Should they bring back conscription?

onthebottom said:
How was the action in the Balkans in US interests? What threat did the Balkans represent to the US? Isn't any military action not ordained by the UN illegal (at least listening to some on this board).
OTB
I'm sure WWI rings a bell with you. Unrest in Europe is not in anyone's interest. I think that you are right about it being a legally gray area, at best. However, given the fact that (1) all of the western traditional allies (i.e. NATO) unanimously supported it (if I recall correctly the only problem with a UN resolution was the Russian veto given the Serbs were a traditional ally), (2) there was a clear exit strategy, (3) if the west had not intervened then, it would have just been a matter of time before they were forced to, (4) there was a clear immediate humanitarian imperative, (5) the reasons given for the war were honest, I would say that it was a very different kittle of fish than Iraq. Nonetheless, I have to admit that I have grown much more understanding of the argument against going in without a UN mandate. It did set a bad precedent.
 
I'll play anti-war liberal in the US for a moment:

someone said:
I'm sure WWI rings a bell with you. Unrest in Europe is not in anyone's interest.

Yes, a very good reason for the EU to get involved, why is this the concern of the US. Surely Europe had FINALLY grown up enough to police it's own continent. Why should some farmer in Iowa loose his only son (or insert other folksy sad story) to some fight on a foreign shore that doesn't threaten the US?

someone said:
I think that you are right about it being a legally gray area, at best. However, given the fact that (1) all of the western traditional allies (i.e. NATO) unanimously supported it (if I recall correctly the only problem with a UN resolution was the Russian veto given the Serbs were a traditional ally)

OK, so if the US and 20 other countries want to take action that's illegal but if all the NATO nations want to take action then it's OK?


someone said:
(2) there was a clear exit strategy,

Now I get it, as long as it's easy it's ok.....

someone said:
(3) if the west had not intervened then, it would have just been a matter of time before they were forced to,

How do you know that, perhaps we just didn't understand them and besides it's an independent country and it's none of our business....

someone said:
(4) there was a clear immediate humanitarian imperative,

Oh, because they're white it makes a difference, didn't see NATO sending troops in mass to Rwanda, now that was a "clear immediate humanitarian imperative"

someone said:
(5) the reasons given for the war were honest, I would say that it was a very different kittle of fish than Iraq. Nonetheless, I have to admit that I have grown much more understanding of the argument against going in without a UN mandate. It did set a bad precedent.

Gee ya think. If France says it's OK then it's OK for the US to send troops.....

That was easy, I can see why so many of you are liberals..... reminds me of my favorite line in "As good as it gets"

Receptionist: "I just have to ask you, how do you write women so well"

Jack Nicholson Character: "I think of a man and remove reason and responsibility"


The perfect description of a liberal....

LOL
 
onthebottom said:
I'll play anti-war liberal in the US for a moment:
Yes, a very good reason for the EU to get involved, why is this the concern of the US. Surely Europe had FINALLY grown up enough to police it's own continent. Why should some farmer in Iowa loose his only son (or insert other folksy sad story) to some fight on a foreign shore that doesn't threaten the US?
That same arguement was made during both world wars.
onthebottom said:
OK, so if the US and 20 other countries want to take action that's illegal but if all the NATO nations want to take action then it's OK?
Come on, you don't believe 1/2 those countries supported the Iraq war for any reason other than getting some U.S. aid.
onthebottom said:
Now I get it, as long as it's easy it's ok.....
If you had ever studied any economics you would know that it is efficient to undertake an action until its marginal cost equals its marginal benefit. However, as a Bush supporter, I would not expect you to understand anything about economics. God, I have even meet MBA students that knew about looking at costs and benefits of actions

onthebottom said:
How do you know that, perhaps we just didn't understand them and besides it's an independent country and it's none of our business....
I can't recall the last time that was a concern of an American president.

onthebottom said:
Oh, because they're white it makes a difference, didn't see NATO sending troops in mass to Rwanda, now that was a "clear immediate humanitarian imperative"
There is also a strong case that the west should have intervenned in Rwanda so I don't know what your point is.

onthebottom said:
That was easy, I can see why so many of you are liberals..... reminds me of my favorite line in "As good as it gets"
If you are using the word in the classical sense it is likely a good discription of me. However, given that you were unfortunate enough to have an American education, I assume that you don't know what the classical meaning is. If you are using it in the modern Americana usage, all I can say is that you don't know what you're talking about if your talking me a liberal. Given that your the one that likes definding American budget deficits, I would remind you about a pot and a kettle.
 
Well, if I made you think twice about it that's good - mission accomplished.

I argue that it set a good precedent. It forced Europe to act when its interests were involved. This is a terribly important point for a fledgling empire to consider.

someone said:
Nonetheless, I have to admit that I have grown much more understanding of the argument against going in without a UN mandate. It did set a bad precedent.
 
someone said:
That same arguement was made during both world wars.

Yes, there were isolationists who thought we didn't belong in a war unless we were directly threatened. We hear that today as well. The wrong side of history in all cases.

someone said:
Come on, you don't believe 1/2 those countries supported the Iraq war for any reason other than getting some U.S. aid.

My point was, does it matter how many countries agree? What is the magic number? I don't think the UK or Australia got much aid out of it.

someone said:
If you had ever studied any economics you would know that it is efficient to undertake an action until its marginal cost equals its marginal benefit. However, as a Bush supporter, I would not expect you to understand anything about economics. God, I have even meet MBA students that knew about looking at costs and benefits of actions

Minor in econ actually, fancy way of saying is the juice worth the squeeze. You're resorting to name calling and generalizations, guess I had it coming after the liberal comment - even though it wasn't targeted at you. There is a difference between if something is right to do and if it's worth doing. That was my point. Your exit strategy comment was just a shot at Iraq.

someone said:
I can't recall the last time that was a concern of an American president.

Just trying to be consistent.


someone said:
There is also a strong case that the west should have intervenned in Rwanda so I don't know what your point is.

See your worth it point. If it is wrong to take action is it wrong to do nothing? Is it wrong to not be prepared for action because you're too selfish?

someone said:
If you are using the word in the classical sense it is likely a good discription of me. However, given that you were unfortunate enough to have an American education, I assume that you don't know what the classical meaning is. If you are using it in the modern Americana usage, all I can say is that you don't know what you're talking about if your talking me a liberal. Given that your the one that likes definding American budget deficits, I would remind you about a pot and a kettle.

Easy, you're getting so mad you're starting to spell like one of your first year students..... I was just having a bit of fun and was not referring to you in particular.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Easy, you're getting so mad you're starting to spell like one of your first year students..... I was just having a bit of fun and was not referring to you in particular.

OTB
I suppose one problem with English is that we don't have a singular and plural “you” to limited such confusion. Perhaps I reacted too strongly, if so I apologize. Anyway, I should get back to work.
 
someone said:
I suppose one problem with English is that we don't have a singular and plural “you” to limited such confusion. Perhaps I reacted too strongly, if so I apologize. Anyway, I should get back to work.



Ya'll is the plural:D
 
papasmerf said:
Ya'll is the plural
You have clearly never lived in Kentucky :D . When I first moved down there I always found it very strange when I would be sitting alone in a restaurant or coffee shop and a server would come over and ask “what can I do for ya’ll”. I was always tempted to look around to find out who else they where talking to.
 
someone said:
You have clearly never lived in Kentucky :D . When I first moved down there I always found it very strange when I would be sitting alone in a restaurant or coffee shop and a server would come over and ask “what can I do for ya’ll”. I was always tempted to look around to find out who else they where talking to.

Ya'll is like deer, one or many.

OTB