Simple minds, simple solutions...refugee crisis

TeasePlease

Cockasian Brother
Aug 3, 2010
7,723
7
38
I think most Canadians get that we need to step up, but it's not just throwing open our doors. Healthcare, education, jobs, etc.


http://t.thestar.com/#/article/news...or-canada-to-accept-more-syrian-refugees.html.


NDP foreign affairs critic Paul Dewar says the NDP will reach out to the Conservative government to ask it to adopt an “accelerated plan” to bring more than 46,000 government-sponsored refugees to Canada by 2019, including 10,000 by the end of 2015.

The NDP plan would involve appointing a Syrian refugee co-ordinator as soon as possible to organize government and departmental resources to facilitate entry and settlement of refugees.
 
Of course it isn't. It's also but one of several refugee situations going on in the world at any one time. But the vast majority of these people will become hard-working, tax-paying citizens in time. Having said that, due diligence must be used to vet those coming in so we aren't just importing "their" problems...
 
Not easy but we should do something. Europe can't shoulder it all. Harper's 10,000 over 4 years sounds pitiful and the media is saying his campaign is losing steam as a result along with other factors.

The only thing I will say is that I don't think Toronto can absorb it all or most, but Canada is a big country with many communities.
 
Last edited:
Of course it isn't. It's also but one of several refugee situations going on in the world at any one time. But the vast majority of these people will become hard-working, tax-paying citizens in time. s...

Not if they're talking about those bands running amok in Hungary. They're not really refugees, having already failed the bullshit test by turning their nose up at registering in Hungary, and proven the willingness to use force when they dont get their way.
 
Aylan-Kurdi-628x328.jpg


No child deserves this while just looking for safety.
I cried at this image, my grandson is the same age.
 
Aylan-Kurdi-628x328.jpg


No child deserves this while just looking for safety.
I cried at this image, my grandson is the same age.

The argument has been put forth that it's also the parents who put their children in extremely risky situations (no flotation devices in their raft). Sad predicament in any event.
 
Muslims created this problem and Muslims have to solve it. We, and that includes the NDP, can't do it for them. The Kurds need their own homeland. Protests held today by Kurds (Muslims) against Turkey (also Muslims).
 
Aylan-Kurdi-628x328.jpg


No child deserves this while just looking for safety.
I cried at this image, my grandson is the same age.

Yup. that image hit close to home. I felt sick to my stomach.

But, Trudeau and especially Mulcair are really dropping the ball here. Instead of seizing a leadership moment, they are pandering to the feeble-minded. more importantly, in the middle of an election campaign, they are showing an alarming lack of understanding of geopolitics and history.

We can and should step up here. It's the Canadian thing to do. But opening our borders is just one of many steps. My prime minister better have answers to the second, third and eighth question after that.
 
Each of the different Islamic sects need to have their own country since they cannot and never will be able to get along with each other. Even with such designated countries I don't know how you stop them from killing each other. I'm not against immigration, not against aiding true refugees but for the sake of my children, grandchildren and future great-grandchildren I don't want to see the middle east Muslim problems imported into Canada. And I don't think either the NDP or the Liberals have the backbone to protect the current citizens of Canada. The election platform of both parties is to end the fight with ISIS, in effect giving ISIS Canada's permission to carry on with their atrocities and genocide. I don't know when Canada became a country that thinks genocide and atrocities are acceptable practices. The only way to solve the refugee problem is to eliminate the terrorists that are causing the refugees, not by sticking your head up your ass and pretending there is no ongoing problem like Justin & Thomas are want to do.
 
Mulcair, for once, got it right:

"He said the current conflict in Syria and Iraq is the result of the attempted overthrow of a government coupled with the misguided military policies of Western powers — proving, he added, that more bombs are not the answer."

The implication is that, if the war went away, people would return to their homes.

That one picture of a child's body washed up on a beach illustrates the ignorance of the suffering that has been going on in Syria for the last 4 years. There are millions of Syrian refugees. The death of children as a result of war and the fleeing of war, in reality, has been repeated thousands of times already. So how come, all of a sudden, the world wants action now, rather than years ago when all this started?

As Joseph Stalin once said: 'A single death is a tragedy.... a million deaths is a statistic.'

