SIU get their man!!!

fmahovalich

Active member
Aug 21, 2009
7,256
25
38
After three tries the SIU has charged that Metro Police lad from the G20 conference.

He has now been identified since he was charged..although his name escapes me at the moment!

Anyway....I'm guessing that the SIU bowed to public pressure, and layed a charge with the same evidence they had at the first investigation! Given their track record, I certainly don't expect a conviction!!
 
My understanding is that the SIU played no role in identifying this cop. Apparently, the Toronto Star purchased the equipment (not sure what that is) required to distinguish the number on the helmet in the photo. Apparently, this is technology that the TPS has available to it, but I guess just never thought to use it in this case.

The way the SIU and the TPS have acted through this whole G20 police behaviour issue has been a joke and both those organizations have lost a great deal of credibility in the eyes of the public. They should both be ashamed of themselves. Not just the police officers that committed the abuses, but all the police, from Blaire on down.
 
The victim, quoted in the Star article, summed it up well:
The Star said:
Barton is heartened by the news. But at the same time, he considers the charging of one officer to be just a “first step toward justice.”

“I don’t really feel like it’s all (one) guy’s fault,” he said. “Someone probably gave him orders to arrest me, and then I was denied medical attention, I was kept in custody for 30 hours,” he said. “None of this has anything to do with (one) guy.”
The Star

The 'leadership, command and management' <tone of sneering irony> of the police—SIU included—has been abysmal from last June's events thru all the non-responses, denials and cover-ups until now. A year to lay (or clear) an assault charge with a dozen cops including supervisors witnessing the incident? Tinpot banana republics do better.
 
The victim, quoted in the Star article, summed it up well:

The 'leadership, command and management' <tone of sneering irony> of the police—SIU included—has been abysmal from last June's events thru all the non-responses, denials and cover-ups until now. A year to lay (or clear) an assault charge with a dozen cops including supervisors witnessing the incident? Tinpot banana republics do better.

Well just be glad we don't live in a real police state. It never would have come this far. There was public pressure and it did have an effect, but as far as the time it took much of that is due to the fact that the whole case had to be totally air tight and there has to be a reasonable expectation of a successful prosecution. Jury are really hesitant to find officer guilty, so the evidence has to be better than good. Any good lawyer will tell you that. The people who were stonewalling had to eventually realize any more would cost them.

I noticed the officer now has a goatee, maybe to hide his identity, but that beak is hard to hide. It will be interesting to see what his roommate has to say under oath, but I suspect it won't make it to court and a plea will materialize.
 
Well, I guess Glenn Weddell, the officer identified by Toronto Star, is probably looking at a couple of years of time off, with pay. He'll just have to scrape by without overtime. He'll probably get to keep his badge, though, so he won't have to worry about having to pay for his food and drinks.
 
Well just be glad we don't live in a real police state. It never would have come this far. There was public pressure and it did have an effect, but as far as the time it took much of that is due to the fact that the whole case had to be totally air tight and there has to be a reasonable expectation of a successful prosecution. Jury are really hesitant to find officer guilty, so the evidence has to be better than good. Any good lawyer will tell you that. The people who were stonewalling had to eventually realize any more would cost them.

I noticed the officer now has a goatee, maybe to hide his identity, but that beak is hard to hide. It will be interesting to see what his roommate has to say under oath, but I suspect it won't make it to court and a plea will materialize.
Geez, silly me! Here I thought that all cases had to "…be airtight" when people (who might be innocent) are charged.

While I think they should be trained, and administered to see the error of their ways, I can understand the line-constables' loyalty and their supervisors as well. But it cannot be tolerated if they are 'our' police enforcing the rule of our laws in our democracy, unless it takes second place to their oath of loyalty to 'we the people' and to our laws and government. I don't question that Scott at the SIU and Blair at TPS have that loyalty, but this episode has demonstrated vividly, just how inneffectual they have been in demanding and instilling it in the rank and file.

This, and other G20 episodes, was a failure of leadership and administration as much or more than it ever was an assault. So far, it seems it still is.
 
