Shout your abortion!

Moral standard changes with time. In Victorian era England
it was socially acceptable for a husband to discipline his wife.
Wife beating wasn't against the law provided that the beating
was not too severe and done for good measure. In today's secular
world laws are enacted to protect individual rights and have
no place to enforce moral standard. Abortion for convenience is
morally questionable but the right of the mother supersede
the right of the fetus.
 
Moral standard changes with time. In Victorian era England
it was socially acceptable for a husband to discipline his wife.
Wife beating wasn't against the law provided that the beating
was not too severe and done for good measure. In today's secular
world laws are enacted to protect individual rights and have
no place to enforce moral standard. Abortion for convenience is
morally questionable but the right of the mother supersede
the right of the fetus.



https://www.debunker.com/texts/ruleofthumb.html
 
Is saying no to a sexual proposal murder too? An unborn baby ...

No, it is a FETUS, with no soul according to Christianity, Jewish, and many other religions.

An abortion in a clinic - not the old back alleys - is far safer and less hard on the women's body than pregnancy although the bias Pro-Life false studies that include illegal back alley abortions want you to believe.

It is just like those that proclaim sex work should be illegal since its abuse of women.
 
For the biblical Christian view on abortion, there are many good books available showing that the biblical Christian knows just like the Jews that there is no soul till birth and that the radical anti-women's choice religious zealots are falsely using the bible for their unfounded emotional attachment to a soulless fetus, rather than the mother.

One small concise book I recommend that goes through every biblical passage related to the issue is "The Origin of Human Life" by R.B. Thieme, Jr.

Robert Thieme is a pastor or Berachah Church, Houston, Texas and graduated Summa Cum Lade from Dallas Theological Seminary. His extensive training in Greek, Hebrew, theology, history, and textual criticism became the foundation for his demanding professional life of studying and teaching the Word of God.

Thieme teaches from the original languages of Scripture in the light of the historical context in which the Bible was written. He has recorded thousands of hours or lectures covering the Bible verse by verse. His scholarly, expository approach to so called God's Word (which it really isn't) and the international distribution of his taped sermons and books have made him a major voice in Christianity today.

The book lays to rest the true biblical issue concerning abortion and concludes there is no issue about when the soul enters the body. It confirms the O.T. Jewish view that their is no soul in a fetus and shows how certain scriptures have simply been misunderstood from their English translations. In the original texts, there is no question, there is no soul till birth. This confirms the O.T. teachings that have been known by Jews, for whom, abortion is much less an issue again since God also reveals in the O.T. no soul till birth.

I suggest any Christian, especially the anti-women's choice zealots need to seriously consider the biblical facts this book explains before trying to deny women their right to decide their abortion options. If you don't believe in abortion, don't have one. But you have no biblical basis to try and make your emotional fetal attachment an anti-choice Christian issue.

Sample of Thieme's quotes from
Dissertation: Neshamah: Is There Life In The Womb: A Critical Analysis Of The Teaching Of R.B. Thieme On The Origin Of Life..

Regarding Roe v. Wade:
“ This is one of the wisest and most brilliant decisions that the Supreme Court has made in many, many, many years.”

“ Abortion is a decision between a patient and her doctor.”

“ A pastor has no right to impose his volition on others — that's tyranny from the pulpit... [People must] carefully consider what is taught in the pulpit so they can make their own decision before the Lord... I can't advise whether to abort - [that is] an intrusion of privacy and the freedom of another person.
 
Some liberal Christians are amazing. They believe God
is on their side over conduct deemed by the church to be
immoral over centuries. Obviously evangelicals also think
alike when they are preaching abortion is evil. But
at least those bible thumpers would take the time to find
the right texts in the scriptures to support their agenda. I
would be interested to know where the bible says or hints
abortion is acceptable.

As far as I know the bible never addressed the issue. If I were
a Christian there are quotes I may use to support the
belief that a fetus is a life.

When Elizabeth heard Mary's greeting, the baby leaped in her
womb; and Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit.

(Luke 1:41)

Upon You I was cast from birth; You have been my God from
my mother's womb.

(Psalm 22:10)

"Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, And
before you were born I consecrated you; I have appointed
you a prophet to the nations."

(Jeremiah 1:5)
 
When Elizabeth heard Mary's greeting, the baby leaped in her
womb; and Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit.