Accepting even 40,000 refugees is merely a drop in the bucket. We may feel good about it but what about the other few million? We are hypocrites if we just accept our quota and say to the rest of them 'sorry, you're on your own'. But there are too many of them; we can't take them all without causing an upheaval in our society.

The only way of sorting out this mess is to end the proxy war the US and its client states and staunch allies (like the single family rule despot rulers of Saudi Arabia) have been waging through their proxies in Syria. Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the Gulf monarchies have been funding, training and transporting ISIS as far back when it was called Al-Qaida, in order to topple the secular regime of Bashar Al-Assad (because they want a pipeline through Syria). The regime of Saudi Arabia is a fundamentalist dictatorship where its citizens have no rights ( I know, I lived there; it's not a fairy tale monarchy and the King doesn't live in the Disneyland castle), and are subject to religious laws far harsher than Iran. At least, Iran has some semblance of a democracy; they have elections, however imperfect.

Mulcair is the first leader to publicly denounce the Western powers' meddling, interference and regime change actions in Syria.

The Syrian Arab Army is the only credible ground force fighting ISIS (the US led air war against ISIS is merely window dressing: an expensive show). The Syrian Army is majority Sunni, so why are they fighting for the Alawite (Shiite Muslim) Assad? Because they want to preserve their secular way of life. Syria is a secular society, where Arab minorities like Christians (Greek Orthodox, Armenian Catholic, Armenian Orthodox, Syriac, Maronite etc) and Shiites coexist with the majority Sunni Muslims, and are integrated in all strata of Syrian life, including its military. The alternative to Assad's secular regime is Islamic fundamentalism that will be the result of US geopolitical goals if Assad falls. That's why people are fleeing. They see what has happened in ISIS controlled territory in the form of ethnic cleansing, mass executions and enslavement of those minorities.
 
Muslims created this problem and Muslims have to solve it. We, and that includes the NDP, can't do it for them. The Kurds need their own homeland. Protests held today by Kurds (Muslims) against Turkey (also Muslims).

I read a lot of dumb things, but this, yes your quote, is purely idiotic and seething with racism.
 
Mulcair, for once, got it right: "He said the current conflict in Syria and Iraq is the result of the attempted overthrow of a government coupled with the misguided military policies of Western powers — proving, he added, that more bombs are not the answer."The implication is that, if the war went away, people would return to their homes.
Question: Are the Western powers bombing Assad or ISIS or both? Regardless, is Mulcair's solution to stop bombing regardless? Didn't the bombing at least stopped any further advance by ISIS? Does Mulcair think stopping any further advance by ISIS is a bad thing?
 
Question: Are the Western powers bombing Assad or ISIS or both? Regardless, is Mulcair's solution to stop bombing regardless? Didn't the bombing at least stopped any further advance by ISIS? Does Mulcair think stopping any further advance by ISIS is a bad thing?

The US is playing a game. They want first and foremost the overthrow of the Assad regime, because Assad is not pliant to US foreign policy, and because he is allied to Russia (which is also not pliant to US foreign policy, unlike his predecessor Yeltsin). That's why they funded the so-called Free Syrian Army; that experiment failed because the political arm never got its act together, and because their US trained and funded fighters either got wiped out by ISIS and the parent Jabhat Al-Nusra front, defected to them, or sold their weapons to them and ran away. ISIS is doing the fighting that is threatening the overthrow of Assad. Saudi Arabia got ISIS going less than a couple of years ago, by financing though private channels, what became ISIS. Saudi Arabia thought they could control ISIS, but it seems the latter got different and bigger ideas; the blowback is the ISIS invasion of Iraq and the ultimate threat to Saudi Arabia. It is not known what the complicity of the US is, but right now, ISIS is doing the US'/Saudi Arabia/Qatar bidding by attempting to overthrow Assad. The US, with its massive billion dollar worldwide intelligence and surveillance operations (CIA/NSA), could not have not known that hundreds of millions of dollars of Saudi money were being transfered to Al-Qaida. With ISIS controlling a territory the size of England, and it's force of over 40,000 jihadists spread over that territory, the US led bombing campaign is ineffective, and was always meant to be. ISIS cannot be defeated by air alone. The only effective use of US air power was to prevent ISIS from overrunning Kurdish towns. Apart from that, the US and its allies are content letting ISIS overrun Syria, and the US doesn't care what historical sites get destroyed, what minorities get enslaved or killed, or the fact that 2000 years of Arab Christianity is about to fade to nothing in the next couple of years.

