... Where am I going to get 10k dollars to buy tools then not get a sponsor.

5. Those jobs Ontario want you to be under 26 yr old.
6. Once I showed up at college and they told me get a sponsor.

7. With immigrants an employer doesn't have to worry about paying $12 hour. This is routine of employers to scream just so the gov't let more trades men in for less than $9 hour. This happens every 2 years.

8. Don't get me started in unions.

In the end find a guy who will fake the sponsor papers for you and pay him his 50 when you get out of school just look for someone else and tell him you were doing this for 3 years.

Everyone lies.
Haven't we covered this topic before.
 
xix said:
I tried to be a millwright, machinist, plumber and some other stuff. Do you think I even had the chance?

I didn't read the last 1/4 of the page so..

1. My guidance counselors was more worried about his football team. And he graduated some of those players.

2. Every time a contractor came over to our place I would ask where can I go learn this trade? the answer was always.. " I don't know"

3. Once I figure out I needed a sponsor nobody wanted to sponsor me.

4. Then I was asked if I had my own tools... Where am I going to get 10k dollars to buy tools then not get a sponsor.

5. Those jobs Ontario want you to be under 26 yr old.
6. Once I showed up at college and they told me get a sponsor.

7. With immigrants an employer doesn't have to worry about paying $12 hour. This is routine of employers to scream just so the gov't let more trades men in for less than $9 hour. This happens every 2 years.

8. Don't get me started in unions.

In the end find a guy who will fake the sponsor papers for you and pay him his 50 when you get out of school just look for someone else and tell him you were doing this for 3 years.

Everyone lies.
Haven't we covered this topic before.

Where there is a will, there is a way. You obviously did not put enough effort into it.

Perseverance pays off.