(Luke 1:41)

Luke 1:41-43 is often quoted where the fetus leaped in the womb and the Holy Spirit told Elizabeth that Mary was carrying Jesus Christ. Many later stage pregnant women feel fetal movements that they would describe as leaping , this is just normal fetal movement. The fact the Holy Spirit told of the blessed event that was to take place had only to do with foreknowledge not a statement as to the status of a soul currently in the fetus. Often scripture uses poetic or symbolic language to show special points. It can't be used to prove soul in womb, only that Holy Spirit said the fetus was blessed and would become Jesus.

Biblical Overview Of Abortion Issue

The Bible is very clear about the abortion issue. Yet some anti-women's choice advocates quote Bible verses about murder or foreknowledge that have nothing to do with abortion.

The idea that human life begins at conception just isn't supported in the Bible, and sacredness of human life is contradicted all over. So people who consider abortion to be murder might be shocked to learn that they are thereby in disagreement with the Bible!

The only thing that makes human life more precious than animals, bugs, or snakes, is the human spirit/soul God gives at BIRTH. This is clearly both the biblical Christian view and even more clearly and strongly the Jewish view. Why in the world any Christian would try and claim abortion of a soulless fetus is wrong is beyond me. But its about choice. The women's choice which of course means abortion is a legitimate, legal choice and Christians as well as Jews should support that choice. Lets see what the Bible really says about it:

The Bible often identifies life with "breath", (Gen. 2:7) suggesting that life begins at birth, not conception. This has traditionally been the view of Jewish Biblical scholars. For example Ezekiel 37:1-14 suggests this which is consistent with Genesis 2:7. Adam did not become a "living soul" until the "breath of life" entered his nostrils AFTER his body was formed. Other examples are in Joshua 10:40, 1 Kings 15:29 and many others where "breath" is treated as a synonym for "life". In biblical terms it seems clear that life begins at birth, not conception.

Ex 21:22-23 makes it quite clear that the death of fetus is not murder. When in the course of a brawl, a man knocks against a pregnant women so that she has a miscarriage but suffers no further harm (other than the death of the fetus), then the offender must pay whatever fine the woman's husband demands after assessment."

The reason for the payment for miscarriage has to do with the women being the property of her husband. In fact the husband probably had many wives or concubines. A mans status was based on the number of children he had (especially sons). Women were considered breeders, thus the widespread use of concubines, that God never spoke against but seems to have accepted just like polygamy and adultery was only wrong for a married women, never a married man.

Early first trimester abortion seems less of an evil than a man knocking a pregnant women who may have been far further along in pregnancy. This doesn't mean that abortion would have been acceptable to Hebrews since many of their laws were set up to increase fertility. But they would not have considered it murder. Today we have too many unwanted children and we have learn way too well how to be fruitful and multiple. We now need to control and reduce world population - the opposite of Hebrew times.

Even more clear is Numbers 5:21 where God shows letting the fetus die is proper as a punishment of the mother. This is clearly intentional not the accidental event in Exodus.

Even an infant under the age of one month is considered to be worth a lot less than an adult (Leviticus 27:1-8, Numbers 3:15,28,34,39,40,43). Also, the god once punished David by killing his newborn son (II Samuel 12:14-19); so apparently the right-to-life of the infant was not important.

The sanctity of life, born or "unborn", is denied in many places. Two examples: "Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling...." (I Samuel 15:3), "they shall fall by the sword: their infants shall be dashed in pieces, and their women with child shall be ripped up." (Hosea 13:16)

The only NT scripture dealing with abortion is Matthew 26:24 which suggests that it would have been better if Judas had not been born! Note the word is "BORN", not "conceived". The only way to have prevented Judas from being born would have been an abortion. Interesting that abortion is suggested as possibly good here!

