Shouldn't reviews be based on SOMETHING concrete?

How do you feel about "Vendetta boys"?

  • Great! I enjoy the heated pissing matches

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Sometimes entertaining, sometimes boring

    Votes: 1 7.1%
  • Sometimes boring, sometimes annoying

    Votes: 3 21.4%
  • Sometime annoying, sometimes infuriating

    Votes: 1 7.1%
  • I think that TERB has no place for prolonged personal grudges

    Votes: 5 35.7%
  • Words cannot describe how little I care about this poll!!!

    Votes: 4 28.6%

  • Total voters
    14

zog

Friendly Arrogant Bastard
Dec 25, 2002
2,019
0
0
60
Downtown TO
There seems to be an increased trend in some review threads recently for certain people to be carrying vendettas against certain SPs or agencies. I think of these individuals who carry very long grudges and seem to need to post something nasty as often as possible as: Vendetta Boys.

These threads start innocuously enough. Someone posts a review of SP "A" or agency "B" in the Escorts section. There usually follow several posts from other hobbyists who have experienced the same SP. These comments may be agreement or not but usually they start off civil and constructive.

Then, one of the vendetta boys comes along. Every time these people see a review of A or B (or whichever SP or Agency thay happen to have a problem with) they feel the unstoppable urge to post a scathingly negative comment. Even if the actual SP is someone they've never seen, they usually swoop in to get another shot off against the Agency.

What follows such a post is usually a tangential argument between the vendetta boy and a few loyal supporters of the SP or Agency. The thread is ruined for constructive discussion of the original experience, and (IMHO) the board loses out on potential quality of contributions.

I think that it might be worthwhile for the moderators to caution members who are frequent vendetta boys that it is not appropriate to slam an SP or an Agency every chance you get. Make your point in a thread for that purpose and move on. We don't want to hear the same tired complaints from the same pople over and over again. Especially since, in some cases, the vendetta boy's beef is many months old and we've all read about several dozen times.

I know that I have been known to support a few providers quite loyally but you'll also have noticed that it's been quite a while since I've bothered to engage with any vendetta boys.

I am hoping that this thread can remain focused on the issue of repeat negative reviews rather than degenerating into a discussion about specific SPs or Agencies. Let's try to keep the personal grudges away from (at least) this particular discussion.

Thanks,

Zog.
 
I personally think that review threads should be locked and contain only the review. A review should not for discussion, comment or rebuttal in an online forum. That is the crux of the problem right there.

And btw..I voted none of the above..

EBS
 
E_B_Samaritano said:
I personally think that review threads should be locked and contain only the review. A review should not for discussion, comment or rebuttal in an online forum.
EBS

A review is just one man's opinion. Failure to allow discussion, comment or rebuttal could result in a serious injustice being done to the SP being reviewed. I could see cases where you suggestion would work eg: where all reviewers are seasoned veterans who are fully conversant with all aspects of the review process. That is simply not the case here, and we gotta make do with what we have.
 
Fred,

Many discussion sites such as this have reviews in a separate area, often unviewable by the casual surfer to the site. There should be no need to publicly discuss or disect a review. I think its a ridiculous waste of time and leads to just the type of nonconstructive flame wars that are the subject of this thread. Locking the thread on the review is a way to shut down specious commentary. If somebody has a review, let him post it. Otherwise, let him shut the *&%$ up.

EBS
 
Responding to reviews is OK with me...

Actually, I don't have a problem with people adding their constructive contributions to a review thread. There have been many really interesting conversations that started this way.

There should be an opportunity for people to respond to a review, ask questions, or present related experiences of their own. I think it's just that the people contributing should actually be contributing. If you don't have something of value to add, please don't feel obliged to re-post a repetetive complaint or accusation. Just read and keep your peace for a change.

Zog.
 
If you lock the thread after 1 review then people wanting to put in their 2 cents may just decide to start their own thread. Then instead of having 1 thread with 20 replies you may just end up with 20 threads with 1 post each. A particularily popular or unpopular SP could end up with a huge amount of review threads about them all with only one post. Personally If I were looking for Info on a particular SP I'd rather open 1 thread and read the replies than having to open multiple threads. Thats just my personal preference though.
E_B_Samaritano said:
I personally think that review threads should be locked and contain only the review. A review should not for discussion, comment or rebuttal in an online forum. That is the crux of the problem right there.

And btw..I voted none of the above..

EBS
 
Wouldn't locking out the discussions also become a free-for-all for shills? I know they're not as common as some people might think, but without the ability to confirm or question a review, how could you tell if it's accurate? To me, the review is only the start -- it's the subsequent comments that give a feel about the accuracy (at least if you take the fanboys and trolls with a 50lb grain of salt.)
 
I am new to this board but nevertheless I often find the comments after the review to be informative. I agree that sometimes the comments are "vendettas" but I think that intelligent readers can ignore such comments when they occur. Should it not be up to other readers/posters to judge the comments for themselves rather than locking each and ever one?
 
All I have to add is that these people generally are only showing their own inadequacies for all to see. If they hold a grudge it's generally because of some bias, based on something they perceive as a personal attack. Many times the whole agency / MP becomes a a target.

I'm sure most members can discriminate as to who holds a personal grudge as opposed to constructive and objective criticism.

My vote went to "sometimes boring, sometimes annoying", but at the same time these people keep us on our toes so as not to let personal issues cloud our judgement and reveal how "ugly" and sad ( even if it's understandable ) it can be.