FYI, the second G20 review meeting was recently held in Etobicoke and a thundering herd of maybe 20+ people showed up to express their concern. No sign of anyone with a long naked skinny tail sticking out of their trousers, I guess GG didn't make it. For those who would dar cross Yonge St even if they were on fire, the next one will be held in Scarborough on June 13(?).
 
Geez, silly me! Here I thought that all cases had to "…be airtight" when people (who might be innocent) are charged.

While I think they should be trained, and administered to see the error of their ways, I can understand the line-constables' loyalty and their supervisors as well. But it cannot be tolerated if they are 'our' police enforcing the rule of our laws in our democracy, unless it takes second place to their oath of loyalty to 'we the people' and to our laws and government. I don't question that Scott at the SIU and Blair at TPS have that loyalty, but this episode has demonstrated vividly, just how inneffectual they have been in demanding and instilling it in the rank and file.

This, and other G20 episodes, was a failure of leadership and administration as much or more than it ever was an assault. So far, it seems it still is.

When dealing with police officers, it has to be even more solid. You know that and why.
 
When dealing with police officers, it has to be even more solid. You know that and why.

Right... because there are laws for us, and then there are laws for them. The reason the case against cops has to be airtight is not because the jury doesn't like to prosecute cops, it's because the cops know how to play the system and have the support of other cops. Evidence goes missing... cops don't remember (or recognize roommates) in their testimonies ... etc.

It's funny how the cops were able to identify and charge the man accused of burning up the cop car months ago, with much less to go on than they had on this asshole Weddell. It's amazing what the cops can do when they are motivated to put someone in jail..... or to keep another cop out of jail.
 
When dealing with police officers, it has to be even more solid. You know that and why.
No it does not. But maybe that is how the cops play their game on each other. That needs to be stopped.

Their unique role and privileged position in society means they should be held to a higher standaard of behaviour—and certainly need no more evidence against them—than ordinary citizens. At $90K, any existing cop who can't measure up will be easy to replace.
 
Last edited:
No it does not. But maybe that is how the cops play their game on each other. That needs to be stopped.

Their unique role and privileged position in society means they should be held to a higher standaard of behaviour—and certainly need no more evidence against them—than ordinary citizens. At $90K, any existing cop who can't measure up will; be easy to replace.

This is not just my opinion, but that of at least a half dozen lawyers that I've had the opportunity to discuss just this kind of topic. The lawyer members of TERB can comment on this.

They don't need 'more ' evidence, just rock solid evidence and no questionable procedures that can be grounds for dismissal or appeal. Considering there have been 7+ committees convened over this G20 event, I'd say there are a lot of people looking into them and their actions, but apparently the public don't generally too concerned or upset as shown by the small turnout at the latest forum to discuss the G20 activity.
 
So which is it? When charging cops do we need evidence of the same standards of rock-solidness as when charging ordinary citizens or not?

Likewise which is it about the inquiries? Are they to be trusted, in which case we can get on with other things or are they mere shams? And are you urging us to get down there and turn them into lynch mobs, or leave them for the people with direct involvement?

Besides, who but full-time followers can figure out which inquiry's looking into what aspect of which bungled bit of the fiasco?
 
So which is it? When charging cops do we need evidence of the same standards of rock-solidness as when charging ordinary citizens or not?

Likewise which is it about the inquiries? Are they to be trusted, in which case we can get on with other things or are they mere shams? And are you urging us to get down there and turn them into lynch mobs, or leave them for the people with direct involvement?

Besides, who but full-time followers can figure out which inquiry's looking into what aspect of which bungled bit of the fiasco?

As far as I can figure out there are a few lawyers here on TERB, but I'm not sure if any of them have been or are Crowns, but I'm sure they can explain it more clearly than I. Because of a natural but not necessarily proper hesitancy for juries to convict police officers, the case/evidence does has to be stronger. Proper or right no, but a regular fact in courts. It's not necessarily a legal standard but a human standard, jurors being human after all. There are changes in this attitude from the Crowns but they are slow and still have to get by the juries mind set.

You last statement is quite correct and makes a lot of the arm chair experts blathering quite light weight at this time. I believe only 2 of the 7 are in with their findings and have no idea when the others will finish. As for their precise mandates, I try not to clog too much of my little grey cells with those details.