Luke 1:15 says he was filled with the Holy Spirit from the moment of birth.
However some bible translations that have a tradition bias falsely translate this as from the womb. However often more recent versions are more honest to the Greek with new earlier texts being found or without the bias/agenda of some of the traditional U.S. Engish versions. For example from http://www.biblegateway.com :

" ... and he will be filled with the Holy Spirit even from birth." NIV-UK version

"He'll be filled with the Holy Spirit from the moment he leaves his mother's womb."- The Message Version

"Even from his birth, he will be filled with the Holy Spirit" - New Life Version

"...and the power of the Holy Spirit will be with him from the time he is born" - Contemporary English Version (CEV)

"He will be filled with the Holy Spirit from the time he is born." - Worldwide English (New Testament) (WE)

"He will be filled with the Holy Spirit from the time he is born." - New International Reader's Version (NIRV)


Gal 1:15 But when it pleased God who separated me from my mothers womb, and called me by His grace... seems the calling was after the separation from the womb. . Or Luke 7:28; Among those who will be born of women there shall not be a greater prophet... (KJ) supports born. Birth is the important point of being a soul, conception is simply first step if not interrupted by normal miscarriage or chosen abortion.

Jeremiah 1:5 says God knew Jeremiah "BEFORE I formed thee". Indicates life begins BEFORE conception! Of course, this whole verse is just a figure of speech indicating that God had foreknowledge that Jeremiah would be a profit just like other passages show foreknowledge was has nothing to do with the abortion issue.

Psalms 139: 13-16 is not talking about a relationship with God while in the womb. It is a poetic verse talking about how God is all knowing. It reveals that God knows all and that God made us in the womb. But God also knew us in our father's loins and even before the world was created. This has nothing to do with abortion. We all know that God knows all and that God made all things. God knew which fetuses will be born (about 50% miscarriage or otherwise die naturally) You can not twist this to mean that God is saying it is wrong to have an abortion. He would have known the fetus didn't make it and was never born.

Luke 1:41,44 has nothing to do with abortion. Elizabeth was six months pregnant. Babies leap in the womb at six months and can be viable. This is beyond the point abortions are done except in rare emergencies.

Psalms 94 likewise has nothing to do with abortion, but does have a lot to do with using the Bible to instill fear and intimidate others who disagree with you.

Note in Gen 25:22 Jacob and Esau "struggled together" in Rebekahs womb. Does this mean they also had personalities that fought before birth? Hardly. Rebekah simply experienced a lot of movement in her womb during pregnancy; later when the brother's fought each other she could look back and say that they even fought when they were in her womb.

If you think God is anti-choice, I suggest you are trying to make God what you think He should be, not what He taught. While no scripture condemns abortion, but shows its no big deal, lots of scripture talks about killing both the born and unborn.

Psalms 137:9 "Happy is he who shall seize your children and dash them against the rock." II Kings 15:16, all the pregnant women were ripped open to kill the fetus as directed by Menahem, king of Israel 748-738 BC. Numbers 31:17-18 where the virgin women are to be taken by the soldiers for themselves and all the other women and children killed. So much for not killing?

Breath = Life is the Biblical View
No matter how emotional fetus loving Christians try and twist scripture to match what they wished it said, the truth is clear: No human life (soul) till first breath at birth. This is the clear biblical view as well as the Jewish view from biblical times and today. There is absolutely nothing in the Bible that says abortion is wrong.

The fact the Bible is silent on the issue may be surprising since abortion was very common. The Bible declares the death penalty for murdering another person but not when a fetus dies since it is not equated with a human person.

In Hebrew the word nephesh means both person and breath. Only after a person is born is nephesh used. In James it was said "for just as the body without breath is dead, so faith without works is dead." Likewise, until birth there is no breath and no spirit.

The Bible does not support anti-choice views. Many Christians realize this. The Religious Coalition For Abortion Rights represents 35 mainline denominations. There phone for information is 202-543-7032. Want is such a tragedy is the number of Christians and others that care so much more for a spiritless fetus, than the women's right to exercise her choice based on HER beliefs, not those of old men in Washington and other trying to act as a pimp over a women's body and trying to justify it by twisting biblical texts.

Example of Abortion in the Bible
There are examples of abortion in the OT as well as in many historic writings of the time and nowhere is anything ever said there is anything wrong with it. There isn't a word about it in the New Testament. Since there are only OT references, the Jewish view is most important.

A direct abortion example in the Sanhedrin is a discussion of what to do with a pregnant women who has been sentenced to death. They conclude she should be beat on the stomach prior to the execution; thereby preventing her from going into labor. It makes no difference how far along she is, the fetus dies with the mother. "I cite this Halacha because it puts the status of the fetus into a Halachic perspective. Even if it could be viable it has no rights unto itself." - Norman Slurzberg

Numbers 5:11-31 Discussion
A mans wife is believed to have gone astray from him and had intercourse with another man, but their is no witness against her so she can not be killed. She is tested by "the water of bitterness that brings the curse." If she has gone astray from her husbands authority and had intercourse with another man, her uterus shall drop, and her womb discharge.