The US/UK/France are not bombing Assad's forces, since they don't have to: ISIS is making gains; doing so would also be an act of war, and a war crime under the UN Charter. The US is not going to bomb ISIS in the defense of Assad. But if ISIS succeeds to overthrow Assad, ISIS is going to take over the power vacuum. Then things will get complicated since Turkey's Erdogan has designs on Syria. Being shut out of EU integration despite being decades in NATO, Turkey is turning its eyes towards its former Ottoman Empire. They want to put their puppet at the head of a re-established Province of Damascus. They also want to crush all Kurds' aspirations to autonomy, and that's why they are bombing them presently in Syria and Iraq (yes, the same ones resisting ISIS) and have proceeded to mass arrests of Kurds in Turkey (while Canada is training Kurdish forces). Turkey with its huge army (it can beat any individual European army), will wipe out ISIS when the time comes and take over all of Syria. It is Turkey that has facilitated the transit of Jihadists from other countries intoto Syria and Iraq. It was also Turkish intelligence that set up the false flag operation in Damascus, where they tried to pin the blame for a nerve gas attack on a part of Damascus on Assad; the real goal was to get the US to start a bombing campain (crossing the red line) against Syrian military, and thereby let the US do Turkey's bidding.

At the same time, the reason why Saudi Arabia wants to overthrow Assad is because of the rise of Shiite Iranian influence in the region on the Shiite states of Iran friendly Iraq (Shiite ever since the US 'liberated' Iraq and handed over power to the majority Shiites), Syria and Lebanon (Hezbollah). They consider Shiites as dirt, only worth chopping their heads off, and they want to spread their form of 17th century fundamentalist Islam and have the rest of Arabia and the Levant toe the line. Saudi Arabia has funded hundreds of Madras' religious schools throughout the Muslim world, that are manufacturing jihadist Wahabi/Salafist fundamentalist, destined to sacrifice their lives in exchange for heaven with the 7 virgins.

Saudi Arabia threatened Russia with unleashing Jihadists on Russia's Caucasus region, especiall Chechniya, if Putin didn't drop Assad as an ally. Putin told Prince Bandar, who's idea it was to fund Al-Qaida/ISIS in the first place, to go fuck himself. Putin is also propping up the Assad regime because he made a deal with the Russian Orthodox Church that they would support his election if he helped protect the 2 million (mostly) Eastern Orthodox Arab Christians of Syria.

The bombing of ISIS has not stopped them from conquering Iraqi city after city. They run almost all of Anbar province, and oil rich Mosul.

So the half billion dollars our aerial bombing operations are costing in Iraq and Syria is a total waste of time. That money would be far more beneficial to help the refugees in the region, by far. Harper is a US foreign policy poodle. There is absolutely no benefit for us to participate in US designs in the region. Our last experiment at spreading democracy turned the prosperous Libyan state into a failed state of warring tribes and a new base for ISIS, and a reason for more people to flee war and instability to Europe.
 
That one picture of a child's body washed up on a beach illustrates the ignorance of the suffering that has been going on in Syria for the last 4 years. There are millions of Syrian refugees. The death of children as a result of war and the fleeing of war, in reality, has been repeated thousands of times already. So how come, all of a sudden, the world wants action now, rather than years ago when all this started?

Because people are remarkably adept at ignoring something until it's shoved right in their faces...like what the media did with that picture. People don't like to contemplate that there is a whole lot of misery in the world, nor should they be consumed with that thought. But these calls to arms seem to me like overcompensating or, in the case of our leaders, merely political maneuvering.

We can't solve the world's woes. It doesn't mean we shouldn't always try, but we shouldn't mistake making a knee-jerk decision as being the best course of action.
 
On the other hand, conversation at the national and international level basically takes the form of an exchange of images, and the images that get printed, shared, liked, and retweeted are the ones that strike a chord in no small part because they sum up in a photo what many people would like to say.