The interpretation seems obvious. If she is guilty and therefore is with child, her uterus shall drop and her womb discharges the fetus. Sounds like an abortion caused by the water of bitterness she if forced to drink. But if she is not pregnant no curse and nothing happens.

Note that only the husband can request that the priests perform the abortion since his wife is simply his property.

Also it should be realized that the man could never be guilty of adultery as long as the women was not married, unlike the married women who committed adultery against her husband. The husband could take as many wives and concubines (breeders) as he wished and it was not adultery as long as the women was not the property of another man

Thus, abortions are approved in case of adultery by the woman. In biblical times, abortions were accomplished through poisoning the woman, clearly a cruel procedure. "The typical abortion methods were to poison the mother (hoping she lived while the fetus died) or to physically abuse the mother's abdomen." (Gilbert) Thus, abortions were not recommended for insubstantial reasons.

Another proof there is no poor innocent child in abortion:
II Sam 12: 8-18
After God gave David many wives and more if he wanted, David also took the wife that belonged to Uriah, the Hittite. The Lord said He would take his wives and give them to his neighbor and "he shall lie with your wives".

The Lord did not kill David for his sin, but said the child must die. "And the LORD struck the child that Uriah's wife bore" On the seventh day the child died.

This would seem to be even worse than abortion, the child was killed after birth. So much for innocent child anti-choice arguments.

Abortion has been known and practiced throughout history, in virtually all cultures and periods of human history. In ancient times, it was performed by a variety of mechanical methods or using herbal abortifacients such as combining pennyroyal with black cohosh or blue cohosh [more detailed accounts and precise methods can be found by going to any search engine, such as http://www.google.com and typing in as required key words: "cohosh blue black pennyroyal abortion"].

RU-486 Pill Similar To Biblical Herbs
The RU-486 pill is in some ways nothing more than modern scientists equivalent to the birth control agents since the days of the early Greeks and Romans, including biblical times. The Washington Post of August 23, 1994 published detailed histories that show some 450 plant species contain natural substances that prevent ovulation, block fertilization, or reduce fertility in some other way. Hippocrates, an ancient Greek physician, prescribed seeds of Queen Anne's Lace as both a contraceptive and as a herbal "morning after pill".

Herbal birth control created much of the wealth of the Greek city-state of Cyrene. Cyrenians collected and exported the sap of the silphion plant. An image of the plant appears on the 5th century BC Cyrenian coins. Roman naturalist Pliny the Elder mentions it. Silphion was so well known that Aristophanes discusses its high cost in one of his plays.

According to the ancient physician Soranus, "Cyreniac Juice", as he called it, when taken by mouth, would prevent conception or induce an abortion, whichever was needed. Other ancient contraceptive remedies in prominent use were products of pennyroyal, rue, willow, date palm, pomegranate, wormwood and myrrh.
 
God of the Old Testament, the God who murdered the
first born sons of Egypt was utterly evil. What part
of those quotes demonstrated that Yahweh or Jehovah
did not stop at killing an unborn baby because
it had no soul not because He was a barbaric God?

Compared with Old Testament atrocities committed by
Moses and Joshua under the auspices of God abortion is
child's play. If you are willing to stoop to the moral standard
of the Old Testament abortion of born or unborn is fine.
 
God of the Old Testament, the God who murdered the
first born sons of Egypt was utterly evil. What part
of those quotes demonstrated that Yahweh or Jehovah
did not stop at killing an unborn baby because
it had no soul not because He was a barbaric God?

Compared with Old Testament atrocities committed by
Moses and Joshua under the auspices of God abortion is
child's play. If you are willing to stoop to the moral standard
of the Old Testament abortion of born or unborn is fine.

Ah but unchanging perfect god is totally different in the New Testament. In the NT he loves humanity so much that he will torture you forever in the most horrific ways if you don't lov... oh, fuck, that's even worse.
 
The law is whats right, everything else is wrong..... or is it that the law is everything that is wrong, everything else is right?

Never mind, but sc, you're right!
Do you understand that there is a difference between law, and right and wrong?
Yet the Supreme Courts in both Canada and the US don't consider abortion to be murder. Deal with it.

Oh yeah this should be comical
To all the pro-abortionists in this thread

If the law says it is right then it is right?
So most of these Libtards arguing with SC are going to have to admit stuff like slavery was cool since law/courts said it was at the time?
Funny how law only applies to subjects a Liberal is interested in isn't it
 
As a matter of fact George Washington and Thomas Jefferson are
glorified to this day as great Americans. Both owned and traded
slaves for their entire life. They were nonetheless considered to be
good men who were 'anti-slavery' in principle and should not be
judged by the moral standard of our time.
 
You know, it's interesting to read this debate. The likelihood of anyone changing the others opinion is very, very small.

Wrt quotes and such from the Bible - and this goes to both sides, you have to remember the time it was written, women were less than men, vicious torture etc., and in theory God was pissed at humankind. Recall Christ's visit to earth was to re-build that bridge. I could go on as you cannot literally interpret it for the world as it is today. It was also written by people.

You also need to keep in mind that it is translated, and that many parts could support either argument.

For me, my choice doesn't lie in a book. It is in my mind and heart. It makes no difference if a fetus / baby has a soul or not.......people kill other people all the time and those people have souls.

God did tell mankind to go and populate the earth.....he didn't put a limit on it either.
 
...
If the law says it is right then it is right?...

After surviving numerous Supreme Court cases, yes (or at least for now).

Sorry but your opinion is only opinion and unless the supreme court judges change their mind, you can't stop women from making their own choices.
 
After surviving numerous Supreme Court cases, yes (or at least for now).

Sorry but your opinion is only opinion and unless the supreme court judges change their mind, you can't stop women from making their own choices.

Oh cmon
Are you actually taking the stance that just because Supreme Court says something that it is right???

There are so many absurd / crazy decisions from them you could write a book

Here is a great one:
Apparently those who live up in the Territories & out in the Maritimes are NOT LEGALLY ALLOWED TO IMPORT ALCOHOL
Yeah you read that right
I can buy alcohol in Quebec and take it to Ontario any day or night
But try to take that same drink into New Brunswick and we have broken the law lol

But Territory are different
Its like crossing the US border despite being located in Canada

Explain that logic for us?
A six-pack of Molson Canadian beer in Yellowknife is $15.10. In Calgary, it goes for $9.

Here is the official Supreme Court decision
https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/17059/index.do
 
Yes. The law is right and you are wrong. As I said, you are entitled to your opinion but you can not stop any woman from doing what she thinks is right.

Law is about the balancing of rights; it's not about moral conduct. You don't understand that difference, hence this discussion is above your pay grade.

If you moved to the Middle East, you'd be the biggest champion of denigrating women, since that is their law. You can't seem to grasp how shallow your argument is.

Base your argument on science and common sense, rather than religion or [bad] law or myopic and biased feminist views, and let us know how it changes.
 
Law is about the balancing of rights; it's not about moral conduct. ....

But it is the law and stands as the official opinion of the country. There are laws I like and laws I don't like but after the depth of scrutiny abortion law has faced in higher courts, it meets the constitution and charter's definition of 'right'.


And it's laughable that you are pretending to care about science.
 
These are harrowing stories from strong women who have made a difference. Share your abortion stories.

8 pregnancies. 3 children. 5 abortions. No regrets.
https://shoutyourabortion.com/writing/8-pregnancies-3-children-5-abortions-no-regrets/
This story in particular comes from an extreme end of the spectrum. Most women I know how have had an abortion very much have regrets, not that they wouldn't make the same decision again, but they certainly don't consider it joyful as does the author, further she frankly seems to have been using abortion as a form of birth control.
 
But it is the law and stands as the official opinion of the country. There are laws I like and laws I don't like but after the depth of scrutiny abortion law has faced in higher courts, it meets the constitution and charter's definition of 'right'.

There are MANY laws that most people are against
A judge is not free to interpret whether a law is just, he is simply applying it

I posted above about alcohol tax, another common one no sane person is for is the digital media tax
Or even marijuana; it was illegal for years, now it is about to become legal. No way majority of population is onboard
 
Dave in Phoenix, for many centuries the position of Christian Churches was that life began at Quickening somewhere between 15 and 20 weeks. Current Roman Catholic doctrine dates only from 1869.